Players you thought were going to be guns but ended up being duds...

[TigerCleavage]

Justin Plapp looked like an absolute beauty when he started. I wouldn't say he turned into a dud, but he definitely tailed off.

 

[bushwood]

i remember the crows using there number 4 pick on a guy named Carey, only played a few seasons never reached his potential, infact nearly every crows first pick

 

[CrowHop]

Adam Saliba would have to be one of the most talented guys I saw (in terms of skills) but never fired a shot at the top level.

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Damien Cupido - for reasons said
Ashley Sampi - high draft pick, took 1 great mark and that was about it. A big disappointment
Danyle Pearce - Rising Star in 2006 and is now pretty much a one-year wonder. Too inconsistent. People said that he was going to be better than Mcleod, how wrong were they!

I was going to saying Justin Westhoff but I'll give him another year.

 

[pazza]

Right now, if he's not careful, Jason Laycock is set to head down that road.

 

[adelaide_40]

Damien cupido

and fergus watts I always thought he was going to be a gun how wrong I was

 

[horj89]

Kepler Bradley.

Was tipped to be the next Dustin Fletcher but hasn't come close.