Round 11 Trades

[Pea Nut]

Hopefully he doesn't miss, but if he does, there is no way Goldy could be traded. Would be suicide. Can't sacrifice the whole season for the sake of one week.

 

[Valzo]

Could someone pls help? I've reversed my trades atleast 10 times this week. I have no idea.
Was thinking m.brown>rookie or wagner>collins and then upgrading either ruggles, or kerridge.

 

[Pea Nut]

Depending on how your bye structure is looking, either:
1. Roll Tippa forward, trade Wagner to Collins and Brown to premo, or
2. D.MacPherson to Mathieson and just do the one trade.

If you do the double trade, you really need to be set into the bye rounds with only 12 trades remaining.

 

[Valzo]

Depending on how your bye structure is looking, either:
1. Roll Tippa forward, trade Wagner to Collins and Brown to premo, or
2. D.MacPherson to Mathieson and just do the one trade.

If you do the double trade, you really need to be set into the bye rounds with only 12 trades remaining.

Cheers for your insight mate, Im just gonna do the 1 trade this week. Then will go wag>collins and brown>boyd next week.
Not too sure who to play on the field this week, wagner vs hawthorn or m.brown vs freo..

 

[Pea Nut]

Not too sure who to play on the field this week, wagner vs hawthorn or m.brown vs freo..

That is tough. If it were me, I would go Wagner, but I normally get my rookies on field wrong.

 

[doona]

go you pups this is my other trade idea with trading Smith a little Early. I didn't like you trading both Smith & Trac as they are both money makers, but this gets me rid of Wagner (at his price, will most likely fall from here) and Smith (Keeps my fwd/mid link which the other kills).

I am willing to take a risk this week with trading out kerridge & cox for Mitchell (I said never) & Howard or Wagner & Smith > Collins/tucker & Mitchell. Huge risk but infield rewards are epic.

EDIT: This ruins my depth in the backline, but positive I don't start a rookie on the field bar Tippa, Kerridge & Wells. (Oh and that spud Martin)

 

[go you pups]

go you pups this is my other trade idea with trading Smith a little Early. I didn't like you trading both Smith & Trac as they are both money makers, but this gets me rid of Wagner (at his price, will most likely fall from here) and Smith (Keeps my fwd/mid link which the other kills).

I am willing to take a risk this week with trading out kerridge & cox for Mitchell (I said never) & Howard or Wagner & Smith > Collins/tucker & Mitchell. Huge risk but infield rewards are epic.

EDIT: This ruins my depth in the backline, but positive I don't start a rookie on the field bar Tippa, Kerridge & Wells. (Oh and that spud Martin)

View attachment 252417

I don't see Smith making huge coin, he potentially crawls to 350k, but can't see him going past 400k

He's playing HB similar to Mills, the difference between Smith and Mills is it seemed to me on the weekend the Pies defenders had confidence in giving him the footy on the switch or running it out of defence, but he has to win his own footy also, so that probably explains the 60s and the 46 he scored before the 80 on the weekend, whereas I'm not sure the Swans defence gives Mills the ball that much and Mills has to win his own footy more to score points. So I think Smith is a good chance to average 70 and average more than a Mills but the low scores he's capable of will potentially hurt his cash generation due to the nature of his role. So after watching Smith live at the ground on the weekend I'm treating him like a Mills type and will wait for peak price then will dump as those low scores can happen with him. If only he was DPP, he'd be so much better than Ruggles, alas he's not.

 

[doona]

I don't see Smith making huge coin, he potentially crawls to 350k, but can't see him going past 400k

He's playing HB similar to Mills, the difference between Smith and Mills is it seemed to me on the weekend the Pies defenders had confidence in giving him the footy on the switch or running it out of defence, but he has to win his own footy also, so that probably explains the 60s and the 46 he scored before the 80 on the weekend, whereas I'm not sure the Swans defence gives Mills the ball that much and Mills has to win his own footy more to score points.

So after watching Smith live at the ground on the weekend I'm treating him like a Mills type and will wait for peak price then will dump as those low scores can happen with him. If only he was DPP, he'd be so much better than Ruggles, alas he's not.

Good insight.

I think Petracca could get to the 400k+ and with his JS is why I think he is worth gold.

Wagner/Cox are maxed.

Smith I am unsure of, but honestly haven't watched him much. I need to ditch players from his bye round, but cox is not worth enough to ditch and no downgrade targets.

This sets me up better for the bye's, but I will slowly roll out the outliers over the byes for upgrades.

Titch & Steven are to good price this week to miss out on the extra infield points. Both are 600K+ players. I have gone titch due to price.

where I am I have to live or dye. No point doing nothing.

