Rate my SuperCoach team 2012

[Ed_Gein]

Oh ok didn't realise that.
Thanks for the info ED

brad crouch is the other one that won't be able to play in 2012, but will be eligible in 2013, like o'meara.

 

[Nasty Penguin]

Defenders
Brendon Goddard Brett Deledio Matt Suckling Dyson Heppell Brian Lake Brandon Ellis Will Sierakowski
(Luke Brown Beau Wilkes)

Midfielders
Scott Pendlebury, Gary Ablett, Matt Priddis, Joel Selwood, Bryce Gibbs Chad Wingard
(Kyal Horsley Elliott Kavanagh)

Rucks
Matthew Leuenberger Jonathan Giles
(Sam Rowe Orren Stephensen)

Forwards
Lance Franklin, Dustin Martin, David Zaharakis, Nick Riewoldt, Jed Lamb, Dayne Zorko, Adam Treloar.
(Tory Dickson, Sam Kerridge)

Another shot only my second draft. Keep getting sucked into all the puff pieces on players and trying to fit em all in Also trying not to be bomber biased.

 

[tomemy]

Backs:
B.Goddard, B.Deledio, H.Shaw, C.Enright, G.Broughton, M.Suckling, M.Buntine (L.Spurr, B.Wilkes)

Mids:
G.Ablett, D.Shiel, C.Wingard, S.Clifton, D.Pfeiffer, A.Treloar (J.McDonald, L.Brown)

Rucks:
S.Mumford, J.Gilles (O.Stephenson, S.Rowe)

Forwards:
L.Franklin, P.Chapman, D.Martin, T.Cloke, D.Zaharakis, N.Riewoldt, J.Brown (D.Zorko, T.Walsh)

 

[Goats]

Hi guys.How does this team look?....(be gentle with me) Salary cap left: $49,200.

Brendon Goddard, Heath Shaw, Corey Enright, Jack Grimes, Shaun McKernan, Matthew Buntine, Marty Clarke
Paul Bower, Jack Hombsch

Scott Pendlebury, Dane Swan, Marc Murphy, Adam Goodes, Stephen Coniglio, Nick Haynes
Sam Reid, Jaeger O'Meara

Aaron Sandilands, Trent West
Jonathan Giles, Orren Stephenson

Lance Franklin, Travis Cloke, David Zaharakis, Jonathan Brown, Adam Tomlinson, Alik Magin, Israel Folau
Ahmed Saad, Amos Frank

I know a bit of Colingwood love in there and some people might say Israel WTF!?
But he will play from round 1 and i think he will surprise many......but hey this is a rough,rough copy.

Amos Frank is extremely unlikely to play the first couple of rounds with Hawks playing Collingwood then Geelong. However Clarkson has said he is a chance to play senior games this year, might be a good downgrade later on.

As with all rookies, NAB Cup performances will be very telling.

 

[longytap]

My rough draft pre NAB cup.
Decided to go light on premiums in the backs to start, due to my lack of confidence in any of them barring Lids,Goddard and Enright

Goodes or Buddy is my other headache

Brendon Goddard, Brett Deledio, Corey Enright, Brian Lake, Marty Clarke, Tim Mohr, Steven Morris
Billie Smedts, Beau Wilkes

Gary Ablett jnr, Marc Murphy, Jobe Watson, Michael Barlow, Dayne Zorko, Dylan Shiel
Luke Brown, James McDonald

Nic Naitanui, Jonathan Giles
Josh Jenkins, Orren Stephenson

Adam Goodes, Paul Chapman, Dustin Martin, David Zaharakis, Nick Riewoldt, Steele Sidebottom, Jonathan Brown
Adam Treloar, Tory Dickson

Rip it to shreds lads!!!

 

[BlueGibbs2011]

My rough draft pre NAB cup.
Decided to go light on premiums in the backs to start, due to my lack of confidence in any of them barring Lids,Goddard and Enright

Goodes or Buddy is my other headache

Brendon Goddard, Brett Deledio, Corey Enright, Brian Lake, Marty Clarke, Tim Mohr, Steven Morris
Billie Smedts, Beau Wilkes

Gary Ablett jnr, Marc Murphy, Jobe Watson, Michael Barlow, Dayne Zorko, Dylan Shiel
Luke Brown, James McDonald

Nic Naitanui, Jonathan Giles
Josh Jenkins, Orren Stephenson

Adam Goodes, Paul Chapman, Dustin Martin, David Zaharakis, Nick Riewoldt, Steele Sidebottom, Jonathan Brown
Adam Treloar, Tory Dickson

Rip it to shreds lads!!!

