No Oppo Supporters OPPOSITION OBSERVATION XXXVI

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

If it was out on the full would it have been a free? If yes, then this should have been a free.
campaigner kicked it 2 seconds before the siren , its delibrate and a free kick on goal after the siren
 
campaigner kicked it 2 seconds before the siren , its delibrate and a free kick on goal after the siren

If it’s not on the full if it lands out after the siren then this isn’t deliberate. It’s a question of exactly when is the ball considered dead.

Don’t have a problem with the decision if our on the full wouldn’t have counted either.
 
If it’s not on the full if it lands out after the siren then this isn’t deliberate. It’s a question of exactly when is the ball considered dead.

Don’t have a problem with the decision if our on the full wouldn’t have counted either.
whatever

all I know is freo wouldve been having a shot to win the game after the siren if they were playing Richmond
 
whatever

all I know is freo wouldve been having a shot to win the game after the siren if they were playing Richmond
Can't even count the amount of times we've been screwed against those campaigners in close games
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

If it’s not on the full if it lands out after the siren then this isn’t deliberate. It’s a question of exactly when is the ball considered dead.

Don’t have a problem with the decision if our on the full wouldn’t have counted either.
I think its actually when the umpire calls it not when it goes over
 
If it’s not on the full if it lands out after the siren then this isn’t deliberate. It’s a question of exactly when is the ball considered dead.

Don’t have a problem with the decision if our on the full wouldn’t have counted either.
The ball is dead when it comes to a stop. If that bounces through for a goal it’s a goal. The action happened before the siren it should have been a free. Once again a murky interpretation, next week they’ll probably pay it
 
The ball is dead when it comes to a stop. If that bounces through for a goal it’s a goal. The action happened before the siren it should have been a free. Once again a murky interpretation, next week they’ll probably pay it

So the rule says it’s not out on the full unless it lands before the siren. There’s a thread on the main board

For mine that means for the sake of the boundary line, the ball is deemed dead as soon as the siren goes. Based on that interpretation the umpire made the correct decision because he considered the siren to occur before the ball went out of play and since it can’t go out of play, it can never technically be deliberate. But naturally the umpire was actually wrong, as the ball was well out when the siren went and it should have been a free to Freo
 
Can't even count the amount of times we've been screwed against those campaigners in close games
Highlight of David Mundy's illustrious career was kicking 2 goals after the siren to sink us. Meanwhile we casually jagged 3 more premierships in that time while the Freo cabinet makes the Saints cabinet look plentiful by comparison.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top