Oppo Camp Non-Eagles Discussion

[briztoon]

His first Brownlow was deserved - he was immense that year. His second Brownlow...

It was a make up, for losing to Cripps the year before, when he had a significantly better season than his first Brownlow season, and Cripps got off of his ban for almost killing Ah Chee on a legal technicality.

 

[KERRPOW]

Id put neale ahead of wines, priddis and woewodin.

 

[happy_eagle]

Id put neale ahead of wines, priddis and woewodin.

Don't forget Adam Cooney

 

[KERRPOW]

Don't forget Adam Cooney

Lol yes true.

 

[FKASC]

And Mitchell, Cotchin

 

[Truckosaurus]

Jobe Watson the worst midfielder to not win a Brownlow

 

[TY24]

Genuine question, not 'aving a laugh, but dose a delisted player like Matt Taberner still count as a listed player?

I would assume so, as he's is probably still considered on the Freo list for this season.

Playing contracts expire on October 31 I’m pretty sure. He’s still on the list until then, ‘being de-listed’ simply means he isn’t getting a new contract once his current one expires.

 

[Mr Eagle]

Thinks his waste is awesome, wants other people to agree.

That answer does not begin to scratch the surface of my

 

[Smeg Head]

Priddis should be a dual brownlow winner if not for the gutless league bitching out of suspending a certain despite multiple incidents.

 

[Bender_]

Priddis should be a dual brownlow winner if not for the gutless league bitching out of suspending a certain despite multiple incidents.

His follow-up year was far better than his winning year too.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

The counter-argument is that he's probably lucky to have one medal as he wasn't ever the best player in the comp.

I feel pretty similar about Neale tbh. Fantastic footballer, elite, but the idea that he could be a 3-time Brownlow medal winner at the end of the night really boggles my mind.

Especially when Bont has 0.

 

[bzparkes]

The counter-argument is that he's probably lucky to have one medal as he wasn't ever the best player in the comp.

I feel pretty similar about Neale tbh. Fantastic footballer, elite, but the idea that he could be a 3-time Brownlow medal winner at the end of the night really boggles my mind.

Especially when Bont has 0.

Bont's not consistent enough over an entire season.

The fault of that lays squarely on Beveridge's feet though. Stuffs him around a fair bit

 

[Broken_Chairs]

Daisy Thomas is an absolute potato, who gave him a hosting/commentating job?

 

[THE A5]

The counter-argument is that he's probably lucky to have one medal as he wasn't ever the best player in the comp.

I feel pretty similar about Neale tbh. Fantastic footballer, elite, but the idea that he could be a 3-time Brownlow medal winner at the end of the night really boggles my mind.

Especially when Bont has 0.

Hence why I stopped watching the brownlow years ago.

 

[MrWoollie]

The counter-argument is that he's probably lucky to have one medal as he wasn't ever the best player in the comp.

I feel pretty similar about Neale tbh. Fantastic footballer, elite, but the idea that he could be a 3-time Brownlow medal winner at the end of the night really boggles my mind.

Especially when Bont has 0.

There certainly would be a very small cohort that would rate Neale (good though he is) as remotely close to as good a player as Bont.

And I doubt that even very few Brisbane supporters wouldn't swap Neale for Bont in a heartbeat.

 

[Keys]

Opening monologue for the Brownlow and they’ve already chucked in a 125 year GF repeat

The two northern states competing in a GF should be something for the AFL to actually celebrate but they still have to drag it back to a Victorian reference point

 

[Spange]

they just can’t let it go. Like who gives a **** about the 1959 nba team the Cincinnati Royals. I’ll tell you who. Nobody!

If the afl want to get new fans then celebrate the most recent events. Don’t think anybody really cares about matches 125 years ago or if Essendon have won 16 vfl flags.

 

[Bleedblueandgold]

It's probably still 2 Victorian teams in the GF for them.

 

[Ambrose Burnside]

Every time they show our match highlights at the Brownlow it's just going to be Harley highlights, isn't it?

Not against

 

[Goroyals22]

There certainly would be a very small cohort that would rate Neale (good though he is) as remotely close to as good a player as Bont.

And I doubt that even very few Brisbane supporters wouldn't swap Neale for Bont in a heartbeat.

Sorry Neale is a vastly superior player to Bomt over a length of time.. Neale can string a consistent season together… Bont has the odd stand out game but then is average for the next couple of weeks…

Bont is a bigger match winner no doubt but Neale is the better player.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[eaglespremiers]

Id put neale ahead of wines, priddis and woewodin.

He's quite a distance behind Pendlebury or Bontempelli though who haven't won a Brownlow between then.

 

[KERRPOW]

Daisy Thomas is an absolute potato, who gave him a hosting/commentating job?

I read somewhere that he was a commentary talent....what?

 

[UseR2006]

All this talk of Bont and he's on 4 points lol

 

[ghostbat12]

All this talk of Bont and he's on 4 points lol

its tough when you have 32 possessions, kick goals and get zero Brownlow points.

afl has completely lost the plot not allowing umpires to look at possessions. they are umpires for goodness sake, not game analysts!!!!

 

[UseR2006]