Nice team longy!

You could probably look for better balance and start 1 rookie in your forwards. Here you have all keepers and left little room in event that 1-2 others become the best fwd, e.g. Buddy, Rioli, or Cloke, You always need to save a space in event thy kill it over your keepers.

IN your mids you have Watson and Barlow. To me that is two risks on players who have been injured. I'd only plump for 1 or the other. But I do understand that gives you the value for your midfield.

Like your ruck and its PoD

Your defence looks a little light on and could lose you quite a bit of points but can recognise you prefer the fwd keepers.

Overall, different and a good team.

 

[Watsclarkosmob]

TheAdrenlines Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by hellnwheel. Salary cap left: $14,000.

Heath Scotland, Brett Deledio, Brian Lake, Andrejs Everitt, Ben Stratton, Karmichael Hunt, Tom Gillies
Marty Clarke, Steven Morris

Chris Judd, Luke Hodge, Jimmy Bartel, Jordan Lewis, Lenny Hayes, Shaun Atley
Claye Beams, Anthony Morabito

Matthew Leuenberger, Robert Warnock
Majak Daw, Orren Stephenson

Dustin Martin, Drew Petrie, Travis Varcoe, Alex Fasolo, Jack Gunston, John Butcher, Jason Porplyzia
Tommy Walsh, Amos Frank


any feed back is welcome...

 

[Super Hans]

Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Broughton, Hanley, Buntine, Ellis
(Spurr, Wilkes)

Ablett, Murphy, Selwood, Coniglio, Wingard, Stevens
(L.Brown, Horsely)

Mumford, Kruezer
(Giles, Stephenson)

Franklin, Chapman, Martin, Zaharakis, Mccaffer, Zorko, Walsh
(Teloar, Panos)

 

[cdonny]

TheAdrenlines Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by hellnwheel. Salary cap left: $14,000.

Heath Scotland, Brett Deledio, Brian Lake, Andrejs Everitt, Ben Stratton, Karmichael Hunt, Tom Gillies
Marty Clarke, Steven Morris

Chris Judd, Luke Hodge, Jimmy Bartel, Jordan Lewis, Lenny Hayes, Shaun Atley
Claye Beams, Anthony Morabito

Matthew Leuenberger, Robert Warnock
Majak Daw, Orren Stephenson

Dustin Martin, Drew Petrie, Travis Varcoe, Alex Fasolo, Jack Gunston, John Butcher, Jason Porplyzia
Tommy Walsh, Amos Frank


any feed back is welcome...

I didn't see Goddard listed first up in DEF, so was thinking 'wtf!?'... kept going, saw Everitt... then K.Hunt

Scrap it all, and start again. Harsh, I'm sorry... but this team will get you nowhere really fast!

 

[cotter101]

Brendon Goddard, Brett Deledio, Sam Fisher, Josh Drummond, Brian Lake, Matthew Buntine, Paul Bower
(Sam Docherty, Luke Brown)

Gary Ablett jnr, Chris Judd, Jobe Watson, Jack Ziebell, Josh Caddy, Stephen Coniglio
(Dom Tyson, Stephen Clifton)

Dean Cox, Matthew Kreuzer
(Jonathan Giles, Orren Stephenson)

Lance Franklin, Steve Johnson, Paul Chapman, Jonathan Brown, Israel Folau, Ahmed Saad, Dayne Zorko
(Sam Kerridge, Sam Rowe)

Rough team still needs some work, Would love opinions.

 

[jockreynolds]

Interesting to see the spread of teams with or without Nick Riewoldt is about 50/50 - could be a real season definer that choice.
Each to his own but my call is still to get on him - there will be no repeat of 2011 for Roo. Higgo still reckons he's not touching him in 2012.. we'll see ey.

 

[sparkyblue]

Waiting for preseason before deciding on NRoo....there's a large percentage of folk who think he's done.

