Preview Rd: 6 - Dogs @ Saints, Marvel Stadium, 7:30pm Thursday 18 April

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

In: Garcia, Harmes, Daniel, Dale

Out: Libba (inured), VDM (omitted), Gallagher (managed), Baker (sub)

Dale on wing, Harmes replaces Vandermeer as pressure forward, Daniel returns to playmaker off half back, Garcia and west replace Libba and rotate through the guts/ small forward.
 
Max king set to miss. Not sure if I even want to watch this one if I’m honest.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

It speaks volumes for where we're at if Garcia, Harmes and Daniel are the likely ins this week.

Garcia was going to be a low pick until he injured his knee throughout the whole u18s season.

He’s a genuine gun with skill, speed and tackle breaking ability. Not to mention he knows where the goals are.

He’s the future of our engine room and has to be getting games, especially when he’s absolutely dominating the VFL.
 
Garcia is deserving of his spot, he finally needs to be tried in the midfield. He is a type of player we desperately lack in the guts
Of course, good form at Footscray should be rewarded.

Garcia was going to be a low pick until he injured his knee throughout the whole u18s season.

Ive heard this story before. Like every recruiter claiming that a 3rd rounder was rated as a 1st.

Its always felt a bit apocryphal to me.

He’s a genuine gun with skill, speed and tackle breaking ability. Not to mention he knows where the goals are.

Seems like a hard working grinder with an ok skill set to me.

He’s the future of our engine room and has to be getting games, especially when he’s absolutely dominating the VFL.

Thats a lot of weight to foist upon a guy who has been on the list for 3 full seasons (the first was clearly a mulligan) and played a total of 20 games.

He deserves a call up, especially in the absence of Libba. However, my issue is whether his game will translate at the higher level.

As always I'll be the happiest guy here if he makes me eat my words.

We shall see.
 
Why would you say that before we've seen how Croft goes???

On SM-A505YN using BigFooty.com mobile app
We have a large body of evidence of Bevo thinking he is the smartest guy in the room only to be shown he makes rash selections, picking favourites who are underdone, and the dods have had poor tactics and games plans, eg against the dee's and cats.
We have poor defensive set ups and we have a stupid game plan of just dumping the ball into the fwd line, a small fwd who flies for everything instead of staying down and trying to get the crumbs off Marra and astro.
I have no idea what Croft will bring to the table but for the hefty price of 3 1st round picks I hope Sanders and Croft are worth it.
 
Should Sanders be dropped? Not necessarily due to pure form but he’s had low TOG% the entire season. I wouldn’t do it personally with Libba out but I think it’s a possibility to give him a couple of weeks of confidence as the main man in the middle.

In: Garcia, Harmes, Daniel
Out: Libba, Sanders, Gallagher

Sub: Bramble (Dale starts after a hopeful rocket last week)

In recent years, typically we’ve won these ‘backs to the wall’ type games.
 
It speaks volumes for where we're at if Garcia, Harmes and Daniel are the likely ins this week.
Honestly what’s the issue? Harmes & Daniel are premiership players and Garcia has been playing great.

We aren’t talking about Hannan & McComb here.
 
Should Sanders be dropped? Not necessarily due to pure form but he’s had low TOG% the entire season. I wouldn’t do it personally with Libba out but I think it’s a possibility to give him a couple of weeks of confidence as the main man in the middle.

In: Garcia, Harmes, Daniel
Out: Libba, Sanders, Gallagher

Sub: Bramble (Dale starts after a hopeful rocket last week)

In recent years, typically we’ve won these ‘backs to the wall’ type games.
In recent years ? In the history of our club we have won
these games back to wall

On CPH2305 using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Last edited:

Remove this Banner Ad

Preview Rd: 6 - Dogs @ Saints, Marvel Stadium, 7:30pm Thursday 18 April

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top