Preliminary Final Edition - Which club do you think will win the flag?

[Mr Meow]

They didn't secure the top 2 until the second to last match of the season, though, I thought they were going to drop out of the top 4 after that Port game performance, they came close to losing their position, they were lucky they had non-finalists for their last 3 matches. I can't find any record of a team going with the recent form of 5-5 into a prelim and winning a premiership. The closest I could find is Adelaide with 6-4 in 1998.

Basically secured. They were like 3-4 games and percentage ahead of 3rd. Gave themselves a tiny late scare but it's disingenuous to say they were seriously fighting for top 2.

So it is an outlier situation, meaning an outlier result is very possible.

 

[GoldbergsGold]

Basically secured. They were like 3-4 games and percentage ahead of 3rd. Gave themselves a tiny late scare but it's disingenuous to say they were seriously fighting for top 2.

So it is an outlier situation, meaning an outlier result is very possible.

Their form was terrible going into their last 3 matches, so it's not disingenuous, it was a reality their position was on the line. I've been looking for a 5-5 recent form team before a prelim who won a premiership, can not see one. Teams for the most part are 7-3, 8-2, 9-1 or 10-0 before a prelim that win a premiership.

 

[Mr Meow]

Their form was terrible going into their last 3 matches, so it's not disingenuous, it was a reality their position was on the line. I've been looking for a 5-5 recent form team before a prelim who won a premiership, can not see one. Teams for the most part are 7-3, 8-2, 9-1 or 10-0 before a prelim that win a premiership.

It's disingenuous to suggest top 2 was not all but locked in before their slump. Yes their slump was so unexpectedly severe and prolonged that top 2 came under threat VERY late.

So it is an outlier situation. This is why you can't find similar scenarios. Anything is on the cards from here.

 

[bungalow_bill]

Cats to lose IMO. Should beat the lions and then easily beat Port in the GF. Raging favourites

 

[Shinboner '07]

Really hoping it’s Lions or Swans. Port and Geelong can GAGF

 

[Mr Meow]

Cats to lose

This is fine, but then who to win?

 

[bloodsbigot]

Unfortunately Cats will win. Can't see any non-Victorian club beating them at the MCG.

Only chance Port or Swans have is if Brisbane stop them in the Prelim or if Geelong get a lot of injuries.

If it were at a neutral venue outside Victoria, I think we'd absolutely annihilate them. But ye old boys club.

 

[PCORF]

Geelong or Brisbane are winning the flag. Scoring power is going to get this done and both teams can kick over 100 points in big, tough games.

Don't write off your Port just yet.

 

[PCORF]

1. Geelong in the drivers seat. It is their flag to lose.
2. Sydney
3. Port
4. Brisbane

 

[JPetro83]

Port have no pressure, thrive on being the underdogs. they cant handle the favorite tag in finals.
They will win tonight and jag the flag this year

 

[Strange Cat]

Sydney have looked the most potent team all year long aside from one brief slump.

This

They should win it this year , while it’s been a good year for us we still have a lot of kids in a rebuild phase so we have done well

Syd looks very competent when they are switched on

 

[bomberclifford]

We all know it's going to be Geelong with the umpires help

I doubt they’ll need the umpires help.

I’d like to say Port but Geelong or Brisbane would be my pick.

 

[Osho]

Now that the Giants have imploded, and the Hawks arrogated, one needs to look hard at the team that looks most real, least flawed, going about their business without fuss, bluster, or pretense.

Only one answer: Cats.

 

[Munich]

Why is everyone on Geelong as a shoe in.

Is it so you can all say we choked if we don't win it?

Bizarre.

 

[ibd77]

Port have no pressure, thrive on being the underdogs. they cant handle the favorite tag in finals.
They will win tonight and jag the flag this year

We do struggle with expectation pressure but we flourish under sack Hinkley pressure, which unfortunately for us has all been released since Kochie's announcement.