 

[Daniels]

Watch Roo kick 3-5 vs Bombers Round 2 of NAB Cup and all of a sudden he will be straight back in a lot of sides. Probably me included

 

[nugget_12]

XXXR8D Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by nugz12. Salary cap left: $14,900.

Brendon Goddard, Heath Scotland, Greg Broughton, Matt Suckling, Jack Grimes, Matthew Buntine, Brandon Ellis
Steven Morris, Billie Smedts

Joel Selwood, Scott Thompson, Brett Deledio, Leigh Montagna, Michael Barlow, Dylan Shiel
James McDonald, Tom Mitchell

Matthew Kreuzer, Jonathan Giles
Sam Rowe, Orren Stephenson

Paul Chapman, Dustin Martin, Jordan Lewis, Mark LeCras, Steele Sidebottom, Jason Porplyzia, Adam Treloar
Tommy Walsh, Dayne Zorko

 

[Jordie_tackles]

XXXR8D Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by nugz12. Salary cap left: $14,900.

Brendon Goddard, Heath Scotland, Greg Broughton, Matt Suckling, Jack Grimes, Matthew Buntine, Brandon Ellis
Steven Morris, Billie Smedts

Joel Selwood, Scott Thompson, Brett Deledio, Leigh Montagna, Michael Barlow, Dylan Shiel
James McDonald, Tom Mitchell

Matthew Kreuzer, Jonathan Giles
Sam Rowe, Orren Stephenson

Paul Chapman, Dustin Martin, Jordan Lewis, Mark LeCras, Steele Sidebottom, Jason Porplyzia, Adam Treloar
Tommy Walsh, Dayne Zorko

Reasonably solid team,

I had similar range mids but couldnt go in without a reliable captains pick, "lock and load"

I think you lack this, also your rucks are obviously lacking, cant say Giles or the Big O will always be playing imo

 

[nugget_12]

Reasonably solid team,

I had similar range mids but couldnt go in without a reliable captains pick, "lock and load"

I think you lack this, also your rucks are obviously lacking, cant say Giles or the Big O will always be playing imo

Nah i agree! im still playing around at the moment! and looking at potential upgrades if all goes well in putting Deledio back into defence after rd13 bye and then having 2 upgrade premium spots in the middle for the likes of GAJ or Pendles/swan etc etc

As for Captain i like to not have the lock and load and have options and with Selwood/Montagna/thompson etc etc i have that!

Trying to find a nice combo for cover for the byes is making it a little difficult!

Rucks ill work on but i may try get a little cash out of Giles/Stephenson then upgrading to a premium to go along with Kreuz!

Not enough money! haha
Cheers mate!

 

[Pie 4 Life]

The Repeaters
Salary cap left: $19,100.

Brendon Goddard, Heath Shaw, Corey Enright, Jack Grimes, Brian Lake, Marty Clarke, Paul Bower
Billie Smedts, Beau Wilkes

Dale Thomas, James Kelly, Michael Barlow, Luke Hodge, Lenny Hayes, James McDonald
Tom Mitchell, Sebastian Ross

Matthew Leuenberger, Hamish McIntosh
Orren Stephenson, Jarrod Witts

Lance Franklin, Dayne Beams, Nick Riewoldt, Travis Varcoe, Alan Didak, Jason Winderlich, Jason Porplyzia
Tommy Walsh, Dayne Zorko

Have gone for a few bargains and cash cows in the hope they come off (Didak/McIntosh/Porps/Bower/Lake), particularly looking to make it solid around the park without haveing too many expensive mids.

Thoughts?

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Interesting to see the spread of teams with or without Nick Riewoldt is about 50/50 - could be a real season definer that choice.
Each to his own but my call is still to get on him - there will be no repeat of 2011 for Roo. Higgo still reckons he's not touching him in 2012.. we'll see ey.

Was a definite for me. Great value for money. Will watch NAB Cup closely, but he'll no doubt be in there providing he doesn't get injured.

