Exactly is a great ‘forward’, couldn’t believe AFLW fantasy listed her as a midfielder, absolutely ruined my plans when selecting my team.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
News Non-Crows AFLW 2024
- Thread starter cmndstab
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Drugs Are Bad Mackay?
Moderator
- May 24, 2006
- 79,354
- 160,485
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Redbacks, Sturt, Liverpool, Arizona
- Moderator
- #52
Saints impressive
Moved the ball with some speed
Moved the ball with some speed
I never rated them, but Gold Coast are meant to be a tough matchup. Smashed them. Wardlaw in great form.
What has happened to the bulldogs? Wow.
Also Brisbane a big loss to North. Didn't pick that. Saw a bit of the game - Brisbane can't exit a stoppage with the ball, anywhere. Eventually North get it. Weird stuff.
I haven't admittedly paid any serious attention to North before, but watching #6 O'loughlin - she's very good. Dancing around everybody. Looks like she's just hitting that prime age of her career as well.
Also Brisbane a big loss to North. Didn't pick that. Saw a bit of the game - Brisbane can't exit a stoppage with the ball, anywhere. Eventually North get it. Weird stuff.
I haven't admittedly paid any serious attention to North before, but watching #6 O'loughlin - she's very good. Dancing around everybody. Looks like she's just hitting that prime age of her career as well.
Totally unnecessary. As if she didn't hear the siren. Even if she did, unnecessary.
Bottom of the ladder last year. Traded out some experienced players. Apparently they lost 11 players through trade/movement/delisting. That's a third of their list.
- Thread starter
- #58
Also, reading between the lines, the club has not been taking their AFLW program seriously. Burke was doing essentially everything and the club was not resourced properly.
Stuff like this is pretty damning:
https://www.afl.com.au/aflw/news/12...ey-issues-that-plagued-lowly-western-bulldogs
Stuff like this is pretty damning:
https://www.afl.com.au/aflw/news/12...ey-issues-that-plagued-lowly-western-bulldogs
Last edited:
- Thread starter
- #59
There is a new dedicated AFLW show airing weekly on 7plus, and I decided to watch the debut episode this week. Don't think I'll bother watching it again. Very Victorian-focused, looks like it was produced on a non-existent budget, and super shallow in its analysis.
They spent all show teasing that they would announce the round 1 rising star nomination (which ended up being Shineah Goody). Finally, with literally 30 seconds of airtime left they came back with the following deep and insightful commentary:
Abbey Holmes: Welcome back to Talking W!
They flash up a still screen showing Goody's stats, no footage of the game
Abbey Holmes: It is our pleasure to finish the show this week by announcing the Telstra W rising star nominee for round 1, and it is Port Adelaide's debutant in Shineah Goody being nominated this week, collecting a handy 15 disposals and a goal in the Showdown. That's very exciting for her, round 1 rising star?
Ben Brown: Absolutely. Fantastic.
Abbey Holmes: Thank you so much for joining us on Talking W! We will see you next Monday!
Yeah, probably not though.
They spent all show teasing that they would announce the round 1 rising star nomination (which ended up being Shineah Goody). Finally, with literally 30 seconds of airtime left they came back with the following deep and insightful commentary:
Abbey Holmes: Welcome back to Talking W!
They flash up a still screen showing Goody's stats, no footage of the game
Abbey Holmes: It is our pleasure to finish the show this week by announcing the Telstra W rising star nominee for round 1, and it is Port Adelaide's debutant in Shineah Goody being nominated this week, collecting a handy 15 disposals and a goal in the Showdown. That's very exciting for her, round 1 rising star?
Ben Brown: Absolutely. Fantastic.
Abbey Holmes: Thank you so much for joining us on Talking W! We will see you next Monday!
Yeah, probably not though.
jenny61_99
Premium Platinum
Taylor Harris out for rest of season with a shoulder injury.
jenny61_99
Premium Platinum
That's a shame. I thought she'd be good.
It’s just the same half-arsed short little basic show that was on channel 9 on Sunday’s after the Sunday footy show in previous years, just jumped channels.
Jeez, caught some of the Dogs/Port game and not new information but the Dogs are so far behind in most facets of the game at the moment. They deadset look like they’re a new expansion team this season, more damning is they are making it look like Nathan Burke was not actually one of their main problems.
Last edited:
TubbsFarquhar
TheBrownDog
They won't win a game this season.
Watched all the 2nd half, I’ve seen some poor teams at this level over the previous 8 seasons including GWS a few years ago, West Coast for a couple of years after they came in and Sydney in their first year but agree I don’t think I’ve seen a worse team than this Bulldogs side is currently, they might fluke something later in the season if their opposition totally f-up but their last 2 weeks have been nothing short of abysmal, actual dragging down the league bad.
I don’t like this kind of criticism of footballers in this league & sure it was a little greasy due to some pre-match rain and Port as they showed last week are a tough pressuring side but if you told someone before the game that the Bulldogs forward line was made up of players from overseas who discovered the game only a couple of months ago they would probably believe you, honestly do they have a head of womens football down there yet? surely they’d be wondering what the coaches have actually been doing these past few months.
- Thread starter
- #66
Yes, going to be a very long season for them. So far they've played the 15th and 16th sides from last season for two losses and a percentage of 12.5%(!)
- Thread starter
- #67
Yes, they reminded me of the GWS side from 2017. Just no system at all and very few players with any business even playing at the level.
They do have a head of women's football now, Patrice Berthold, as of March this year. They lost a whole heap of players and coaches in the interim though.
I know nothing about Patrice Berthold. According to the press release she's a former cricketer who then went on to lead Cricket Australia's operations team working with the men and women.
- Thread starter
- #68
Daisy's Eagles struggling against Essendon this week, down 3 goals to 0 midway through the second quarter. It should have been 4 goals to 0, but a goal after the quarter time siren was disallowed for, as far as I can tell, no reason whatsoever? The official explanation is that she moved off her line on the set shot, but the replay shows she absolutely didn't, and the umpire on the mark made no signal at all. Maybe she took too long to take her kick?
Who knows. The umpiring in the AFLW is pretty terrible. An Essendon player got a free kick at a ruck contest for a shepherd against Wafker. She barely touched her arm. Can you shepherd someone with the force? I've seen free kicks paid for holds which were barely holds, but then you see other players continually held at contests.
- Thread starter
- #70
Port's captain Cuthbertson out with an ACL injury now 
Tough break. Just turned 34. Could be the end of her career?Port's captain Cuthbertson out with an ACL injury now
- Thread starter
- #72
Certainly a reasonable chance of it. She's had some pretty serious injuries previously, too.
Crows played them last year. We also had West Coast and GWS last year. Brisbane didn't get to play any of these bottom teams, but won the flag. They had a much tougher draw.
