Player X or Player Y (Part II)

[Hammers_Saints]

That was Hibberd.

I knew about Hibberd, maybe it was just something that I had imagined..

 

[carn_freo]

simon buckley vs D heppell? im not sure about buckleys chance of playing many games...

 

[JuddyBuddy]

Heppell, easy.

 

[tyram23]

ok last question.. please help

bewick, curnow, atley, wallis, helbig, irons, savage, buckley??????


which bloody one should be my last sub haha????

 

[happy_eagle]

Atley or Bewick

I'm stuck for a final back bench
Puopolo v Toy v Coad v Buckley
I have until tomorrow to figure it out though

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

Duigan or Brodie Smith?

 

[tyram23]

any rucks gonna get games? cheap ones?

 

[sossy19]

lewis jetta & nathan Krakoeur

vs

Rookie (bewick) & Duffield

 

[Little Jerry]

Stanton + Sandilands vs Ryder + Montagna

 

[cfx_1]

any rucks gonna get games? cheap ones?

Zac Smith definately, other than that i would say that Lachlan Keefe is the closest to selection with campbell, bailey still injured.

To play on the field.. Simon Buckley Vs Dyson Heppel

 

[94_Eagles]

Heppell by miles.

 

[kerplunky]

prestia v dixon

mainly worried about prestia's job security here

 

[The Spornstar]

prestia v dixon

mainly worried about prestia's job security here

I'd still go Prestia.

Enright + Vince

vs

Otten + Montagna + 130k

 

[AFaiL]

prestia v dixon

mainly worried about prestia's job security here

Prestia much better potential, but, anyone's guess how many games. I'd prob go Prestia. But, if this is fwd line, hows about darling, tapscott, richardson?

For me the dilemma is:

have Pittard, Bewick in the mids

over in the backs Heppl and Coad

Options:

A) Leave it
B) Heppell to mid, replace him with Stanley. then replace one of Pitt/Bew with hep?
C) Just swap Pitt / Bew to Libba...
D) B and C.. lol

HELP!

 

[AFaiL]

I'd still go Prestia.

Enright + Vince

vs

Otten + Montagna + 130k

2nd option, easy. Montags is a star. Enright has been on the slide

 

[AFaiL]

Stanton + Sandilands vs Ryder + Montagna

Eeek..... Probabyl 2nd option..

 

[AFaiL]

any rucks gonna get games? cheap ones?

moran best choice

 

[WCE9]

For me the dilemma is:

have Pittard, Bewick in the mids

over in the backs Heppl and Coad

Options:

A) Leave it
B) Heppell to mid, replace him with Stanley. then replace one of Pitt/Bew with hep?
C) Just swap Pitt / Bew to Libba...
D) B and C.. lol

HELP!

I'd go option B, Stanley is a safer option than pittard, and libba will be in and out of the team

My questions are:

Prestia v Swallow (Without prestia i have no mid/fwd dpp)

and

A.Otten v No Otten

 

[Masss#10]

Brent Harvey or Colin Sylvia ?

 

[AFaiL]

Brent Harvey or Colin Sylvia ?

Sylvia, easy choice. Especialyl if you're going for league win

 

[srv23]

Brent Harvey or Colin Sylvia ?

Sylvia for me.

Didak vs Sylvia vs Goodes

 

[Masss#10]

Sylvia, easy choice. Especialyl if you're going for league win

Thanks mate, what about Richardson and Tapscott? Who will get more games you think?

 

[94_Eagles]

^^^^

Too hard to say.

Ward v L. Jetta and why?

 

[Squall]

Thanks mate, what about Richardson and Tapscott? Who will get more games you think?

Richardson for me likely to play more games IMO.

Otten vs Toy plus $$

 

[Woody15]

id go Otten. wont be sub and will have a good JS this year.

Didak or Green or Sylvia ?