Game Day Round 1, 2024 - Fremantle vs. Brisbane Lions

[scoman]

Well nobody you named played well today so not sure how you can make an argument for this

My argument isnt about today, as you well know. Its that our list is loaded. Its about as good as it can be considering a number of factors. Its looking like a waste though as our tactics and coaching cant seem to get the most out of it.

 

[Nathan Barley]

Not players like Lohmann and Answerth who are constantly in and out/substitute. Players like Rayner and Berry who have been completely ineffective two weeks in a row despite being consistent best 22 players for 5-6 years now.

But all you’re doing in bringing in duds like Answerth and Lohmann

 

[Nathan Barley]

My argument isnt about today, as you well know. Its that our list is loaded. Its about as good as it can be considering a number of factors. Its looking like a waste though as our tactics and coaching cant seem to get the most out of it.

It’s top heavy and a bit unbalanced. No depth unfortunately

 

[Tom14]

Not players like Lohmann and Answerth who are constantly in and out/substitute. Players like Rayner and Berry who have been completely ineffective two weeks in a row despite being consistent best 22 players for 5-6 years now.

But all you’re doing in bringing in duds like Answerth and Lohmann

Doing this serves my ‘get a first round pick in ahead of the Ashcroft bid’ agenda so thumbs up .

 

[lionshine]

But all you’re doing in bringing in duds like Answerth and Lohmann

Okay but why do they get the chop when Berry and Rayner were just as putrid or in my opinion more so?

You can say more runs on the board but if some of these fringe types got a consistent go at it they might start to look more settled at senior level.

I’m not advocating for recklessly dropping players. I just think a spell in the reserves can be a good motivator at times for players whose performances have become stale/subpar. I’m one of Rayner’s biggest supporters but his effort today and last week was not there.

 

[scoman]

It’s top heavy and a bit unbalanced. No depth unfortunately

Explain heavy and unbalanced if you don't mind.

edit: Sorry didnt read correctly. I get your meaning now.

edit edit: So by top heavy you think we should have less A grade types and more B and C graders?

 

[Nathan Barley]

Okay but why do they get the chop when Berry and Rayner were just as putrid or in my opinion more so?

Rayner was 5th in the best and fairest last year, that should answer your question about him

We’ve tried a bunch of blokes on the wing and nobody has been better than Berry

 

[3KZ is Football]

No leaders out there tonight.

 

[McIvor]

I called a 4-5 goal loss on here a day or two ago and I was wrong.

 

[Happy_Neale]

Open the review thread, my body is ready

 

[Nathan Barley]

No leaders out there tonight.

Wow even 3KZ turning on his pets

 

[lionshine]

Rayner was 5th in the best and fairest last year, that should answer your question about him

We’ve tried a bunch of blokes on the wing and nobody has been better than Berry

Yep they’ve got runs on the board I’ll give them that. So did Payne though… sometimes a spell in the reserves is a good thing.

 

[Jivlain]

Review - Round 1, 2024 - Fremantle vs. Brisbane Lions

Not very good foot-ball (so far).

www.bigfooty.com