Preview Round 10, 2024: St.Kilda v Fremantle - Marvel Stadium - Saturday 18th May, 7.30pm AEST

[Hubnester]

AFL - News, Fixtures, Scores & Results - AFL.com.au

Australian Football League. All the latest AFL news, video, results and information

www.afl.com.au

Back in Melbourne to host the up-and-down dockers this week. Neither team is convincing this year but still expect a loss against a more advanced team.

Something major needs to change to arrest this form slump if we are to have any hope of reviving our season, but at this point in time the question is would we even want that? Keep getting games into the kids, keep experimenting and trying new things, and hit the draft - preferably with a higher pick rather than another mid-table finish.

 

[CaptainRisky]

Not a chance in hell I'm going to travel 4 train stops to watch this Mob ATM

 

[Murraj1966]

This club likes to feck with our emotions so the defeatist attitude we'll all have means we'll win

Freo by 45

 

[SaintSteele9]

I’ll be there but expecting little. Freo midfield is very good. Will the coach/es stick fat or start to shuffle some magnets?

 

[Saintos The ITK]

I’ll be there but expecting little. Freo midfield is very good. Will the coach/es stick fat or start to shuffle some magnets?

They should start by reshuffling themselves.
Defense has worked pretty well, get Boris down to the forwards.

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

5 mins into the 2nd quarter, and we looking terrible in the two's too

 

[mad-saint-guy]

As of half time during the sandy game (Byrnes 2 disposals, Collard 0, Arie out with concussion)

Out: Hayes, Hastie, Ross
In: Sharman, Clark, Jones

B: Wilkie, Howard, Webster
HB: NWM, Battle, Sinclair
C: Hill, Steele, Wood
HF: Henry, King, Wilson
F: Garcia, Membrey, Sharman

Foll: Marshall, Windhager, Owens
Int: Clark, Stocker, Bonner, Paton
Sub: Jones

Clark mid, Stocker defence/inside mid, Bonner half back/wing, Paton wing/defensive forward

 

[Saint12]

Looking at other teams ...why do they look so much more physically enhanced than us. A lot of sausage arms in our team compared to all others.

 

[Parkysp]

Looking at other teams ...why do they look so much more physically enhanced than us. A lot of sausage arms in our team compared to all others.

Little known fact. The rebuild of Moorabbin only included enough money for cardio equipment.

Funky has been bought on as CEO with a priority to get a government grant for weights.

 

[Saint12]

Little known fact. The rebuild of Moorabbin only included enough money for cardio equipment.

Funky has been bought on as CEO with a priority to get a government grant for weights.

Probably best we build the best wellness centre in the comp.

 

[littlecreatures]

In: Caminiti and Jones
Out: Hayes and Paton

Sub: Jones

I think selections will be limited for this game, with Dow, Clark and Pou needing a stronger case at VFL level to get back in. Sharman not far off.

Hopefully Chito and Nas can get a decent run through the middle.

 

[Saint12]

In: Caminiti and Jones
Out: Hayes and Paton

Sub: Jones

I think selections will be limited for this game, with Dow, Clark and Pou needing a stronger case at VFL level to get back in. Sharman not far off.

Hopefully Chito and Nas can get a decent run through the middle.

Why Hayes out?... Why give Membrey 20 shit games in a row and drop Hayes

 

[westernsainter]

I would seriously look at bringing Clark/Dow/Pou all back this week. Hastie and Garcia need time to develop. Not sure Paton offers more as a sub than any of those three (or Z Jones for that matter).

Hayes had a dirty day but was great last week, we will need him playing especially if they're running with Jackson and Darcy.

I have no idea how we are favourites. Genuinely perplexing.

 

[Miha]

Hard pass

 

[Pakenhamsaint]

Form suggest we won't win.

 

[Saint12]

With the worse forward line in the afl how is the pressure not on Rob Harvey? Not a great record at Collingwood and continuing with us. No shitz given that he was a good footballer. He has not shown any semblance of having a good coaching record let alone having any good communication abilities.

 

[gringo2011]

45 point loss coming up.

 

[gringo2011]

With the worse forward line in the afl how is the pressure not on Rob Harvey? Not a great record at Collingwood and continuing with us. No shitz given that he was a good footballer. He has not shown any semblance of having a good coaching record let alone having any good communication abilities.

I said it at the time and got shouted down. Favourite sons isn't a great hiring policy. Should be best available every time.

 

[Saint12]

Harvey is one of those "great footballer...but" type of guys.

 

[my name was taken]

I want Caminiti back, can tell he's learning the game every senior match and brings some enthusiasm and energy.

Tired of the calm, cool and (not so) collected appearance of our side. The season is almost a wrap and it's not like membrey is playing as a game changer.

 

[The Jack]

Form suggests around a 5 point loss.

 

[littlecreatures]

Why Hayes out?... Why give Membrey 20 s**t games in a row and drop Hayes

I’d rather see Caminiti given a go at his age, Hayes being 28, so if he’s not impacting games with what 2 disposals on the weekend I think it leaves him vulnerable at the selection table when there’s others performing at VFL level. We need to be making changes when team isn’t getting it done.

 

[g_TRAIN]

With the worse forward line in the afl how is the pressure not on Rob Harvey? Not a great record at Collingwood and continuing with us. No shitz given that he was a good footballer. He has not shown any semblance of having a good coaching record let alone having any good communication abilities.

Because most of what our forwards do is the result how of easily they can read whats happening up the field and then the delivery they receive. Ross was pretty clear on that but we all should know that without the coach needing to spell it out.

To go with that statistically the best looks at goal come from forward half turn-overs something we are currently unable to generate.

So yes sure our forwards need to lift but if you're not considering the other obvious aspects that are outside of our forwards control then you're blind.

For mine, football starts in the middle. Lets get that right and then complain about the forwards

Man for man Collingwood have one of the worst forward lines in the AFL. Doesn't stop them kicking goals.

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

Sandy were awful in the 1st half - turned off media coverage. Seems like they improved? to end up losing by 5 points. Caminiiti, Heath, Phillipou named amongst the best. Byrnes & Collard amongst the worst. Dow, Clark, Jones, Keeler & Sharman average at best.

 

[g_TRAIN]

Dow looked better as the match went on. Showed his speed a few times, kicked a nice goal.

But he was putrid in the first half. Quite similar to last week.