news: Tiger Coughlan suffers minor knee setback

Remove this Banner Ad

SteveRFC

All Australian
Dec 13, 2007
892
766
Canberra
AFL Club
Richmond
INJURY-plagued Richmond midfielder Mark Coughlan will miss this weekend's NAB Cup clash with Fremantle due to soreness in his right knee, but the club says preliminary indications are that it is not a serious problem.

The 2003 best-and-fairest has had two knee reconstructions which led to chronic hamstring issues, injuries which have combined to keep him sidelined since round 12, 2006.

Coughlan looked good in the club's intra-club match last Thursday, but felt soreness in the knee today.

Richmond's football operations manager Ross Monaghan said the club was taking a cautious approach, despite it not appearing to be a major problem.

"Mark was just doing some light training and goal kicking this morning, just a little bit of twisting and turning, nothing unusual, and it turns out he's slightly damaged his cartilage," he told richmondfc.com.au on Tuesday night.

"It's not severe – it's being checked out by a specialist either later on tonight or first thing in the morning.

"Probably the worst-case scenario would be an arthroscope and missing two or three weeks, I would guess.

"It's early stages, but it's nothing to do with the knee problems he's had in the past – there's no reconstruction required, nothing like that.

"So it's not a massive alarm bell, it's just a little bit of a setback for him."

Monaghan said everyone at the club was amazed at how well Coughlan had worked through his series of injuries, and said he expected that Coughlan would be available for selection in round one of the season proper.

"He's been amazing in the amount of work he's done to get back to the stage he's at, and everyone was just looking forward to him having a game this week," Monaghan said.

"He got through last week's practice game with no problems at all, and this little incident has occurred.

"But like I say, it's not a tragedy. It's certainly disappointing for him and everyone else involved, but we're hoping he'll be back as good as gold in a few weeks time.

"Two to three weeks is probably worst-case scenario, so he's still every chance of playing in the last round or two of the NAB Cup, and being right for round one, so we can certainly say that's still a possibility."

Coughlan had successful treatment on his troublesome hamstring in Germany last season, which allowed him to return to the track with Coburg for the last few games of the year, and that success had flowed through into the pre-season.

Just three weeks ago he was looking forward to his first AFL game in nearly three years, and declared: "It's pretty exciting – I've done most of the pre-season, and I'm just trying to get through the rest of January now and hopefully put my hand up for that first game against Fremantle over there.

"I'm feeling pretty good in the body - this year's just been a bonus, being able to do a pre-season and the group's looking pretty good for the year, so I'm pretty excited about maybe being a part of that."
 
thats bad, but thankfully no major damage done. Hopefully we see him up and running for the start of the season.:thumbsu:
 

Log in to remove this ad.

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Do you even know what that expression means??? Your post doesnt make any sense. :confused:

Youre suggesting he's a total loser and Cogs is far from it.

But as for the article, "slightly damaged his cartilage" does sound ominous.

Mate, I'd be careful having a go at someone elses post - when maybe it's you that doesn't understand the expression :)

Bad news for Cogs - fingers crossed!
 
Another article on it:

0,,6480829,00.jpg

Richmond footballer Mark Coughlan lame again

Rebecca Williams | February 11, 2009 12:00am

RICHMOND midfielder Mark Coughlan suffered minor knee cartilage damage at training yesterday.

Tigers football manager Ross Monaghan said it would delay Coughlan's start to the season by three weeks. Monaghan said the injury could require minor arthroscopic surgery.

The 2003 best-and-fairest was aiming to return in the NAB Cup clash against Fremantle on Sunday at Subiaco after more than two years in the football wilderness. "At this stage we think it is only minor cartilage damage," Monaghan said.

Coughlan, 26, had back-to-back knee reconstructions in 2006 and 2007 before hamstring injuries ruined his comeback hopes. His last AFL game was Round 12, 2006.

"It's really disappointing for Mark, but compared to the other injuries he has had, this is a relatively minor one," Monaghan said.

"It's disappointing because he was looking forward to playing in Perth in Sunday."

The Tigers will take a strong line-up to Perth, with senior stars Matthew Richardson, Nathan Brown and Troy Simmonds all making the trip.

Despite the travel, Monaghan said the key trio didn't want to be rested. "They were pretty keen to have a run and we were pretty keen to field a reasonably strong side," he said.

Monaghan said Ben Cousins had pulled up well from his hitout in last week's intraclub match. "He just needs a little bit more conditioning. Our aim is to play him in Round 2 of the NAB Cup," he said

Kane Johnson, Trent Cotchin and Jordan McMahon will miss

Link
 
Do you even know what that expression means??? Your post doesnt make any sense. :confused:

Youre suggesting he's a total loser and Cogs is far from it.

But as for the article, "slightly damaged his cartilage" does sound ominous.


WTF you on about :confused:
 
seriously if i was him i would retire, hey?

there really isnt much point playing again, its not like he's going to be much of a player anymore when he or if he comes back

very few players are the same after a knee reco

but 2 consecutive?

hamstring related complications

and now this

i'd throw in the towel. do something else with my life

sometimes things arent meant for you: case and point- michael clark the former fremantle and collingwood player, had millions of injuries in his footy career, had a go at cricket, had a million injuries trying that.

he just wasnt meant to play sport
 
Seriously, if I was him, I'd keep trying.

Quitting in his case is the easy way out. Mentally hes strong enough - proven. Hes in great physical shape. He could have easily gone back over to the West when he was playing some of the best footy of his career but instead, he stayed a Tiger. And, it looked like he had a huge future ahead of him.

If Lance Armstrong quit cycling after he had cancer, would he have won the Tour De France (the most grueling physical sporting challenge there is) again after beating it? No.
 
Seriously, if I was him, I'd keep trying.

Quitting in his case is the easy way out. Mentally hes strong enough - proven. Hes in great physical shape. He could have easily gone back over to the West when he was playing some of the best footy of his career but instead, he stayed a Tiger. And, it looked like he had a huge future ahead of him.

If Lance Armstrong quit cycling after he had cancer, would he have won the Tour De France (the most grueling physical sporting challenge there is) again after beating it? No.

Lance wouldnt have won Le Tour though if he had massive knee problems. The previous poster has a point, you are a long time retired, the more operations etc one has, the more problems (arthritis) are to be expected in the future.

But hey, most kids in our country growing up wanting to play in the AFL, Cogs is living the dream, if he can get himself back on the park.

I reckon though, if he cant get himself right this year, then that will be it, the club will probably make the decision for him. Which would be a tragedy.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

news: Tiger Coughlan suffers minor knee setback

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top