Oppo Camp Opposition Watch

Remove this Banner Ad

Jirik13 said:
Very rarely draftees have adequate muscles mass. Always remember how skinny Fyfe was or even Lynch if you look at their draft picture. From your list I personally would not consider any player skinny Flanker. Lemmens, McPherson, Wigg, Shoenfeld are close to optimal body, muscle. Ballard drafted was 83 kg, as Scrimshaw. In a 1-2 years both will be 90kg with developed bodies.
Heron as a small forward has actually the best body from our draftees.
Click to expand...
That is my point , if you continue to top up 18 years ,whether they are GC academy or other draftee you going to end up light Weight in your overall list .

Barlow , Hall, Lynch , Rosa will not be easy to replace, not forgetting last year Ablett , Matera and Saad .
 
Last edited:
Jirik13 said:
JOM, Bowes, Ah Chee not skinny Flankers for me. The rest I would say yes.
Click to expand...
That isn't the point. People smear Scott Clayton as the guy who recruits "skinny flankers" who can't tackle, but I just listed 8 players who both fit that loose category, yet many of his picks have eventually blossomed into specialist positions.

Have a look at Alastair Lynch's All-Clayton team in 2008.


B: Lindsay Gilbee, Brian Lake, Ryan Griffin;

HB: Chris Scott, Justin Leppitsch, Nigel Lappin;

C: Daniel Cross, Michael Voss, Jason Akermanis;

HF: Daniel Giansiracusa, Mitch Hahn, Luke Power;

F: Craig McRae, Daniel Bradshaw, Robert Murphy;

R: Matthew Clarke, Adam Cooney, Simon Black.

INT: Beau McDonald, Darryl White, Ryan Hargrave, Matthew Boyd, Dale Morris, Shane O'Bree.

That's 4 Brownlow Medallists and 3 AFL Coaches

How many Suns players could dislodge these selections?

How many skinny flankers can you spot here?

Simon Black went at pick #31 - Clayton loves skinny flankers from WA

Daryl White was plucked from obscurity in NT, another of Clayton's happy hunting grounds.

Clayton passed on Justin Murphy to pick "skinny flanker" Nigel Lappin at pick #2.

9 teams passed on Robert Murphy before Clayton picked him.

A lot of Suns fans claim Scott Clayton is the worst list manager and other palaver, but on the evidence he has been one of the most successful list managers in modern AFL history. Just flawed in that he was never able to put together a premiership list within his tenures at 3 clubs, despite his successors being able to turn his lists into contenders after his departure. The Bears/Lions merger was Clayton's undoing, but his successor did quite poorly at the Draft and it was really the recruits like Martin Pike, Mal Michael and Brad Scott that helped the existing group become the best team ever.
 
Eddie McGuire complaining on afl website about the finals fixture

Guess what mate. You’ve had it your way all year long.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

gcsunsfc said:
Eddie McGuire complaining on afl website about the finals fixture

Guess what mate. You’ve had it your way all year long.
Click to expand...
Saw that. Collingwood are insane. They have demanded all the things they see other clubs getting, like choosing where and when they play, gaining access to Talent Academies and rarely leaving Victoria. They are currently looking at pick #14 unless they can beat the Hawks and then Richmond and make the GF. Isaac Quaynor is tied to them through the Next Gen Academy and is likely to go mid first round. Will Kelly is a Father/Son selection also tipped to go first round, probably late but as a KPD he could gain early interest. Atu Bosenavualagi is another Next Gen player tied to the Pies.
Then they have picks #14, #49, #52, #70 and #88 which means that right now they can't afford all of their own designated targets AND they reckon they can afford Lynch or May while they have as many as 20 players yet to sign for 2019.
 
The 5th year in a row that an interstate team that finished higher plays a GF in Melbourne against a Victorian team.
Perth have a stadium that holds 60K, that's enough for me to say they can play it there.
It will never be a true national comp. The deal to lock in the MCG as host until 2057 is a sham
Carn the Eagles.
 
Suns of Anarchy said:
Tim Kelly requesting a trade to the Eagles. Geelong fans in meltdown.

View attachment 568738
Click to expand...

