Rate my team Part III

[Sw3Et]

I would definately trade out one of the two for a rookie (bastinac comes to mind) put shuey on the ground because he is a scoring machine. And then use the left over money to upgrade a back or forward.

This is my team so far, definately not finalised.

Backs: GODdard, Hargrave, Enright, Hodge, M. Brown, Hunt, Waters (Sheppard, Lisle)

Mids: Bartel, Gibbs, Mitchell, Masten, Martin, Shuey (Banner, Barlow)

Rucks: Clark, Naitanui (Warnock, Lobbe)

Forwards: Reiwoldt, J. Brown, Pavlich, Petrie, Franklin, Dangerfield, Hitchcock/Stewart (TDL, Gumby)

My main problem is forward line depth. I think I'll have a play around with it but would love some feedback for now

 

[weagles_fan]

First ever go at a DT

Backs: Cornes, Hodge, Mattner, Bower, Hurn, Myers, Ladson (Maguire, Davies)
Mids: Bartel, Gibbs, Boak, Higgins, Masten, Martin (Banner, Lucas)
Rucks: Hille, Kreuzer (Warnock, Currie)
Forwards: Reiwoldt, Pavlich, Harvey, Franklin, Waite, Yarran, Veszpremi (Davis, Podsiadly)

Any glaringly obvious problems?

Cornes? Injury prone the last few years isn't getting any younger. Bower not a dter. Put Higgins in the forward. Too many Carlton players.

 

[theone5]

Because he's young improving and has a permanent spot in the Adelaide midfield. He will go up in price, sure he might not be a keeper but at his price with a spot every week in the middle he's hard to go past.

Adelaide probably has the most competitive midfield in the league.
A tonne of players who rotate through there...i would not say it is permanent.

 

[RichoGun]

Hey guys i made a change and wondering if anyone thought it was a good move or not.

I got rid of Joel Selwood and replaced him with Deledio which allowed me to get Gia instead of Medhurst in the forward line now i have 30k in the bank to upgrade when season starts?

Thoughts?

 

[Dr Awkward]

Because he's young improving and has a permanent spot in the Adelaide midfield. He will go up in price, sure he might not be a keeper but at his price with a spot every week in the middle he's hard to go past.

He definately won't be a keeper. He would have to raise is avg by almost 40 points.

 

[WCE_Phill]

Richo, i would have keep J.Selwood as i think he'll tear it up this year but thats just my opinion. Maybe downgrade someone else to change medhurst to gia.

Heres my final team, barring any injuries or surprise selections round 1.

Backs: Goodard, Enright, Hodge, Waite, Ladson, Hunt, Waters (McGuire, Trengove)

Midfeild: Bartel, Gibbs, Masten, Trengove, Martin, Shuey (Jetta, Banner)

Rucks: Sandi, Hille (Lobbe, Warnock)

Forwards: Roo, ROK, Brown, Pavlich, Higgins, Franklin, Ziebell (TDL, Gumbelton)

86k in bank*

 

[Cynic]

Heres my final team, barring any injuries or surprise selections round 1.

Backs: Goodard, Enright, Hodge, Waite, Ladson, Hunt, Waters (McGuire, Trengove)

Midfeild: Bartel, Gibbs, Masten, Trengove, Martin, Shuey (Jetta, Banner)

Rucks: Sandi, Hille (Lobbe, Warnock)

Forwards: Roo, ROK, Brown, Pavlich, Higgins, Franklin, Ziebell (TDL, Gumbelton)

86k in bank*

I'd swap Waite to Hargrave/Shaw/Fisher. Having Waite, Ladson, Hunt & Waters in the same backline is a recipe for zeros without a lot of luck I would imagine.

 

[WCE_Phill]

I'd swap Waite to Hargrave/Shaw/Fisher. Having Waite, Ladson, Hunt & Waters in the same backline is a recipe for zeros without a lot of luck I would imagine.

Fair point, who would score better out of Hargrave and Fisher, i refuse to have Shaw in my team ;p

What do you think of the rest of the field?

 

[Cynic]

Fair point, who would score better out of Hargrave and Fisher, i refuse to have Shaw in my team ;p

What do you think of the rest of the field?

My money would be on Hargrave as it stands.

Rest of your squad is fine, 14 keepers including Masten, only area you'd be worried about is of course your midfield but you can't cover all your bases and have that many keepers.

