Players I don't want us to trade for

[Broadbridge_20]

If any of these players end up at Melbourne I will be convinced that our coaching staff have rocks in their head and I will strongly consider not buying a membership ticket next year


Matthew Richardson
Joel Bowden
Kayne Pettifer
Ben Holland
Nick Holland
Aaron Fiora
Corey McKernan
The Lonies either of them
Peter Street
Daniel Harford
Heath Black
Leon Davis
Ben Kinnear
Stephen Paxman
Shannon Watt
Kris Barlow
Lance Picoane
Patrick Wiggins

*This list will be updated as more come to mind.

 

[Tim56]

Of that list, I wouldn't mind if we got:

Matthew Richardson
Joel Bowden
Ben Holland
Nick Holland
The Lonies either of them
Heath Black

 

[Deestroy]

Agreed. Add:

Adam Kingsley
Shannon Watt
Stephen Paxman
Jarrod Molloy
Ben Kinnear

 

[BT]

Broadbridge_20

If any of these players end up at Melbourne I will be convinced that our coaching staff have rocks in their head and I will strongly consider not buying a membership ticket next year


Matthew Richardson
Joel Bowden
Kayne Pettifer
Ben Holland
Nick Holland
Aaron Fiora
Corey McKernan
The Lonies either of them
Peter Street
Daniel Harford
Heath Black
Leon Davis

Deestroy

Agreed. Add:

Adam Kingsley
Shannon Watt
Stephen Paxman
Jarrod Molloy
Ben Kinnear

There will be more but you blokes have made a great start. None of these blokes have any value to us at all.

 

[NathanCarroll41]

Wouldn't mind terribly to see Paxman added for a year, on the verterans list (which is currently empty at Demons) on a basement salary.
His experience now that Ellis has retired would be invaluable and just three weeks ago when Paxman towelled up Tarrant nobody even contemplating him retiring.
Richo isn't that bad and would give us a boost in membership due to pure excitement but the rest of the list is fairly accurate.
I've got no doubt though that when together the Lonie boys can play footy, maybe the pair of them on half back would work

 

[Deestroy]

Originally posted by NathanCarroll41
Wouldn't mind terribly to see Paxman added for a year, on the verterans list (which is currently empty at Demons) on a basement salary.

You have to have played 10 consecutive years at the club to be eligable, can't just change clubs and jump onto their vets list.

 

[Demon37]

Matthew Richardson- I'd take him for the right price.
Joel Bowden- Agree.
Kayne Pettifer- Agree.
Ben Holland- Agree.
Nick Holland- Agree.
Aaron Fiora- Agree.
Corey McKernan- Agree.
The Lonies either of them- I'd take Ryan for sure.
Peter Street- Agree.
Daniel Harford- Agree.
Heath Black- Agree.
Leon Davis- Agree.
Adam Kingsley- Agree.
Shannon Watt- Agree.
Stephen Paxman- Agree.
Jarrod Molloy- Agree.
Ben Kinnear-Agree.

 

[Broadbridge_20]

Originally posted by Deestroy
Agreed. Add:

Adam Kingsley
Shannon Watt
Stephen Paxman
Jarrod Molloy
Ben Kinnear

I've added Kinnear, Paxman and Watt to the list.

EDITED: Molloy has just retired and Kingsley might be OK if we got him in the pre season.

 

[chiliboy]

Well prepare to be upset..

At least of of either Watt, or B holland will be at the club...

 

[SPUNKY_MONKEY45]

Re: Re: Players I don't want us to trade for

Originally posted by Demon37
Matthew Richardson- I'd take him for the right price.
Joel Bowden- Agree.
Kayne Pettifer- Agree.
Ben Holland- Agree.
Nick Holland- Agree.
Aaron Fiora- Agree.
Corey McKernan- Agree.
The Lonies either of them- I'd take Ryan for sure.
Peter Street- Agree.
Daniel Harford- Agree.
Heath Black- Agree.
Leon Davis- Agree.
Adam Kingsley- Agree.
Shannon Watt- Agree.
Stephen Paxman- Agree.
Jarrod Molloy- Agree.
Ben Kinnear-Agree.

i agree with this, i'l definately take either Lonie

 

[Broadbridge_20]

Originally posted by chiliboy
Well prepare to be upset..

At least of of either Watt, or B holland will be at the club...

If we get either of those duds we will be going backwards 5 years.

If we want a backman and have plenty to spend we should look at poaching Polak who is out of contract.

We'll have to overpay for him but at least he'll be worthwhile.

Even throw pick 20 and a fringe player at Brisbane for Bradshaw and Morrisson.

 

[CowboyFromHell]

As stupid as this may sound, if Vardy doesn't come up and we know this by trade week, I wouldn't mind Leon Davis in a pocket if he came cheap.

 

[BT]

Originally posted by CowboyFromHell
As stupid as this may sound, if Vardy doesn't come up and we know this by trade week, I wouldn't mind Leon Davis in a pocket if he came cheap.

But that's Farmer's spot!

You already know I think this suggestion sounds stupid btw

 

[BT]

Originally posted by Broadbridge_20
If we get either of those duds we will be going backwards 5 years.

Agreed!

 

[The Shev]

Leon Davis?

He doesn't hold a candle to a fit and firing Jeff Farmer. If we are going for a small forward at all, it must be the Wiz.

 

[Broadbridge_20]

New entry - Patrick Wiggins.

 

[Deestroy]

Originally posted by Broadbridge_20
New entry - Patrick Wiggins.

Agreed, he's not getting a touch as a KPP at the Doggies!

__________________
The MFC Flame - All new design

Long live sigs.

 

[Broadbridge_20]

I am convinced that our coaching staff have rocks in their head and will strongly consider not buying a membership ticket next year.

 

[BT]

Originally posted by Broadbridge_20
I am convinced that our coaching staff have rocks in their head and will strongly consider not buying a membership ticket next year.

I think you're right, but if we don't SUPPORT the club we'll have nothing to complain about soon enough.

 

[Broadbridge_20]

Originally posted by BT
I think you're right, but if we don't SUPPORT the club we'll have nothing to complain about soon enough.

Do anymore deals like the one we did today and there'll be nothing to support anyway.

 

[BT]

Originally posted by Broadbridge_20
Do anymore deals like the one we did today and there'll be nothing to support anyway.

There will be if we can weather the storm.

 

[Tim56]

Originally posted by Broadbridge_20
I am convinced that our coaching staff have rocks in their head and will strongly consider not buying a membership ticket next year.

Go on, **** off then. If we are talking about duds, we should be talking about Broadbridge.

 

[Demon37]

Originally posted by Tim56
Go on, **** off then. If we are talking about duds, we should be talking about Broadbridge.

hahaha.

I'm fine with Holland at the Dees. Pick 20 may be a bit high, but Richmond are paying us big bucks to take him.

 

[Broadbridge_20]

Originally posted by Tim56
If we are talking about duds, we should be talking about Broadbridge.

So says the man who rates Bowden, Fiora, Pettiffer, the Lonies and Heath Black.

This is football mate not dancing.

If you were in charge you’d have us playing in mini skirts and leotards

Maybe you are in charge, that would explain why we’ve done **** all the last 50 years.

 

[Tim56]

Originally posted by Broadbridge_20
So says the man who rates Bowden, Fiora, Pettiffer, the Lonies and Heath Black.

This is football mate not dancing.

If you were in charge you’d have us playing in mini skirts and leotards

Maybe you are in charge, that would explain why we’ve done **** all the last 50 years.

1. I do rate Bowden, the Lonies and Black; Fiora and Pettifer I do not.

2. Say what you will about Ben Holland, he isn't soft