Roast Port Adelaide's failure to do a HIA assessment on Aliir - [AFL confirms both players FAILED concussion tests on Monday]

[g_TRAIN]

There’s just no reason to even try and throw shade at something which doesn’t exist here.

He passed the SCAT test - tick.
We’re monitoring for delayed - tick.
He’s removed from unnecessary media while resting - tick.

We couldn’t have been more open or cautious about him.

He will likely have further tests this week to assess any delayed symptoms and if he doesn’t play then, that will be why and fair enough. Not because of some conspiracy after following the correct protocol.

All good mate, I wasn't throwing shade myself just curious how Port fans are feeling when it comes to concussion issues and the club.

Sounds like everything is being done above board with this incident.

 

[Powerade 08]

Cheaters never prosper

No better example than the Crows.



Hit with instant karma for not sending McAdam to the sidelines (Keays point). and now their rebuild looks likely to yield a bottom 4 finish

Ah well

 

[Dez!]

Should scan Esavas head after chest marking behind the line by himself.

 

[Muddiemoose]

Should scan Esavas head after chest marking behind the line by himself.

Not the first time he’s cost his team a goal on the line
Once when he was the cats he spoiled (yes spoiled with a punch) a certain cats goal when he was playing forward

Bloke had the footy iq of a divvy 4 local cricket player

 

[maskmcgee]

So Port's doctors are just totally incompetent right, can't diagnose hamstring injuries, cant do concussion tests.

 

[Soggy2112]

So Port's doctors are just totally incompetent right, can't diagnose hamstring injuries, cant do concussion tests.

Is it the doctor or is it Ken thinking he knows better?

 

[Wargreymon90]

Is it the doctor or is it Ken thinking he knows better?

can we sack both?

 

[ibd77]

So Port's doctors are just totally incompetent right, can't diagnose hamstring injuries, cant do concussion tests.

Probably the same doc that doesn't give certificates for sickies.

 

[1990crow]

So Port's doctors are just totally incompetent right, can't diagnose hamstring injuries, cant do concussion tests.

It's not even hyperbole to suggest this. He's been negligent to Ports players for a long time now.
Puts the club ahead of them.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Not the first time he’s cost his team a goal on the line
Once when he was the cats he spoiled (yes spoiled with a punch) a certain cats goal when he was playing forward

Bloke had the footy iq of a divvy 4 local cricket player

Can confirm the trade did have a no refunds clause in the fineprint. Thanks Port.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

So Port's doctors are just totally incompetent right, can't diagnose hamstring injuries, cant do concussion tests.

Apparently they thought Rozee has superhuman recovery powers.

Just beyond stupid that not one person on the selection panel or doctor didn't overrule the decision to play Rozee.

Said during the week I would be pleasantly surprised if Rozee plays as means they will will be 1 short.

Could tell from his 1st kick he was proppy, so wtf are they doing with their fitness tests or basic common sense?

Just beyond stupid & smacks of desperation.

 

[powerrrrrrrrrrrr]

How is it that Stewart and Schultz clash heads, both are down following the contact and only Schultz was off for a concussion test and out of the game given the time that was left.

Why Wasn’t Stewart assessed? Just patch him up and straight back out.

That was a piss poor look from the Cats.