 

[Mr Meow]

I know over here in SA a few of us Crows fans are going to be cashed up when Port win the flag. figured if they are going to win it we need something to soften the blow. i got port last week at $18 and chucked a bit of cash on JHF and Butters for the Norm smith.

What are you spending the winnings on?

 

[Kobe Gryant]

Unfortunately Cats will win. Can't see any non-Victorian club beating them at the MCG.

Only chance Port or Swans have is if Brisbane stop them in the Prelim or if Geelong get a lot of injuries.

If it were at a neutral venue outside Victoria, I think we'd absolutely annihilate them. But ye old boys club.

Amazing persecution complex ready and waiting.

If you're actually good enough you win anywhere, and before you say it, Geelong are the same with the Kardinia Park debate.

When we're actually the best side it never seems to trouble us. It didn't in '07-11, and it didn't in '22.

It's only when we became a borderline contender that people chose to bring it up. It's a safety net from a supporter POV.

As 'unfair' as it may seem, you play between the rules that are given to you. They haven't changed in 100 years, and they don't look like changing anytime soon.

If paid professional athletes can't handle that then that's their problem.

It's a field of grass with goalposts at either end, it's not a subcontinent cricket pitch.

 

[bloodsbigot]

Amazing persecution complex ready and waiting.

If you're actually good enough you win anywhere, and before you say it, Geelong are the same with the Kardinia Park debate.

When we're actually the best side it never seems to trouble us. It didn't in '07-11, and it didn't in '22.

It's only when we became a borderline contender that people chose to bring it up. It's a safety net from a supporter POV.

As 'unfair' as it may seem, you play between the rules that are given to you. They haven't changed in 100 years, and they don't look like changing anytime soon.

If paid professional athletes can't handle that then that's their problem.

It's a field of grass with goalposts at either end, it's not a subcontinent cricket pitch.

You only choose to believe all that bullshit you wrote because the MCG massively favours Geelong.

 

[NetworkNerd]

Why is everyone on Geelong as a shoe in.

Is it so you can all say we choked if we don't win it?

Bizarre.

Champion team with hardened premiership stars playing in Vic.

The other 2 clubs do not have that

 

[Footy_Fan2007]

Champion team with hardened premiership stars playing in Vic.

The other 2 clubs do not have that

The other 2 have the recent pain of losing a GF.

 

[Bartel84]

The other 2 have the recent pain of losing a GF.

People act like this means something. Like they have a leg up because they lost a GF. I don’t think there is much science behind this.

 

[Osho]

Why is everyone on Geelong as a shoe in.

Is it so you can all say we choked if we don't win it?

Bizarre.

I think some punters are def doing this. But some of us, uhummmm, no names, have been saying Cats since May. In an even season, the best managed and coached team will have an advantage.

 

[Robroy22]

Unfortunately Cats will win. Can't see any non-Victorian club beating them at the MCG.

Only chance Port or Swans have is if Brisbane stop them in the Prelim or if Geelong get a lot of injuries.

If it were at a neutral venue outside Victoria, I think we'd absolutely annihilate them. But ye old boys club.

Lol.....this is exactly what we used to say about Melbourne in the '50's...."they're playing on their home ground!!"

 

[bloodsbigot]

Lol.....this is exactly what we used to say about Melbourne in the '50's...."they're playing on their home ground!!"

Didn't they win 5/6 as a result?

 

[Cleansweep17]

Amazing persecution complex ready and waiting.

If you're actually good enough you win anywhere, and before you say it, Geelong are the same with the Kardinia Park debate.

When we're actually the best side it never seems to trouble us. It didn't in '07-11, and it didn't in '22.

It's only when we became a borderline contender that people chose to bring it up. It's a safety net from a supporter POV.

As 'unfair' as it may seem, you play between the rules that are given to you. They haven't changed in 100 years, and they don't look like changing anytime soon.

If paid professional athletes can't handle that then that's their problem.

It's a field of grass with goalposts at either end, it's not a subcontinent cricket pitch.

It affected you in 08 though. Don’t see you losing a GF at GMHBA