Thats what im stuck on. I really want Bartel in my team, but the extra 100k is practically a second upgrade.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
(New) Player Comparison Thread
- Thread starter chrisknights
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Thats what im stuck on. I really want Bartel in my team, but the extra 100k is practically a second upgrade.
Kornes or Thompson
personally id go Kornes, he'll give ya 90 ever week just about guarenteed.
- Banned
- #230
I figured something like that too but I need a big scorer for this recplacement and Kornes hurting his shoulder worries me. I plan on upgrading Andy Otten who has never disappointed me this season being the most consistant rookie and if I plan on upgrading him then I want a big point bonus. I get a feeling Adam Goodes will fire against the Hawks and get a lot of big scores... but at the same time, I'm not sure, I don't see Adam Goodes too much. Nick Dal Santo is going to have Brady Rawlings chained to him this week so I figured I'd avoid him, Thompson though looks good, I am a bit worried about his consistancy as he tends to score absolute rubbish on occasions but he's certainly capable of racking in big scores.
- May 8, 2008
- 2,517
- 5
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Chelsea/MVFC
Sweet midfield.
Loud Eagle
Senior List
Kornes or Salopek
Kane
My question is Lockyer and Gia + 40k verse Enright and Leon Davis.
Will Davis be affected by the return of Didak.
Likewise will Gia be affected by the return of Robert Murphy?
Loud Eagle
Senior List
Loud Eagle
Senior List
Didak but in a week or 2
( I want to change this week).Yea thats what i was thinking. Didak may get the high scores but is coming back from injury thus making him more risky. Gia is the safer, but could playing melbourne get didak back into form??
H.Shaw +10K or Mackie, Shaw avging 89 since coming back in round 7, looks like not getting a tag, Mackie coming off a 100, however will his role change again seeing as though Harley is out for a couple of weeks?
I think you might get the bad score now and then from mackie but his scores will get better as the rest of the team start to come back to full power ie. Harley,ablett and Corey fit. He is also in a team that is goin to win alot more games and alot more football than Collingwood who could very easily miss out on the 8 this year. With Shaw you have to worry about injury, tagging(if he keeps up some form) and off field stuff. I think both have the same scoring potential but shaw has alot more risk, but with that being said collingwood have just got alot of stars back and sould pick up some form and you would think that leon davis,swan or didak would get the tag first on current form so you could go for either play but i would personally go for mackie just seems safer with he same upside.
Pirelli_223
Draftee
- Apr 8, 2009
- 17
- 0
- AFL Club
- Essendon
As a 6th / 7th forward what are people's thoughts on Fevola?
His price has dropped and he seems to be posting some decent scores the past few weeks... Is injury still a concern?
Am I better off with a ROK / Didak / Franklin... Franklin has been rubbish most of the year and Didak is still a bit of an unknown quantity.
Opinions appreciated!
Thanks,
His price has dropped and he seems to be posting some decent scores the past few weeks... Is injury still a concern?
Am I better off with a ROK / Didak / Franklin... Franklin has been rubbish most of the year and Didak is still a bit of an unknown quantity.
Opinions appreciated!
Thanks,
Dimitri_Mishkin
Team Captain
What do people think about Salopek?
Im thinking of doing 2 trades this week (Chad and Zaha upgrade), and the only way I get Goddard is to get a midfielder around $330,000...and Salopek looks the best option there (maybe knights, power, cooney)
Can he manage 95+ for the year? Is he a worry injury wise?
Thanks
Im thinking of doing 2 trades this week (Chad and Zaha upgrade), and the only way I get Goddard is to get a midfielder around $330,000...and Salopek looks the best option there (maybe knights, power, cooney)
Can he manage 95+ for the year? Is he a worry injury wise?
Thanks
He is a risk but I think he is worth it. In 2007 he played 13 games, in 2008 he played 15 games so he is a bit of a worry. His scores before getting injured were great (84, 102, 108, 104, 103, 115) so I definitely think he can average 95+ from here.What do people think about Salopek?
Im thinking of doing 2 trades this week (Chad and Zaha upgrade), and the only way I get Goddard is to get a midfielder around $330,000...and Salopek looks the best option there (maybe knights, power, cooney)
Can he manage 95+ for the year? Is he a worry injury wise?
Thanks
Dimitri_Mishkin
Team Captain
formula16
Senior List
- Apr 21, 2009
- 253
- 11
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
o'keefe looks like a sure bet with hall and oloughlan back he'll play his usual role
ablett/bartel vs kornes + 100k?
i alreadly have 600k in bank if that makes a difference?
jezza you beauty
Senior List
Im looking to do the same, decide between Gia or Okeefe, or maybe even Lids.
When looking at Gia, and his recent 120 score, has anyone else noticed that whilst Gia did well, Aker had a terrible game. What happens when Aker returns to form (as he has most of the season). Dont they play a similar role, along with BJ?
As for Deledio, im not confident on any tigers at the moment.
Im probably leaning towards O'Keefe for safety, although i think Gia could be just as good if not better, but with a little more risk. I'll probably sit on the fence until right before lock out, friday afternoon. Would love to hear more oppinions on comparing these forwards.
Similar threads
- Sticky
