Proposal to include premierships dating back to 1870 gathering pace

[sherb]

Clubs can record history however they like, but the league should stick to it's own history only.

Exactly. It really is as simple as that.

 

[PhatBoy]

You said you wanted them included in a separate tally/classification. Which they already are as VFA flags.

As well as being included in the total tally.

I’m honestly sick to death of Geelong people’s superiority complex tbh. You guys get so many advantages already and you are still greedy for more even wanting to change tallies to suit you.

I guarantee if Geelong didn’t win any VFA flags you’d be arguing against it.

I know I’m not the only person that thinks this.

I don’t want any extra flags included in any tally.

But the spinelessness of this advantage bullshit you pump out post after post just emphasises how weak as a fan you actually are.

 

[MelbourneGWS]

All flags count - in the competition they were won in.

Cats are free to combine VFA, VFL & AFL flags in their combined tally - but that does not make them all AFL flags.

But the AFL counts VFL premierships officially to the number of flags won by AFL clubs. Colin’s argument is that VFA flags won before the start of the VFL in 1897 should also be officially added?

 

[Cyclops]

Col doesn't want to turn old VFA Premierships into VFL or AFL ones. He just wants them to be formally recognised as Premierships by the AFL, and thus, added to the official tallies of Premierships won by the clubs. Like is the case with English Football Titles.

 

[Wojcinski]

You said you wanted them included in a separate tally/classification. Which they already are as VFA flags.

As well as being included in the total tally.

I’m honestly sick to death of Geelong people’s superiority complex tbh. You guys get so many advantages already and you are still greedy for more even wanting to change tallies to suit you.

I guarantee if Geelong didn’t win any VFA flags you’d be arguing against it.

I know I’m not the only person that thinks this.

and yet of your 5530 posts on this account 5218 of them are either in Geelong related threads or mention Geelong/its players. I'd be sick of Geelong too if all I did was obsess over them on an internet forum

 

[Cleansweep17]

and yet of your 5530 posts on this account 5218 of them are either in Geelong related threads or mention Geelong/its players. I'd be sick of Geelong too if all I did was obsess over them on an internet forum

Looking up other people’s post counts is what children do. You can go be a mute somewhere else I like talking.

 

[sherb]

Not sure why it's so hard to change it if doesn't doesn't really matter? Restoring history does matter for some of us, even if we are in the minority.

The history is there for you already, there's nothing to restore.

Geelong Football Club - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

 

[rapidfire7]

One thing is clear, there's gonna be a full on meltdown when this eventually gets over the line.

 

[Cleansweep17]

One thing is clear, there's gonna be a full on meltdown when this eventually gets over the line.

And you’ll be sooking forever because it won’t.