-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Training Preseason 2024
- Thread starter DragoDelph
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Sturty2Hurty
All Australian
- Jul 24, 2021
- 606
- 1,287
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Question for the more knowledgeable!
Have we ever had more upside players than we do this preseason?
Ie players who have a genuine chance to improve significantly on 2023… in a way we win more games because of this
Upside players are the ones that move us up the ladder and into finals if our good players keep performing.
Thoughts on the following as genuine Upside players?
Sturt
O’Meara
Darcy (vs 23 injured darcy)
Chapman
Fyfe
Sharp
Taberner (refer Darcy)
Erasmus
O’Driscoll (bring back 22 NOD!)
Frederick
Treacy
Johnson
Walker
Brodie?
Emmett?
Others?
Who to add, who to remove?
Thanks all for keeping the flame alive over summer too - learning a bucketload from most….of the posts!
I remember going into 2018 feeling the most excited I have ever felt before a season.
We had a gun full forward in Hogan. We traded in a ruck/fwd (Lobb) - the one position that killed us in ‘13.
Bennell was going to carve teams up. Walters still mid career.
2 Hills on either wing.
2 young mids in Cerra/Brayshaw to compete along with Fyfe.
Proven coach.
Cox and Darcy starting to show something.
Hamling and Pearce both gun defenders.
The list was ready.
...
What a f****** disaster. I have been so jaded during pre-seasons ever since.
To be fair to you, all those players at their peaks and playing together is a top 4 team. You forgot Mundy too.
DocT
Club Legend
- Sep 4, 2022
- 1,014
- 2,173
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Purple Jesus
not jess
Yep, had the right idea for a decent side, but it was 'greedy' and the mistake was topping up to reload and go again instead of accepting we needed to rebuild completely in 2016.
Compared to 2023, all they need to do is not get injured for 6-8 weeks straight;(
Thats a pretty good list!
How much mana do Freo need to have in the bank?
Yep, many of them weren't at their peaks. Andy and Cerra were still babies, Lobb was never that good and Hogan...
2019 hurt worse for me.
In the top 8 halfway through the year and dropped out because of pretty much every player over 195cm getting injured.
I think Sturty2Hurty meant 2019.
We didn’t have some of the players mentioned in that post in 2018.
Honestly I think Ross Lyon got sacked because we underperformed with a top eight list in 2019. At least that’s what the people who made the decision thought.
Longmuir got some time to build the list and game plan up again, bearing in mind we lost both wingers at the end of that season putting us back a bit. It also took us another two seasons to get some of the careers Jason Weber nearly destroyed back on track.
I don’t care how many excuses we can make now for Longmuir. He’s had this list for four years and it will be five end of this year:
- Neesham got four years
- Harvey got four years
- Connolly would’ve been sacked in 2006 (his fifth year) had we not made finals. There was talk of that happening until we won nine in row and went from outside the eight mid season to top four at the end of it.
- Lyon got four years after finals and I daresay his contract we probably the main reason he got as long as he did.
- It isn’t worth mentioning our other coaches.
**** the excuses - for any valid excuse there’s a reason why it exists and Longmuir could be somewhat responsible for most of them. It’s time to deliver or it’s time to move on.
Nailed it.
No serious organisation would be extending this coaches contract if we have another bottom 6 finish and are out of contention again by early July.
Five years is a LIFETIME in the context of an AFL club list. Over half the list changes in that timeframe.
It’s time for JL to deliver significant progress in 2024 or move aside and let someone else have a crack. It’s a defining year for him.
- Jul 20, 2018
- 1,651
- 3,009
I'm more confident with bell not there that they'll make the hard call on JLo if he doesn't perform
With bell, I'd expect a 2 year extension as JLo is an ex player and there's sentiment there
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
With bell, I'd expect a 2 year extension as JLo is an ex player and there's sentiment there
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I get nervous with the rumours that we are after McDonald and using 2
first rounders.
A first and second rounder maybe, but it always feels like we are focused on
the future.
It’s always which player will lift the club. Why is a team of champions our only
avenue?
It’s got to be a combination of talent/hardwork/ingenuity.
This preseason we will see if all 3 have been implemented.
King Huskii
Norm Smith Medallist
- Apr 19, 2022
- 8,155
- 12,223
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
I don't want it to cost us the farm but Sydney will play hard ball especially if West Coast put forward an offer.
Out of contract obviously helps.
He is no champion and quick fix though. Logan's 2024 season will help set his value. I think he is worth a top 10 pick and a late 1st if he continues to develop his game at the expected rate.
You would expect Walls would look at this year's draft and see predict if he would be a better player long term than the player or players expected at the draft picks that are required to trade for him.
Logan could be anything and also a long term player for us. Both he and Amiss could be the version of Cameron and Hawkins without the figjam.
It would also depend on the long term view of Tracey and his development this season.
- Jul 20, 2018
- 1,651
- 3,009
2 firsts is fine if we get a second back
The concern for me is salary
Building a premiership team has players accepting unders from what they could get to go elsewhere
Keep poaching players and paying out big contracts - you'll ask the question too many times for players to accept unders.. and they'll walk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
The concern for me is salary
Building a premiership team has players accepting unders from what they could get to go elsewhere
Keep poaching players and paying out big contracts - you'll ask the question too many times for players to accept unders.. and they'll walk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
- Dec 6, 2020
- 3,579
- 7,613
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Last updated: Sunday 7 January 2024
Session Type
Main Training
Date
Thursday 11 January
Time
9am
Location
Victor George Kailis Oval (Cockburn ARC)
Would you have traded Hayden young (a year ago) for a first and a second?
Logan - 2020 pick 4, showing great signs at AFL level
(2022) Young - 2019 pick 7, showing great signs at AFL level
There's no way I would've traded Young for that, people who are offering anything less than 2 1sts are absolutely dreaming
So what did we get from Carlton for Cerra?
A pick 5, but out of contract player.
Swings and roundabouts.
That deal should've been two first rounders with a second coming back. That's the going rate for a midfielder that has the potential to be in the competition's top 20 mids.
Bell and co have the reputation of being hard at the trade but are actually soft as butter. The Cerra trade is almost a sackable offence imo.
We got bent for cerra
I'm not sure if it was due to covid list cuts the year before affecting the market (and covid continuing thru 2021) but it's clear we got absolutely bent over there
Thank **** that pick ended up being Amiss
- Sep 30, 2013
- 796
- 1,581
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Montreal Canadiens
Gotta say, I'm not sure I buy the "players don't want to come to Cockburn" argument. It's a very nice facility, and you can easily live in Freo (wonderful lifestyle) and just pop down there for your day job, taking 20 minutes or less in the car. It's not like players need to live in Cockburn. Heaps of nice spots within 30 minutes.
flyingblind
Draftee
- Nov 15, 2019
- 10
- 23
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Completely agree. If we take off the purple tinted glasses for a sec, it would be hard to see how Sydney would value McDonald any differently to what we would expect to get for Amiss. Two firsts would be the minimum to get to done unfortunately