 

[kez379]

This is my team any feedback / improvements would be greatly appreciated thanks

Backs
S Fisher
Adcock
Hodge
H Shaw
Malceski
Ladson
Waters

Davis
Trengove

Centres
Pendlebury
S Thompson
Cooney
Masten
Mcveigh
Morabito

Shuey
Banner

Ruck
Sandilands
Naitanui

Lobbe
Warnock

Forwards
Reiwoldt
Sylvia
Pavlich
B Harvey
Giansiricusa
Dangerfield
Rockliff

Gumbleton
Dennis Lane

 

[JuddCousinsKerr]

I'd probably question the following players:
Adcock - had some injury troubles last year, think there is better value elsewhere
Malceski - struggled to get back to the form he showed before the knee op and also Kenelly may take possessions from him playing that running HB role
Morabito - think he is overpriced and pulled up sore in the NAB cup game, I'd look at Bastinac for a cheaper option or Martin as a similar priced option

Other than that it look good to me

Here's my team - appreciate any and all feedback - Thanks

Enright - S.Fisher - H Shaw - B Waters
J Harbrow - T Kennelly - R Ladson
P Davis - A Smith

J Selwood - S Mitchell - P Dangerfield
A Cooney - L Ball - C Masten
L Shuey - R Bastinac

D Hille - NicNat
R Warnock - J Trengove

N Riewoldt - ROK - S Higgins - J Ziebell
L Franklin - J Roughead - P Medhurst
C Hitchcock - TDL

 

[Dunn - Well Done]

That team you have put is a bit extreme. As long as you have at least 2 premium keepers in each position then I dont really think it matters. If you think there is more value in a certain position then maybe dont get too many keepers in that possie.

If you look at the person who won dream team last year they didnt have many midpricers. I assume a midpricer is someone between about 200 and 360ish.

Thus balance, you answered it for yourself

If you look at SD, his midprice strategy has netted him something along the lines of 5 top 100 finishes. Proof that this strategy can work, however it is becoming a little out dated IMO. Alot of people on this forum said they were going to be selecting a midprice strategy but its amazing how people dont follow through with there word.

LOL. This team with say 1 or 2 different players has been posted a million times on here.

2 different players is a lot IMO. you'll find with DT experience over the years that 2 or 3 different players can change rankings greatly, obviousily trades play apart but the initial side effects the trades.

Also if you could find me one before that that has less than 2 differences at of the 30 it would be appreciated.

 

[indieswan96]

I'd probably question the following players:
Adcock - had some injury troubles last year, think there is better value elsewhere
Malceski - struggled to get back to the form he showed before the knee op and also Kenelly may take possessions from him playing that running HB role
Morabito - think he is overpriced and pulled up sore in the NAB cup game, I'd look at Bastinac for a cheaper option or Martin as a similar priced option

Other than that it look good to me

Here's my team - appreciate any and all feedback - Thanks

Enright - S.Fisher - H Shaw - B Waters
J Harbrow - T Kennelly - R Ladson
P Davis - A Smith

J Selwood - S Mitchell - P Dangerfield
A Cooney - L Ball - C Masten
L Shuey - R Bastinac

D Hille - NicNat
R Warnock - J Trengove

N Riewoldt - ROK - S Higgins - J Ziebell
L Franklin - J Roughead - P Medhurst
C Hitchcock - TDL

Not sure whether Nic Nat is a solid DTer and your rucks are questionable you probably should downgrade Roughead or Higgins to get a more solid combo. Otherwise good team.
Here's mine:

Backs: J Gram - C Enright - L Hodge - H Shaw - N Suban - T Kennelly - J Hunt EMG: M Macguire - P Davis

Midfield: L Montagna - J Bartel - J Selwood - J Mcveigh - D Martin - L Shuey EMG: L Jetta - R Bastinac

Rucks: A Sandilands - D Hille EMG: R Warnock - M Lobbe

Forwards: A Goodes - ROK - J Brown - M Pavlich - L Franklin - P Dangerfield - T Rockliff EMG: TDL - J Podsiadly
Feedback appreciated

 

[Spoony]

This is my team any feedback / improvements would be greatly appreciated thanks

Backs
S Fisher
Adcock
Hodge
H Shaw
Malceski
Ladson
Waters

Davis
Trengove

Centres
Pendlebury
S Thompson
Cooney
Masten
Mcveigh
Morabito

Shuey
Banner

Ruck
Sandilands
Naitanui

Lobbe
Warnock

Forwards
Reiwoldt
Sylvia
Pavlich
B Harvey
Giansiricusa
Dangerfield
Rockliff

Gumbleton
Dennis Lane

Backs are good, but im not to keen on waters i would try and upgrade him
Mids are fine but change moribito to martin
Rucks- i dont like Natanui as a DTer change him to tippet
Foward- dont like sartinf with rockcliff there is a player who is better for like 2k less.

