Preview Preliminary Final: Geelong Cats v Brisbane Lions - 7:50 PM Friday the 16th of September

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
A week is a long time in footy.

Yes, it’s a cliché that would make Fish Whiting shudder, but the anything-but-linear nature of season 2023 epitomises just how much of an impact a week can have.

For this preview to begin, we must start from round 23.

The final siren rang through the Gabba. Zorko was the disgrace of the competition. Rayner and Answerth were suspended. Brisbane were pretenders, destined to fall short to an in-form Richmond Tigers.

7rR55fuu.jpg


Fast forward a fortnight (maybe a fortnight is also a long time in footy?), Brisbane play the ‘sure thing’ Richmond in a final that had everything and more. They win in the most unlikely of ways (thanks Joe!) and left millions of neutral AFL fans celebrating a match of the year contender, all the while assuming Brisbane were on their way to another drumming at the hands of the Demons.

lcimg-8ecf91d4-ab11-4bff-b566-6f04a2841fa6.jpg


Fast forward another week. It’s game day and Fagan gets a call. Last week’s matchwinner Joe Daniher is flying home due to his partner giving birth. Fullarton is in. The betting odds skyrocket to 4.50. Brisbane can’t win in the minds of most, if not all.

But we did. Through sheer persistence, belief and desire, we fought and fought until we hit the lead. From that moment, we would not be surrendering the victory under any circumstances. The final siren rang through the MCG this time, and with it were the words “We are the pride of Brisbane town”.

HBaRx9EP.jpg


A date with our old foes Geelong was set and in a week’s time we will walk the hallowed grounds of the MCG once again.

The narrative has not changed. Brisbane play the ‘sure thing’ Geelong, they will get smashed, Geelong are basically already through to the grand final. Brisbane can’t win without Berry. The list goes on.

A week is a long time in footy.

The Matchup

If you are to believe the media, you’d think we’re a young, plucky David walking into the colosseum to fight the demi-god known as Goliath, yet the stats paint a very different picture.

1662866425671.png

Brisbane and Geelong had very similar seasons. Both teams average 14 goals a game, have similar disposal efficiency (both around the ground and inside 50). The hitouts are only slightly in the Lions favour, while the Lions average 2 more clearances a game than the Cats (including 1 more a game from the centre).

Where Geelong excel over Brisbane is marks inside 50 thanks to Tom Hawkins. If he is on, Geelong are a very hard team to stop.

Despite Hawkins’ dominance in the contested marking space, Brisbane has a slight edge in contested marks which says to me – shut Hawkins down, shut Geelong’s marking power down. While Cameron is an incredible player, his work is done around the F50 just as much as it’s done deep. Like Hipwood, he’ll be a hard player to stop, but if we can stop his foils in Hawkins and Stengle, then their potency will take a big hit.

23b9e6fb01a9325fa9b7fdd38b36889b


Looking at our match against Melbourne (who have a superior midfield to Geelong), we lost clearances soundly but cut them up on the outside through uncontested possession chains. While Brisbane have always been good in this area, the tactical change in personal has meant we are much, much stronger on the spread and – as we saw just a few days ago – makes up for the hit we take in clearances.

In many ways, Geelong’s resurgence of 2022 (and I say resurgence as they made some personal and tactical changes that have aided them in a big way this year) mirrors that of our past fortnight. A newfound focus in moving the ball fast to avoid contested situations, but an absolute willingness to scrap and run both ways.

So, both teams match up on each other well, how will each team win?

Geelong

Geelong win this by doing what they’ve done to us many times over the years – bully us around the ball until we submit to their physicality then let their forwards do the work. It is a recipe for success that we always struggle to counter. If they can pressure us around the ball and bully our younger mids physically, then we will struggle to stop their inside 50s. If Geelong get easy inside 50’s, we will lose by 30-50 points with ease.

4371.jpg


Brisbane

While beating Melbourne was incredibly satisfying as a fan, watching the replay with a level head led me to think about how this game style would stand up to Geelong and – after a quick check of a specific stat – it was plain to see. 1%ers. Geelong – for all their weapons – are not all that good at 1%ers. They need to beat you with physicality around the ball and their fantastic zone defence. When it comes to the gritty side of footy, things like knock-ons, spoils, smothers and shepherds are not Geelong’s strong suit.

While throughout the year we were about 5 a game better than they were, we’ve gone to another level in finals. Across the two finals, we’ve averaged 64 1%ers to Geelong’s 47 across the season (including their final win against Collingwood).

If we can bring the same level of pressure, desperation, fight and belief then we can win against the Cats as we did Richmond and Melbourne. Play fast, and stop the oppositions attack at all cost and this game is absolutely up for grabs.




Final thoughts


In the past 3 weeks we’ve been disgraced, pretenders, lucky, given no chance against the dynasty Dees, plucky, gritty and ultimately victorious. This war has two more battles left to fight and our troops are well and truly up for the challenge.

While a week is a long time in footy, the opportunity the Brisbane Lions have this finals series is a chance at immortality. What happens next is up to the 44 players who take field this Friday.

Go Lions!​
 
Time to believe. Already two wins down into the finals. Here's hoping the extra week off Geelong's had works in our favour and we get going with the extra momentum from the last couple of wins.

Either way, really looking forward to this one.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Geelong has played 1 game in what, almost a month? That may not necessarily be a good thing for them.

