NEUTRALS who is a better triple premiership captain?

Who is a better triple premiership captain (whole career)?

  • T Cotchin

    Votes: 15 7.7%
  • L Hodge

    Votes: 44 22.4%
  • M Voss

    Votes: 137 69.9%

  • Total voters
    196

Remove this Banner Ad

Who is a better player out of (whole career):

T Cotchin

L Hodge

M Voss

IF YOU SUPPORT RICHMOND, HAWTHORN or BRISBANE you CANNOT vote.

If you like you can rank them 1-3 and give your reasons
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Hodge because Hawthorn went the old classic priority pick route and didn’t have financial assistance to keep their list together.
Voss
Cotchin
 
Trent Cotchin has always given off Cameron Ling vibes.

Premiership captains but objectively ordinary footballers.
 
Still think guys like Pendlebury, Pavlich and Nick Riewoldt are better captains than Trent Cotchin.

Could even argue Tex because the poor bloke must be the only or one of very few to captain a club through the death of a coach.
 
I'd probably have the two that weren't knocked out of finals by Mason Cox 1-2
 
I voted Voss but all 3 are great premiership captains. All led by example.

Those posters on here belittling Cotchin clearly did not watch him play. He threw himself into each contest without regard for his welfare as did Voss and Hodge. All 3 were great leaders.
 
Last edited:
Voted Voss, but strongly considered Hodge.

Cotchin is a bit of a laughable comparison

How often has the GOAT captain and the overall GOAT - period - played together on the same side though?

Case closed.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Yeah but where would you put it?

#inception
Freak Out Reaction GIF
 
As a player

1 Voss 2 Hodge 3 Cotchin. No contest.

Captaincy
1. Voss 2.Cotchin 3 Hodge

As captains Voss & Cotchin had tougher tasks than Hodge , insipring a new merged club and a club starved of success for 37 years (and very few finals campaigns as well) to success. Hodge led a very succesful club, though perhaps he may had to do a balancing act between Clarko and the players.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

NEUTRALS who is a better triple premiership captain?

Back
Top