- Mar 20, 2013
- 5,303
- 5,509
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Dow vs Naughton
Ignore positional difference, just compare on average, JS, value
Ignore positional difference, just compare on average, JS, value
-
Guest - BigFooty Tipping 2025 - Get on! - $500 first prize - Weekly Prizes - Click to Join
PLUS Your club board comp is now up!
Player X vs Player Y vs Player Z
- Thread starter SELFCONFESDAFLNERD
- Start date
- Tagged users None
doona
SMFC
Naughton is a better 200k+ Rookie than Dow due to position in my opinion. Dow, there are way better rookies, in my opinion, to have in front of him like Brayshaw, kelly, banfield, holman, etc..... where as in defence I see Naughton as one of the better options.
Note: I am rocking three onfield rookies in defence, and Naughton is one of the onfield rookies.
Last edited:
Dow + Venables. I think Venables has slightly more JS then Barry, but Barry has the better scoring potential. I’d go Dow over Rayner, similar JS but Dow has the better role.
Edit:
Hibberd + Parker + Sicily
Or
Sicily + Parker + Billings
Or
Brayshaw + Zorko(Dusty/Adams) + Billings
Last edited:
That would be a difference of +10ppg if my arithmetic is correct.
- Jun 27, 2013
- 47,129
- 44,138
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspur, SSC Napoli, ESH
Yep it's only 10 on that math, not 20.
The Smith option gives me no DPP and while Coniglio is a great starting pick, I feel he's better suited to a starting M6 rather than a M5, my midfield looks stronger with a Treloar/Zorko at M3 who are good chances to be top 10 mids. Really surprised Billings didn't get DPP, he's sitting at F2 currently in this set up but I can use his cash in midfield instead if I feel I get more points elsewhere.
Petracca at least has DPP going for him so he can be F7/M9 if he only averages in that 75-85 range. Reckon Smith is in the 85-92 Dahlhaus range, not 95.
Might cut a premium forward and see if I can use the funds in midfield instead too though.
- Jun 27, 2013
- 47,129
- 44,138
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspur, SSC Napoli, ESH
Can downgrade Zorko down to Macrae or Rocky and get Smith that way
Reckon Macrae will be solid this year and should be around the 105-110 range, but can probably get him cheaper during the year, Rocky a risk and one I've been burned a few times by by the need to trade him in out.
Reckon Macrae will be solid this year and should be around the 105-110 range, but can probably get him cheaper during the year, Rocky a risk and one I've been burned a few times by by the need to trade him in out.
- Mar 20, 2013
- 5,303
- 5,509
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Considering this myself. If Barry named pick him unless you think he will be straight out for gray.
If $$ allows go Coffield to Dow though, no use taking in a non playing cash cow.
I'd say the first option will give you more points.
I'm rocking with but it's tough because Martin is sole ruck and should score well...
doona
SMFC
No Coffield if that comes to pass means I don’t want to carry 3 rookies on field in defence. I am thinking of:
Kelly + Coffield
V
Laird + Dow
Severely weakens my midfield but if Laird can average 100, points should be fine.
Kelly + Coffield
V
Laird + Dow
Severely weakens my midfield but if Laird can average 100, points should be fine.
Josh Kelly? I think I'd go josh kelly and conffield. Naughton seems to have locked his place down. Laird will most likely average what you pay for him I think.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
doona
SMFC
But a non-playing rookie in defence when fielding 3 is rort with danger. I was fine with that formation thinking Coffield would have been a solid D4 to start the year.
Yeah that's completely fair. The way I've combatted this is I've found a way to get conffield up to Byrne whilst maintaining my structure. I really didn't want to lose my M6. Could be an option
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
doona
SMFC
I have tentatively gone:
Coffield > Bonner
Rayner > Fogarty
Kruezer > Martin
I really don't like it, but, it is the only thing that I can do without killing my structure. The only other option is taking Kelly to Parker/Coniglio
Yeah I want bonner but I was about 5k short.
You won't regret Martin surely, sole ruck who is almost a midfielder. Hopefully the smith experiment has been put to bed. Not sure about Rayner > Fogarty just worried about security.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Bonner v Byrne.....for my structure it needs to be one. Both have their pro's and con's.
Which leaves upfront losing Waterman or Ryan - one of those will be changed to a keeper - not sure which one to keep though??? They'll probably average roughly the same but it's more of a roll of the dice for job security.
Which leaves upfront losing Waterman or Ryan - one of those will be changed to a keeper - not sure which one to keep though??? They'll probably average roughly the same but it's more of a roll of the dice for job security.
- Mar 20, 2007
- 30,136
- 28,528
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Waterman goes out when Kennedy comes back in. Not to mention he will be playing fairly deep when playing. I would be avoiding him all together to be honest
Cripps Vs Treloar Vs Gibbs
I need some help Keep changing my mind
I need some help Keep changing my mind
- Sep 6, 2015
- 28,197
- 23,341
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Pelicans, Perf Wildcats
Rule out Cripps, he's more suited to SC.
I'm also contemplating Gibbs v Trelly
Schulzenfest
TheBrownDog
I have neither, but if I was gonna pick one, go Treloar. Cripps is unproven ever and Gibbs is unproven at his new club. Treloar is definitely the safer of the three.
- Sep 6, 2015
- 28,197
- 23,341
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Pelicans, Perf Wildcats
Waterman's been coming up the ground for marks. Ryan is the one who stays deep
Gibbs playing predominately midfield and a bit of half-back at the crows is tasty IMO.
