Oppo Camp Non-Eagles Discussion

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Honestly get stuffed North. If it weren’t for no interchange infringement we could win tonight and Reid would be safe. As well as that now they win just as I had accepted and moved on the Pick 1 possibility. Feels wrong wanting to lose, arhhhh
 
Last edited:
JHF was a consensus #1 and well clear of the next. Would you live with us tanking the Adelaide game if the same happened with our #1?

Anyway, maybe we are arguing in circles and not really relevant anyway as I am sure the team is going to give their all tonight. And if we lose, we lose.

I never really understood why people preferred JHF to Daicos, except for his height and feeling like he could become a Cripps/Fyfe-type tall midfielder. From memory, Daicos was a even or slightly ahead of JHF going into their draft season and then put up video game numbers (averaging 36 disposals and 2 goals). I think everybody just got kind of bored with Daicos because he had been highly regarded forever and everyone knew that he’d end up at Collingwood. But he was always the best player in that class, for mine.
 
I never really understood why people preferred JHF to Daicos, except for his height and feeling like he could become a Cripps/Fyfe-type tall midfielder. From memory, Daicos was a even or slightly ahead of JHF going into their draft season and then put up video game numbers (averaging 36 disposals and 2 goals). I think everybody just got kind of bored with Daicos because he had been highly regarded forever and everyone knew that he’d end up at Collingwood. But he was always the best player in that class, for mine.
Daicos is a gun and plays to his strengths but he's a bit of a squib and quite possibly this is his ceiling. Of course, you'd take that any day of the week but he'd want to find his contested side over the next few years, otherwise he'll get shut out of games quite easily.

JHF will probably be able to throw Port on his back and carry them to wins in the future, despite whatever attention he receives.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Won't we too disappointed if we lose tonight(unless we get smashed) but I sure as s**t will be cheering a win.
Last week I was gonna watch the game on kayo after I found out the result but 5 mins before the game ended some woman in the street mentioned Eagles are winning . It was good watching it afterwards because I didn't have to hope we lose .
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I never really understood why people preferred JHF to Daicos, except for his height and feeling like he could become a Cripps/Fyfe-type tall midfielder. From memory, Daicos was a even or slightly ahead of JHF going into their draft season and then put up video game numbers (averaging 36 disposals and 2 goals). I think everybody just got kind of bored with Daicos because he had been highly regarded forever and everyone knew that he’d end up at Collingwood. But he was always the best player in that class, for mine.

JHF was available, Daicos wasn't, it impacts how people view players. GWS didn't bid on him either. They bid on Darcy and took Callaghan so they didn't even rate him in the top 3. My gut feel is if JHF didn't have a hardon to go number one we would have bid on Daicos, similar to Ashcroft last year.

I don't know if it is justified or not, but people see the type of X-factor with JHF that is a bit like Dusty, there are very good midfielders who beat Dusty 80-90% of the game only to have him turn on a 10-15 minute period where he would blow open the game and kick 3 or 4 goals. How do you quantify that with someone who just performs at a very high standard consistently, Richmond didn't achieve success until they got Prestia and they weren't reliant on Dusty as a nuts and bolts midfielder.

I think there is a lot more expectation on his shoulders than there was at Dusty at the same age... that being said, he has contributed towards that spotlight to some degree.
 
Mate, we both want the Eagles to win games of Football.
It sounds like you want the Eagles to win every game, I'm happy to settle for the Eagles winning Grand Finals specifically.
I believe that the #1 pick gets us closer to a flag than chairing Shuey/Hurn off in a win & pick 3.
We might have to agree to disagree.
you win every game you win the grand final
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top