Richard Tambling vs Lance Franklin Season 09

[Nightwolf]

Buddys last 2 games have been better than what Tambling has put up his whole career.

 

[mellowyellow]

oh look, out of the woodwork the come

 

[Hodgepodge]

And yes, buddy has had a few good weeks and good for him but he has yet to have a season as solid as bling,week in and out .

2008 no good?

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

The more things change the more they stay the same.

Richmond supporters...still showing themsleves to be complete muppets.

 

[mellowyellow]

The more things change the more they stay the same.

Hawks supporters...still showing themselves to be complete arrogant twatts .

Edited to reflect the current reality

 

[mellowyellow]

2008 no good?

2009 locked and loaded. No mention of 2008

 

[breeno]

Buddy is the third best KPF in the league.

Tambling is 84th for disposals and 42nd for I50's.

Enough said.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Buddy is the Third best KPF in the league.

Tambling is 84th for disposals and 42nd for I50's.

Enough said.

It's good isn't it....even though he's supposedly 'fat, lazy and out of form' and having an average year he's still the 3rd best KPF in the league, as well as sitting 3rd in the Coleman.

 

[shurg123]

Richmond is an irrelevant club, won't make the finals for 10 more years. Supporters of said club are even more irrelevant, they are reminiscent of the sewer mutants from Futurama. No matter how much Tambling improves, he'll be retired before Richmond play finals. Hawthorn have already won a premiership with Franklin, hence this poll = **** on a bull.

 

[Jimthegreat]

No. Just like I cannot work out why you are using five question marks.


Are Dream Team and Super Coach points any indication

Because to silly Richmond supporters deluded by by thinking Tambling's been better than Franklin this year, average Buddy year or not, it needs emphasising! Not surprising you can't work it out. I actually pointed and laughed at the screen when I read this comparison. You made one biggest drafting blunders imaginable....admit it! It's all Richmond do .....blunder, blunder, blunder.

But if it makes you feel better.......

 

[Jimthegreat]

Edited to reflect the current reality

It was right first time. Suppose when you've been useless for so long you'll try to hang you hat on anything, even things that aren't there. This poll is a classic example.

It close to a career ending move to coach Richmond.

 

[Spluff]

Franklin has his first good game, and the Hawk fans flood this thread. Who would have guessed it?

 

[mellowyellow]

It was right first time. Suppose when you've been useless for so long you'll try to hang you hat on anything, even things that aren't there. This poll is a classic example.

It close to a career ending move to coach Richmond.

As if the words from a supporter of the most disgraced, cheating, dishonorable club in the league carries any weight around these parts.

And to find the most useless club this century, look no further then you pathetic mob........ Enjoy

 

[mellowyellow]

Franklin has his first good game, and the Hawk fans flood this thread. Who would have guessed it?

Such a fickle and fair weather lot

Disgraceful

 

[cs61]

Franklin has his first good game, and the Hawk fans flood this thread. Who would have guessed it?

Good game?

He completely dominated the game, did things Tambling simply will never be able to do, which is what makes this poll such a joke.

 

[dipper86]

I really don't get it.....Tambling has racked up the stats but does he truly have an influence on the game like Franklin does.

The Tambling type is a dime dozen, he's not even in the top 50 in the AFL at what he does.

 

[Rioli magic]

Franklin has had more influence in his last 5 quarters than Tambling has had in 5 years. Tambling is improving though he's probably up to about 60th best wingman in the league.

 

[Richo83]

Franklin has had more influence in his last 5 quarters than Tambling has had in 5 years. Tambling is improving though he's probably up to about 60th best wingman in the league.

Erm, he's bog at the moment and has been very influential in our wins against the eagles and freo. Fail. I'm happy with Tambling, finally showing why we picked him up at number four.

 

[shurg123]

...has been very influential in helping west coast and freo get priority picks.

Edited for accuracy.

 

[tony_montana]

tambling was BOG

pull your heads in nuff nuffs

he's in hot form now and is going from strength to strength almost every week.

has become a very good player over the past 11 weeks, wil be a jet going into next season

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

tambling was BOG

pull your heads in nuff nuffs

he's in hot form now and is going from strength to strength almost every week.

has become a very good player over the past 11 weeks, wil be a jet going into next season

Maybe, and probably somewhere else other than Richmond too.

 

[deledio7]

Maybe, and probably somewhere else other than Richmond too.

Huh?

 

[pacman]

tambling was BOG

pull your heads in nuff nuffs

he's in hot form now and is going from strength to strength almost every week.

has become a very good player over the past 11 weeks, wil be a jet going into next season

BOG in the first half then when the heat was on he was unsighted until he missed the goal from 30 out to win the game but apparently hes a gun.
They'll accept anything at Richmond.

 

[Nine]

Ridiculous thread.
It's been said before but if any other 22 year old KPP had 51 goals, we'd be singing his praises.
There are just some sympathy votes for Tambling surely.
They had to resort to hypno-therapy to save his career.

 

[Bazzar]

Funny how all the meat head morons come on and bag Tambling with no real argument to back it up. Yet 65% (silent majority) so far rate Tambling as having a better year than Franklin.