You are kidding yourself, you wouldn't have got a top 10 pick for him last year and you won't get a top 20 for him this year either. Andrew Lovett went for 16 and whilst St Kilda overpaid (ignoring post trade incidents), he had showed alot more in his career than Tambling.
Whilst Tambling might excel at another club, he might also stay at the same level he has played at Richmond in which case any club picking him up will be cautious and unwilling to risk wasting a high draft pick on him.
That's just my opinion, given he wants out of Tigerland I guess we'll see soon enough
Pick 11 for McLean skews many posters' thinking - best we consider that as an error, and not reflective of an informed market price.
I think Tambling would get close on pick 20 - maybe a few either way