 

[Jorda5910]

Backs: J Gram - C Enright - L Hodge - H Shaw - N Suban - T Kennelly - J Hunt EMG: M Macguire - P Davis

Midfield: L Montagna - J Bartel - J Selwood - J Mcveigh - D Martin - L Shuey EMG: L Jetta - R Bastinac

Rucks: A Sandilands - D Hille EMG: R Warnock - M Lobbe

Forwards: A Goodes - ROK - J Brown - M Pavlich - L Franklin - P Dangerfield - T Rockliff EMG: TDL - J Podsiadly
Feedback appreciated

Backs looks pretty solid, i wouldnt pick maguire, u might get 40's each week at best. Try find someone who might make a bit more money, maybe a trengrove or webberly.
IMO Montagna wont be able to keep up the average he managed last year, but thats just me. Also I'd feel safer starting trengove over shuey, and moving shuey to the pine.
Rucks are alright, i'm sure u know the risks with hille.
Forwards are good just make sure your confident in your rookies starting.

 

[Jorda5910]

about 15k left over

 

[indieswan96]

about 15k left over

Uprgrade Higgings to Pav if you can.
Armitigae most likely will not play 22 so downgrade him to maybe Mackay or Ziebell to free up some cash.
If you choose to downgrade to Ziebell upgrade Yarran to Dangerfield and if you don't downgrade to Ziebell swap Warren for Dangerfield.
Rhys Shaw's input will be not as big with Malceski and Kennelly back so maybe exchange him for Adcock or maybe Carrazo.
And finally make Selwood your vice - captain not that it matters.

 

[careyrips(I)]

My Team
Backs
Goddard, Fisher, Hodge, Shaw, Malceski, Kennely, Ladson (Trengrove, Webberly)

Mids
Bartel, Mitchell, S. Thompson, Masten, Trengrove, Martin (Shuey, Bastinac)

Rucks
Sandi, Tippet (Warnock, Lobbe)

Forwards
Roo, Gian, Pav, Sylvia, Medhurst, Danger, Watts (TDL, Podsiadly)

What do you think??

 

[saints07]

Hey all,

Just wondering what your thoughts are on my team:

Backs: Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Shaw, Suban, Ladson, Hunt (Emerg: Davis & Trengove)

Mids: Bartel, Selwood, Gibbs, Armitage, Martin, Trengove (Emerg: Bastanic & Shuey)

Rucks: Sandilands, Kreuzer (Emerg: Lobbe & Warnock)

Forwards: Riewoldt, ROK, Pavlich, Franklin, Ziebell, Dangerfield, Wonaeamirri (Emerg: TDL & Podsiadly)

Only got $2,000 left but not happy with Wona (will he play?) and my backs are a bit weak.

Cheers.

 

[Game1989]

Backs:
1. Goddard
2. Hargrave
3. Enright
4. Carrazzo
5. Kennelly
6. Ladson
7. Hunt
Res: Davis, Davies

Mids:
8. Bartel
9. Mitchell
10. Hodge
11. Armitage
12. Redden
13. Trengove
Res: Martin, Shuey

Rucks:
14. Sandilands
15. Hille
Res: Warnock, Lobbe

Forwards:
16. Riewoldt
17. O'Keefe
18. Higgins
19. Franklin
20. Ziebell
21. Varcoe
22. Dennis-Lane
Res: Astbury, Panos

What does everyone think?