Just read the last few pages of Geelong Tim Kelly thread. To see the meltdowns and hypocrisy of those that were the most self-righteous and trolling of our board 12 months ago has well and truly made my day.
I’ve always said the Handbaggers Franchise was glass jawed and it’s been displayed again.

Off I go to semi-exile again.
 
kreglze said:
GWS losing a lot of players at the moment. Salary Cap or something more sinister?
Click to expand...
Mostly cap issues I keep reading and hearing.
Once their premiership window starts closing they’ll lose players left right and centre like us.
Scully happy to take a pay cut and signs for 5 more years. Cracks the sads with 3 years left and pulls out the ‘family reasons’ card.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

The “go home” factor of the sport of AFL is blight and an embarrassment to the sport and to the entire Australian Milennial Generation.
It baffles me because the AFL should have total power over its players Union. AFL players have zero mobility, they can’t go play overseas and they can’t go and play another sport.
Yet those unbelievable morons at VFL house have allowed its player union to take hold over them and it’s weak as piss cheerleader Media is completely incapable of criticism or scrutiny.
It’s affecting the games growth.
 
kreglze said:
GWS losing a lot of players at the moment. Salary Cap or something more sinister?
Click to expand...
Setterfield, Shiel, Scully, Lobb, Finlayson, Patton being floated. That’s gotta be $2million in cap right there that they’re trying to get rid of to get under the cap apparently.
Who is in charge of the salary cap there and how does he have a job still?

Also, at what point does the term ‘exodus’ Come out?
 
Young_Guns said:
Setterfield, Shiel, Scully, Lobb, Finlayson, Patton being floated. That’s gotta be $2million in cap right there that they’re trying to get rid of to get under the cap apparently.
Who is in charge of the salary cap there and how does he have a job still?

Also, at what point does the term ‘exodus’ Come out?
Click to expand...
Hm, Craig Cameron was GWS list manager May 2016 - Oct 2017 :)
 
Mr Bods said:
The “go home” factor of the sport of AFL is blight and an embarrassment to the sport and to the entire Australian Milennial Generation.
It baffles me because the AFL should have total power over its players Union. AFL players have zero mobility, they can’t go play overseas and they can’t go and play another sport.
Yet those unbelievable morons at VFL house have allowed its player union to take hold over them and it’s weak as piss cheerleader Media is completely incapable of criticism or scrutiny.
It’s affecting the games growth.
Click to expand...
Free agency was introduced to allow players the right to choose a home.
How is May, Neale, Scully, Shiel, Hogan, Wingard etc etc requesting to go to a specific club whilst still contract any different?
They've created a monster.
 
Mr Bods said:
Can’t stand Brisbane but this whole thing with Dayne Beams and Collingwood stinks.
Click to expand...

After this year / trade period the Adelaide clubs have firmed as my least favourites.
Sydney up there - although I think thats probably because of their association with FIGJAM Roos.
 
There you have it
Is there a more disgusting hypocrital self-righteous and loathsome group of sub-human inbreds than the Handbaggers Franchise???
My answer is NO.

If it’s a wealthy player from another club involving an adult sister with issues then compassion is paramount
BUT
An indigenous young family getting started who’s very own child has Autism then there is zero care and compassion.

They have insulted caters of special needs children , the indigenous community’s deep love of family connectedness and exposed who they really are tonight.

The Handbaggers

Shame Shame Shame
 
Last edited:
Mr Bods said:
There you have it
Is there a more disgusting hypocrital self-righteous and loathsome group of sub-human inbreds than Handbaggers????
My answer is NO.

If it’s a wealthy player from another club involving a sister with issues then compassion is paramount
BUT
An indigenous young family getting started who’s own child has Autism then there is zero care and compassion.

They have insulted caters of special needs, the indigenous community and exposed who they really are tonight m

Handbaggers
Click to expand...
He’s the only one with a real excuse too.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Oppo Camp Opposition Watch

Similar threads

GC2015
Brownlow 2024 Brownlow watch
2
Replies
34
Views
2K
SandyToes
SandyToes
Ben Drever
Dusty watch 2024
13 14 15 16 17
Replies
403
Views
21K
Big Red Machine
Big Red Machine

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top