Our Top 10 players?

[Demon37]

Got this idea from the Roos Board.

Who are our top 10 players? Try basing it on a mixture of talent and importance to the side.

Here is mine:

1. Bizzell
2. Neitz
3. Yze
4. Johnstone
5. Bruce
6. White
7. Heffernan
8. Jolly
9. McDonald
10. Whelan

We're very lucky to have 2 quality ruckmen when many clubs struggle to find 1.

 

[The Shev]

1. Neitz
2. Yze
3. Johnstone
4. White
5. Bizzell
6. Bruce
7. Robertson
8. Green
9. Jolly
10. Heffernan

 

[Demon37]

Interesting to see you have White and Johnstone ahead of Bizzell.

 

[The Shev]

Potentially they are better. This year Bizzell was miles ahead though. It depends how you rate them. We saw how good Johnno is last year and we know how good White can be.

 

[Broadbridge_20]

1. Bizzell
2. Nietz
3. Yze
4. Johnstone
5. Bruce
6. Jolly
7. Whelan
8. Nicholson
9. Thompson
10. Armstrong

 

[twist]

Top ten for the year or top 10 most talented players?

 

[jivinivan]

1. Neitz
2. Yze
3. Bizzell
4. White
5. Johnstone
6. Bruce
7. Whelan
8. Heffernan
9. Walsh
10. Armstrong

 

[Demon37]

Originally posted by twist
Top ten for the year or top 10 most talented players?

Mixture of both.

This is funny. Apart from Broady (who had one), everybody has White and Johnstone amongst their Top 6. Yet when I read Demonland, the two just mentioned are always 'up for trade', 'useless' and 'soft'.

There are some people on there who have no clue.

 

[year of the roo]

Originally posted by Demon37
We're very lucky to have 2 quality ruckmen when many clubs struggle to find 1.

you do?? who?? i can think of one ruckman who used to do all right who is touted as being trade bait by many. hmmm cant think of who you may be referring to, please enlighten me!!

 

[Demon37]

Re: Re: Our Top 10 players?

Originally posted by year of the roo
you do?? who?? i can think of one ruckman who used to do all right who is touted as being trade bait by many. hmmm cant think of who you may be referring to, please enlighten me!!

Darren Jolly and Mark Jamar.

 

[year of the roo]

Re: Re: Re: Our Top 10 players?

Originally posted by Demon37
Darren Jolly and Mark Jamar.

who?? im sure you said quality ruckman too. oh well at least you got neitz!!

 

[rizzo]

You have ten good players??????

more like 3

 

[Demon37]

Originally posted by rizzo
You have ten good players??????

more like 3

 

[The Shev]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Our Top 10 players?

Originally posted by year of the roo
who?? im sure you said quality ruckman too. oh well at least you got neitz!!

I suppose you've seen a lot of those two, expecially Jamar.



What the hell would you know roo boy?

 

[year of the roo]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Our Top 10 players?

Originally posted by The Shev
I suppose you've seen a lot of those two, expecially Jamar.



What the hell would you know roo boy?

you wouldnt know either way whether i have seen a lot of these 2 or not. and as a result of not being a melbourne supporter, i must confess i have not seen a lot of them. i dont exactly go out of my way to see melbourne games, but i reckon i saw about 8-9 melbourne games this year plus some sandy games and those 2 didnt impress. but thats just my opinion...chin up!!

 

[rizzo]

Originally posted by Demon37

hehehe u got me there

 

[Deestroy]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Our Top 10 players?

Originally posted by year of the roo
but thats just my opinion...

Ok now you've stated it, so **** off.

 

[rizzo]

Originally posted by Demon37

looks a bit like david neitz

 

[Deestroy]

Originally posted by rizzo
looks a bit like david neitz

Took you 2 tries to come up with anything? And it still sucked.

 

[rizzo]

thankyou

 

[CowboyFromHell]

1. Craig Turley
2. Glenn Molloy
3. Danny O'Brien
4. Darren Cuthbertson
5. Todd McHardy
6. Clay Sampson
7. Dean Irving
8. Damien Gaspar
9. David C-Collins
10. Donald C-Collins.

 

[Deestroy]

Originally posted by CowboyFromHell
1. Craig Turley
2. Glenn Molloy
3. Danny O'Brien
4. Darren Cuthbertson
5. Todd McHardy
6. Clay Sampson
7. Dean Irving
8. Damien Gaspar
9. David C-Collins
10. Donald C-Collins.

Luke Ottens was dead-set robbed!

 

[CowboyFromHell]

Originally posted by Deestroy
Luke Ottens was dead-set robbed!

When looking at that list, do you really think so?

 

[The Shev]

How you missed Paul Hopgood or Scott Chisholm is beyond me!

 

[Demon37]

Originally posted by CowboyFromHell

9. David C-Collins

Surely he should be #1?

Brent Grgic looks like Wayne Carey compared to him!