 

[Jordie_tackles]

Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Suckling, Grimes, M Clarke, B Ellis, Spurr, Hombsch

Pendlebury, Murphy, Selwood, Coniglio, Clifton, Shiel, Kavanagh, Mitchell

Leunberger, Kreuzer, Giles, O

Franklin, Martin, Riewoldt, Riewoldt, Watts, D Smith, Walsh, Treloar, Zorko

Thoughts?

i have 172K in the bank so some room to move, just cant decide where....

Thanks

 

[Jordie_tackles]

Which looks better?

Team 1:


Brendon Goddard, Brett Deledio, Sam Fisher, Josh Drummond, Brian Lake, Matthew Buntine, Paul Bower
(Sam Docherty, Luke Brown)

Gary Ablett jnr, Chris Judd, Jobe Watson, Jack Ziebell, Josh Caddy, Stephen Coniglio
(Dom Tyson, Stephen Clifton)

Dean Cox, Matthew Kreuzer
(Jonathan Giles, Orren Stephenson)

Lance Franklin, Steve Johnson, Paul Chapman, Jonathan Brown, Israel Folau, Ahmed Saad, Dayne Zorko
(Sam Kerridge, Sam Rowe)


OR Team 2

Brendon Goddard, Brett Deledio, Jack Grimes, Nathan Grima, Josh Drummond, Matthew Buntine, Paul Bower
Nathan Blee, Luke Brown

Gary Ablett jnr, Sam Mitchell, Jobe Watson, Michael Barlow, Josh Caddy, Brad McKenzie
Mitchell Grigg, James McDonald

Dean Cox, Ivan Maric
Jonathan Giles, Orren Stephenson

Lance Franklin, Steve Johnson, Paul Chapman, David Zaharakis, Jonathan Brown, Brad Dick, Dayne Zorko
Sam Rowe, Cory Dell'Olio

Or Team 3

Brendon Goddard, Brett Deledio, Matt Suckling, Josh Drummond, Brian Lake, Matthew Buntine, Marty Clarke
Billie Smedts, Luke Brown

Gary Ablett jnr, Dane Swan, Jobe Watson, Michael Barlow, Brad McKenzie, Mitchell Grigg
James McDonald, Tom Mitchell

Dean Cox, Sam Jacobs
Jonathan Giles, Orren Stephenson

Lance Franklin, Dustin Martin, David Zaharakis, Jonathan Brown, Allen Christensen, Darren Pfeiffer, Tommy Walsh
Dayne Zorko, Sam Rowe

Maybe highlight the differences, just so much to look at

 

[cotter101]

Team 1:

Brendon Goddard, Brett Deledio, Matt Suckling, Josh Drummond, Brian Lake, Matthew Buntine, Marty Clarke
Billie Smedts, Luke Brown

Gary Ablett jnr, Dane Swan, Jobe Watson, Michael Barlow, Brad McKenzie, Mitchell Grigg
James McDonald, Tom Mitchell

Dean Cox, Sam Jacobs
Jonathan Giles, Orren Stephenson

Lance Franklin, Dustin Martin, David Zaharakis, Jonathan Brown, Allen Christensen, Darren Pfeiffer, Tommy Walsh
Dayne Zorko, Sam Rowe

Team 2:

Heath Shaw, Sam Fisher, Corey Enright, Greg Broughton, Matt Suckling, Matthew Buntine, Luke Brown
Beau Wilkes, Steve Wrigley

Gary Ablett jnr, Sam Mitchell, Jobe Watson, Michael Barlow, Stephen Clifton, Dayne Zorko
Mitchell Grigg, Sam Kerridge

Dean Cox, Trent West
Jonathan Giles, Orren Stephenson

Lance Franklin, Paul Chapman, Brent Harvey, David Zaharakis, Shannon Byrnes, Darren Pfeiffer, Tommy Walsh
Sam Rowe, Tom Couch


Which one should I continue working with?

