Player X Verse Player Y
- Thread starter doona
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
skins62
Team Captain
Clark & Vberg if you have to make two changes.
Depends on your team but I'll give Griffen another week, I wouldn't mind waiting another week to see if Whitfield can back it up as well.
I started Salem and Vandenberg last week and this week it's currently at the two you said above.
If Cripps isn't starting sub though, I might choose him as I'm worried there is a chance Vandenberg could be starting sub since he was named on the bench.
Cripps might do a bit better back in his home state and against a weaker midfield.
Gonna keep Griffen for one more week.
jakemelksham17
Rookie
- May 20, 2013
- 40
- 9
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Dylan shiels vs ollie wines
Rich vs Newton
- Apr 18, 2012
- 2,960
- 1,465
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Should I field Saad or Talia?
Wines
Tend to side with wingard as well. Only 50k difference in price, bit safer. Hard call though.
Tough one again. My head says Newton but my. heart says the lion. I remember watching Rich before his injury, he was a gun. But for a cash purposes probably Newton.
Saad for me.
James LeBron
Senior List
- Feb 20, 2015
- 163
- 18
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Who to start this week? Oxley,Saad or even Goodes?
James LeBron
Senior List
- Feb 20, 2015
- 163
- 18
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Don't know really, He started as the sub for the match, but next game he might not be, But his job security isn't as good as the other two so just ignore him
Saad or Oxley?
kainomac
Debutant
- Mar 20, 2014
- 126
- 24
- AFL Club
- Geelong
For consistency purposes, I'd say go with Saad but Collingwood face a reasonable weak forward line in St kilda where Oxley could step up. Would still go saad for consistency and midfield runs.
Bonts.
Wines or Dangerfield?
There is not much to split them on exposed form. Given that both are performing about on par, I'd take Dangerfield as he is $20k cheaper.
Scratch that, just realised I was looking at their supercoach scores not AFL fantasy. Change my vote to Wines. An extra 20 points avg for $20k.
Which two should I start of - Cripps, Yolmen, Vandenberg, Newton
I'm thinking Crips and Yolmen. Newtwo and Vandenberg scored quite meh last week and have an even tougher opponent
this week in Adelaide. Yolmen might not score as much with Thompson back, but I think he might do better than the two Melb mids.
In defence - Oxley, Goodes or Saad? I've gone with Oxley this week, but Saad is starting.
Oxley would be an odd sub though.
Up forward - Salem, Clark or McCarthy. I've gone Salem, even though I don't think he'll do too great this week in Adelaide but not sure if Clark will get a big score and McCarthy will have a tough day against Sydney probably.
I'm thinking Crips and Yolmen. Newtwo and Vandenberg scored quite meh last week and have an even tougher opponent
this week in Adelaide. Yolmen might not score as much with Thompson back, but I think he might do better than the two Melb mids.
In defence - Oxley, Goodes or Saad? I've gone with Oxley this week, but Saad is starting.
Oxley would be an odd sub though.
Up forward - Salem, Clark or McCarthy. I've gone Salem, even though I don't think he'll do too great this week in Adelaide but not sure if Clark will get a big score and McCarthy will have a tough day against Sydney probably.
It is a tough one.
Mids - I'm staring Newton with Cripps(E)/Ellis-Yolmen on the bench, because I'm worried they may both get the vest (Cripps first game back and Grigg has been omitted for Radelaide maybe putting the vest onto Ellis-Yolmen). There is a definite risk reward scenario though. I need to go with the lowest risk in my midfield as I spent a lot of money up forward, so I have a few high risk players in the middle.
Def - I'm starting Oxley with Goodes/Saad(E) on the pine. Very gunshy about Goodes now he get a sub 20 score.
Fwd - Yeah, of that lot I'd play Salem. My choice was Honeychurch/McCarthy/Clark and I chose Honeychurch with McCarthy getting the (E).
Some good points re the sub for midfield, gonna be a hard choice.
Can see myself changing it right before lockout.
- Jun 9, 2010
- 798
- 771
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Orlando Magic
Griffen to
Neale vs Whitfield vs Stephen Hill
KK to
Jasper Pittard (all I can afford)
Neale vs Whitfield vs Stephen Hill
KK to
Jasper Pittard (all I can afford)
Bert Man
Premiership Player
- Jul 22, 2012
- 3,591
- 1,343
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- PSG, ARSENAL
Neale out of him, Whitfield and Hill
- Status
