I believe there is now a case to include Leigh Matthews in this thread. Matthews has 915 goals in his VFL career, as well as 29 goals for Victoria and 49 in the night series games. He also kicked 4 in the 1971 Australian Club Championship and 3 in the 1976 NFL Championship series, which gives him 1000 exactly. In addition, according to the website for Chelsea Football Club in the Mornington Peninsula FL, Matthews played senior football for them in 1968, kicking 70 goals that season, to give him 1070 senior goals over all.