 

[Jordie_tackles]

Team 1:

Brendon Goddard, Brett Deledio, Matt Suckling, Josh Drummond, Brian Lake, Matthew Buntine, Marty Clarke
Billie Smedts, Luke Brown

Gary Ablett jnr, Dane Swan, Jobe Watson, Michael Barlow, Brad McKenzie, Mitchell Grigg
James McDonald, Tom Mitchell

Dean Cox, Sam Jacobs
Jonathan Giles, Orren Stephenson

Lance Franklin, Dustin Martin, David Zaharakis, Jonathan Brown, Allen Christensen, Darren Pfeiffer, Tommy Walsh
Dayne Zorko, Sam Rowe

Team 2:

Heath Shaw, Sam Fisher, Corey Enright, Greg Broughton, Matt Suckling, Matthew Buntine, Luke Brown
Beau Wilkes, Steve Wrigley

Gary Ablett jnr, Sam Mitchell, Jobe Watson, Michael Barlow, Stephen Clifton, Dayne Zorko
Mitchell Grigg, Sam Kerridge

Dean Cox, Trent West
Jonathan Giles, Orren Stephenson

Lance Franklin, Paul Chapman, Brent Harvey, David Zaharakis, Shannon Byrnes, Darren Pfeiffer, Tommy Walsh
Sam Rowe, Tom Couch


Which one should I continue working with?

I think that i prefer the second one

Liked team 1's forwards and Jacobs over West, but liked team 2's midfield and defense....

Both have the extra money spent in different areas...

 

[cotter101]

I think that i prefer the second one

Liked team 1's forwards and Jacobs over West, but liked team 2's midfield and defense....

Both have the extra money spent in different areas...

Agree on Jacobs over West sadly I don't have the cash.

Who do you think is a better 2ndr uck option out of: Trent West, Shaun Hampson, Ivan Maric(Bound for lots of game time), Hamish McIntosh(Would be McIntosh but they have Goldy now) or Tom Derickx(Risky)

Thanks.

 

[Jordie_tackles]

Agree on Jacobs over West sadly I don't have the cash.

Who do you think is a better 2ndr uck option out of: Trent West, Shaun Hampson, Ivan Maric(Bound for lots of game time), Hamish McIntosh(Would be McIntosh but they have Goldy now) or Tom Derickx(Risky)

Thanks.

I have thought about Maric myself, scored about 70 in the past 4 years...26 could do things, will definitely be Richmonds first ruck as they traded for him, if your going for a 2nd tier second ruck, i am goign Kreuzer at this stage then you will only be talking about 10-15 ppg really max

I would go Maric over West

 

[hess]

The Repeaters
Salary cap left: $19,100.

Brendon Goddard, Heath Shaw, Corey Enright, Jack Grimes, Brian Lake, Marty Clarke, Paul Bower
Billie Smedts, Beau Wilkes

Dale Thomas, James Kelly, Michael Barlow, Luke Hodge, Lenny Hayes, James McDonald
Tom Mitchell, Sebastian Ross

Matthew Leuenberger, Hamish McIntosh
Orren Stephenson, Jarrod Witts

Lance Franklin, Dayne Beams, Nick Riewoldt, Travis Varcoe, Alan Didak, Jason Winderlich, Jason Porplyzia
Tommy Walsh, Dayne Zorko

Have gone for a few bargains and cash cows in the hope they come off (Didak/McIntosh/Porps/Bower/Lake), particularly looking to make it solid around the park without haveing too many expensive mids.

Thoughts?

Nothing hugely wrong with the team but for a number of reasons it is likely to fall short if you're gunning for overall ranking. On the plus side theres some uniqueness in the squad so if you nail the selections theres some upside there.
All depends on how well your second-tier premiums turn out. If they all improve a level you're laughing if not you'll do ok but struggle to make a real impact.
Defence and forwards are pretty standard. Still heavy on the midpricers and light on rookies which is obviously why you're short a super-premium or two.
Your overall midfield mix is where you fall behind the eight-ball.

The weak links area s follows
- Thomas as your leading mid. Nothing against Daisy but leaves your mids short on firepower. You need him to have a big season to set you up.
- James Kelly, at his age he is unlikely to find a new level. His current level is ok, but for using up a spot in your mids where you need to generate some big points he's a liability and will impede your final result.
- Varocoe's a bit of a roughie, in an awkward price range he has enoough ability to turn out the 95+ average you're going to need but he's a risk. Your other option is to downgrade Winders and to a rookie and upgrade Varcoe to a premium, makes your team to the more standard structure.

In short you'll need to burn a fair few trades to upgrade this team to a top 500-1000 level Kelly finds a previously unsuggested new level and both Varcoe and Daisy have blinders.