-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Most underrated/overrated players in the comp!!
- Thread starter okeydoke7
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I rekon Jacob Surjan is underrated
melbourne150
All Australian
He was pretty bad when he was at collingwood but he was defienitly a good player when at melbourne.
thedaz47
All Australian
underrated:
jordan lewis
daniel merrit
overrated:
carlton's list... not trolling but a lot of carlton's hopes are pinned on bryce gibbs and matt kreuzer one day BECOMING a star or chris judd and what he USED to be able to do. both categories of player have a fair way to go to get up to/back to their full potential and i'm sick of hearing how good these players are. i don't doubt that they will be one day, just not today.
jordan lewis
daniel merrit
overrated:
carlton's list... not trolling but a lot of carlton's hopes are pinned on bryce gibbs and matt kreuzer one day BECOMING a star or chris judd and what he USED to be able to do. both categories of player have a fair way to go to get up to/back to their full potential and i'm sick of hearing how good these players are. i don't doubt that they will be one day, just not today.
Overrated
Porplyzia
Pratt
Birchall
Enright
J.W. Smith
Underrated
Judd
Wells
Thomas
Dal Santo
Goodes
this thread is dumb.
Porplyzia
Pratt
Birchall
Enright
J.W. Smith
Underrated
Judd
Wells
Thomas
Dal Santo
Goodes
this thread is dumb.
BluesRules
Club Legend
Overrated: Dale Thomas, Reiwoldt, Tarrant, Fraser, Hansen (Eagles).
Underrated: B.Fisher, Medhurst, Stanton, Corey
Underrated: B.Fisher, Medhurst, Stanton, Corey
Exactly, but because his names Ablett people are just gonna keep dismissing him. You cannot tell me he isn't as good as Judd was at his best.
winterlover
Cancelled
- Banned
- #35
buckley by a mile; retirement came years too late.
Carlton.No.1
Team Captain
For those who saying Judd is over-rated or dosnt have the same influenece as other players just look at West Coasts record with Judd playing and then without him playing or playing injured.
Most people rank the swans defence the second best, behind Geelong. How is that underated?
Joey Bungle
Team Captain
Oh, not again...Adam Goodes for me. His numbers just don't add up to win the Medal whether he be a ruckman/midfelder/orange boy. If Sydney people say he did, then the standard was pretty low.
As for Judd, I'm concerned he could be the Miss Finland of the AFL.
thedaz47
All Australian
you seriously think that daniel wells and chris judd (probably the highest rated player in the league) are underrated?
thedaz47
All Australian
if these players were rated any higher, you'd swear that the ground they walked on sprouted daisys which sung their praise. definitely overrated imo... with a mild exception in goodes, who i haven't heard as much of lately.
- Banned
- #43
Most overrated players in the comp?
Sheahan, Caro, Hutchy and all the other media parasites who think they are "playas"
In spite of what they think about themselves, they aren't the stars. They are mostly second rate scribblers with heads on 'em like mice (as Newman would say)
Most underrated players in the comp?
Any footballer who has played over 100 games of AFL football, but is not mentioned in Sheahan's Top 50, nor had any threads started about them here on the Big Footy Main Board over the past 24 months.
Everyone talks up the stars and the new kids. Meanwhile there are hundreds of good footballers who get hardly get any credit.
Sheahan, Caro, Hutchy and all the other media parasites who think they are "playas"
In spite of what they think about themselves, they aren't the stars. They are mostly second rate scribblers with heads on 'em like mice (as Newman would say)
Most underrated players in the comp?
Any footballer who has played over 100 games of AFL football, but is not mentioned in Sheahan's Top 50, nor had any threads started about them here on the Big Footy Main Board over the past 24 months.
Everyone talks up the stars and the new kids. Meanwhile there are hundreds of good footballers who get hardly get any credit.
i was referring to ur post, about the comedian crap.. and i wasnt tryna be funny
Thedaz47, please, if you are going to name our own players in a thread can you please spell their names right!?
thedaz47
All Australian
ha ha, go me... see my signature for my nick name at footy and further explanation lol
LeisureSuitLori
Debutant
Let this be a lesson to people who are thinking about sniffing glue before replying to a thread.
thedaz47
All Australian
re-read your post... clearly no one is perfect, just ask danien merrit
but the way you have got overrated and underrated the wrong way around followed by this thread is stupid would allude to the fact that you were trying to be funny. my bad.
btw totally agree if your overrated group and underrated swap.
Accepted 04
Cancelled
- Dec 10, 2007
- 1,334
- 1,290
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Overated:
Franklin
Thomas
Robertson
Grant (North Melb)
Underated:
Foley
Mitchell
Bock
Adcock
Franklin
Thomas
Robertson
Grant (North Melb)
Underated:
Foley
Mitchell
Bock
Adcock