Or it could be just what their aging bodies need. How will they cope playing two games in a row should they win? They should consider forfeiting.
 
I just hope Jeremy Cameron doesn't kill anyone.
 
I just hope Jeremy Cameron doesn't kill anyone.

Jeremy Cameron to concuss Hawkins and Stengle in the opening marking contest thinking he was charging in on Joe and Charlie.
 
2022 Geelong is no joke. They are an extremely good team.

We'll have an insane amount of belief and lots of our players are capable of pulling an insane game out of nowhere. I can see why we're not favourites but I don't think it's impossible.

Lots of redemption already happening this finals series. I'm sure the team has been crying out for an opportunity to undo the 2020 Prelim.
 
Who goes to Hawkins and Cameron? Adams usually did a pretty good job but I'm worried about what we do in these match ups if they don't work out, is it Andrews and Payne or bust, I don't think either of them match up too well on Cameron.

Could a left field idea could be McStay back if one of them get out of control?
 
2022 Geelong is no joke. They are an extremely good team.

We'll have an insane amount of belief and lots of our players are capable of pulling an insane game out of nowhere. I can see why we're not favourites but I don't think it's impossible.

Lots of redemption already happening this finals series. I'm sure the team has been crying out for an opportunity to undo the 2020 Prelim.

In summary, this is a must win danger game but also a redemption arc.
 
2022 Geelong is no joke. They are an extremely good team.

We'll have an insane amount of belief and lots of our players are capable of pulling an insane game out of nowhere. I can see why we're not favourites but I don't think it's impossible.

Lots of redemption already happening this finals series. I'm sure the team has been crying out for an opportunity to undo the 2020 Prelim.

They absolutely have been a great team, but equally I think their draw has overinflated how great they've actually been. We'd have finished top four if we got North and West Coast twice too. Not saying they aren't good or shouldn't be favourites (or flag favourites), but I think they're no harder than Melbourne. If we bring the same level of pressure as we did against the Demons, I genuinely believe we can get on top. Maybe not to a similar fashion as that game at the Gabba last year, but can see us winning by 3-4 goals if we bring the same pressure and ball movement as we did against the Demons.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

great write up!

I think in the end it will be Andrews Cameron, Gardiner Hawkins, Payne Rohan?

or maybe switch gardiner and payne and hope Rohan spent all his tickets in the Pies match.

I suspect it'll be:

Payne v Rohan
Andrews v Hawkins
Gardiner v Cameron
Starce v Stengle

When Danger rests forward, I suspect Starce will swap to him and Wilmot will go to Stengle.
 
In all honesty Geelong possibly even lucky to be here, they looked pretty rattled against Collingwood in the first half and could have been blown away if it wasn’t for inaccurate kicking. We were the most attacking side in 2022 and for me that would be the key against the Geelong, take risks and look to move the ball quickly and look to score, the boys will have plenty of belief that they are one win away from a GF after everyone wrote us off.
 
In all honesty Geelong possibly even lucky to be here, they looked pretty rattled against Collingwood in the first half and could have been blown away if it wasn’t for inaccurate kicking. We were the most attacking side in 2022 and for me that would be the key against the Geelong, take risks and look to move the ball quickly and look to score, the boys will have plenty of belief that they are one win away from a GF after everyone wrote us off.
full credit to collingwood their pressure is nutty. enough to make most teams into unforced errors. fremantle wilted horrendously under it last night, geelong looked a lot less composed than usual but managed to get the job done. if we can bring the same pressure as we did against melbourne we should be right in it
 
Yep, I watched both Collingwood finals and they were just absolutely relentless, Geelong just scraped through but they did not look comfortable at all, Freo lucky to not get belted by 10 goals. If we can emulate that pressure we are in with a huge chance, we have a much more potent attack than Collingwood.
full credit to collingwood their pressure is nutty. enough to make most teams into unforced errors. fremantle wilted horrendously under it last night, geelong looked a lot less composed than usual but managed to get the job done. if we can bring the same pressure as we did against melbourne we should be right in it
 
full credit to collingwood their pressure is nutty. enough to make most teams into unforced errors. fremantle wilted horrendously under it last night, geelong looked a lot less composed than usual but managed to get the job done. if we can bring the same pressure as we did against melbourne we should be right in it

Pressure acts:
Geelong: 334
Collingwood: 320

1 %ers:
Geelong: 47
Collingwood: 55

^ the big difference between the two teams pressure stats were Atkins and Blicavs delivering BIG pressure numbers, with Close not far off the pack. Collingwood were much more balanced, albeit less.

Pressure acts:
Brisbane: 275
Melbourne: 265

1 %ers:
Brisbane: 70
Melbourne: 44

^ less pressure acts due to the nature we forced the game to be played - fast and chaotic. What really shines through is not only did we chase, but we blocked for our team mates, shepherded, knocked the ball on and kept things going at any cost. Collingwood do so in a similar way to us, except we have the firepower up forward.

For what it's worth Collingwood had 50 1%ers last night. Unsure on pressure acts, but safe to assume they were likely similar to week one.
 
In- Robinson, Daniher
Out- J.Berry, Fullatron

B Gardiner Payne Starcevich
HB Rich Andrews K.Coleman
C Bailey Zorko Mcluaggage
HF Rayner Hipwood Ah’Chee
F Cameron Daniher McCarthy
FOLL- Omac Robertson Neale
I/C- McStay, Answerth, Wilmot, Mathieson
Sub- Robinson
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top