 

[happy_eagle]

Not sure whether Nic Nat is a solid DTer and your rucks are questionable you probably should downgrade Roughead or Higgins to get a more solid combo. Otherwise good team.
Here's mine:

Backs: J Gram - C Enright - L Hodge - H Shaw - N Suban - T Kennelly - J Hunt EMG: M Macguire - P Davis

Midfield: L Montagna - J Bartel - J Selwood - J Mcveigh - D Martin - L Shuey EMG: L Jetta - R Bastinac

Rucks: A Sandilands - D Hille EMG: R Warnock - M Lobbe

Forwards: A Goodes - ROK - J Brown - M Pavlich - L Franklin - P Dangerfield - T Rockliff EMG: TDL - J Podsiadly
Feedback appreciated

Very nice team, just a little question mark over suban, and i'm not completely sold on kennelly as much as everyone else is.
I like Jared Mcveigh in i think will have a very good year, was looking at him but couldnt fit him in

 

[The Hunting Coach]

BACKS:
Goddard, hargrave, Carazzo, Hodge, Kennely, Ladson (Davis, J Trengrove)

MIDS:
Bartel, Hayes, J Sellwood, Vince, Armatage, mcVeigh (D martin, M banner)

RUCKS:
Sandillands, Hille (Warnock, Lobbe)

FWDS:
Bate, Grey, Hawkins, Medhurst, Zeibel, Dangefield, Rockcliff (Gumbleton, Possidilly)

Still think my fwds need some work. any help?

 

[Judds Jiants]

BACKS:
Goddard, hargrave, Carazzo, Hodge, Kennely, Ladson (Davis, J Trengrove)

MIDS:
Bartel, Hayes, J Sellwood, Vince, Armatage, mcVeigh (D martin, M banner)

RUCKS:
Sandillands, Hille (Warnock, Lobbe)

FWDS:
Bate, Grey, Hawkins, Medhurst, Zeibel, Dangefield, Rockcliff (Gumbleton, Possidilly)

Still think my fwds need some work. any help?

take armitage out for a rookie barlow perhaps then use the spare money to upgrade rockliff

also id trade goddard down to shaw or mackie and use the 100k and upgrade hawkins to boomer

this would make a much more balanced team

my team can someone please do it


Backs: fisher hodge shaw macdonald macleski greenwood kenelley (waters Webberley)
Mids: bartell Mitchell anthony cooney martin trengrove (barlow shuey)
Rucks: tippet hille (warnock Lobbe)
Fwds: reidwolt brown gia buddy Medhurst ziebell dangerfield ( dennis lane , gumbleton)

40k bank

any advice i know that buddy is suspended round1

 

[XPISTO]

Backs: fisher hodge shaw macdonald macleski greenwood kenelley (waters Webberley)
Mids: bartell Mitchell anthony cooney martin trengrove (barlow shuey)
Rucks: tippet hille (warnock Lobbe)
Fwds: reidwolt brown gia buddy Medhurst ziebell dangerfield ( dennis lane , gumbleton)

40k bank

any advice i know that buddy is suspended round1

Obvious question marks for me are Greenwood and Anthony. Anthony is risky for the price given his age and I don't know much about Greenwood. Could be a good unique option though!

Fisher is another interesting one... Can get a lot of ball but the Saints will be up top again so I don't know how much cheap possies he will be getting, especially with Goddard and Gilbert in the side. Gilbert has hurt Fisher's scores imo.

 

[stevevan]

Backs:
1. Goddard
2. Hargrave
3. Enright
4. Carrazzo
5. Kennelly
6. Ladson
7. Hunt
Res: Davis, Davies

Mids:
8. Bartel
9. Mitchell
10. Hodge
11. Armitage
12. Redden
13. Trengove
Res: Martin, Shuey

Rucks:
14. Sandilands
15. Hille
Res: Warnock, Lobbe

Forwards:
16. Riewoldt
17. O'Keefe
18. Higgins
19. Franklin
20. Ziebell
21. Varcoe
22. Dennis-Lane
Res: Astbury, Panos

What does everyone think?

Backs - don't know Davies. Other than that solid fairly typical of sides you see here.
Mids - Prefer Hodge in the backs. Armitage and Redden risky but could be good.
Rucks - good. Lots of options around Hill price so if he's going to play forward rather than be the main ruck might be worth considering other options e.g. Mumford, Ottens, Nic Nat.
Forwards - Higgins somewhat injury prone. Varcoe could be a good pick. 3 rookies pretty risky other option is soemwhat like a Warren/Danger if you downgrade a high end premium to soemoen you think can improve to a premium. Don't know how likely it is Panos will get many games.

My team:
B: Gram Enright Fischer Hodge Greenwood Kennelly Hunt (Waters Webberly)

M: Bartel Bock Cooney Ball Connors Martin (Shuey Bastinac)

R: Ottens Nic Nat (Warnock Skipper)

F: Riewoldt O'Keefe Pav Franklin Schnider Warren Dangerfield (Rohna TDL)

100K left over

Any thoughts appreciated.

Cheers
Steve van