Not sure which of my 2 are the best option though.

EDIT: I think trading Smith & Wagner are better for byes, riskier but should have more points on field as I will still have enough trades left to finish my team and cover.

 

[doona]

Could someone pls help? I've reversed my trades atleast 10 times this week. I have no idea.
Was thinking m.brown>rookie or wagner>collins and then upgrading either ruggles, or kerridge.

D.MacPherson to Mathieson should be the number 1 trade. Having a player guaranteed not playing in the bye rounds is a killer in my opinion.

I think that should give you enough cash to trade M. Brown to a promo either forward or back. Maybe a Bartel (through tippa)??? Brown is maxed and worse then wagner in my opinion.

 

[STANDBYHIRD12]

Good insight.

I think Petracca could get to the 400k+ and with his JS is why I think he is worth gold.

Wagner/Cox are maxed.

Smith I am unsure of, but honestly haven't watched him much. I need to ditch players from his bye round, but cox is not worth enough to ditch and no downgrade targets.

This sets me up better for the bye's, but I will slowly roll out the outliers over the byes for upgrades.

Titch & Steven are to good price this week to miss out on the extra infield points. Both are 600K+ players. I have gone titch due to price.

where I am I have to live or dye. No point doing nothing.

Not sure which of my 2 are the best option though.

EDIT: I think trading Smith & Wagner are better for byes, riskier but should have more points on field as I will still have enough trades left to finish my team and cover.

Would you go Treloar or Steven mate?

 

[Danger_zone]

Cheers for your insight mate, Im just gonna do the 1 trade this week. Then will go wag>collins and brown>boyd next week.
Not too sure who to play on the field this week, wagner vs hawthorn or m.brown vs freo..

I like it. You get Mathieson on the bubble and Brown/Wager shouldn't bleed any cash this round (touch wood). Boyd is a great trade in next week.

Based upon the number of points each team gives away over the last 4weeks, I'd field Brown over Wagner. Freo gives away more points (1650) than Hawthorn (1500).

 

[doona]

Would you go Treloar or Steven mate?

Steven. It is a saving of 70K on Treloar. Yes Treloar has been playing awesome, but the game is about selling high and buying low. That 70K gets you closer to another premo on another trade. Steven is a player that will get back up to that price point.

 

[Tippaz]

What to do if Goldy misses

hmmm, i'm looking at a donut if Goldy misses (Goldy/Gawn/Currie)

perhaps Currie -> Tippett is worthwhile because i've got West fwd

 

[The Loosh]

go you pups this is my other trade idea with trading Smith a little Early. I didn't like you trading both Smith & Trac as they are both money makers, but this gets me rid of Wagner (at his price, will most likely fall from here) and Smith (Keeps my fwd/mid link which the other kills).

I am willing to take a risk this week with trading out kerridge & cox for Mitchell (I said never) & Howard or Wagner & Smith > Collins/tucker & Mitchell. Huge risk but infield rewards are epic.

EDIT: This ruins my depth in the backline, but positive I don't start a rookie on the field bar Tippa, Kerridge & Wells. (Oh and that spud Martin)

View attachment 252417

I had a slight stiffy looking at your team. Its insane mate, well done.

If you dont mind me asking how many trades do you have left?

Also who are you looking at to finish your team? Looks nearly done to me

 

[doona]

12 - I had a few sideways trades at the start after starting Milera/Sheridan/Robinson/Barlow/Gresham....... Without those I would have been in a much better position.

I am looking at in

Def: McVeigh (Will be cheap and if he hits form), Bartel

I think that they are both a cut above the rest. McVeigh if he finds form and Bartel is just playing extremely well.

In terms of Mids & Fwds, I am not targeting a player. I Didn't want to bring in Titchell but the price is right for a 108 average mid player. I wanted Steven last week, but the trades didn't work. I will just be looking to target the cheapest/best player I can afford. I would love Dahlhaus at F6 and in the mids, there are always mids that have a bad game and drop in price so not 1 player in particular.

 

[getgaff]

McCarthy -> Wingard

 

[clogwearer]

I'm in the unusual - for me - position of having a team I'm not unhappy with at this stage. Already gone MacPherson > Mathieson. Doesn't make a lot of money but Mathieson is playing, so that's something.

I don't really have much in the way of mid options at the moment. Cows still mooing and no dpp so that was a bit short sighted, although it can potentially be fixed a bit later.

Looking at Brown out as my other trade this week. Could go Wingard and pocket a little cash, but I'm not sold on him yet. My other thought was Howe in the backline, moving Tippa forward. That would leave Williams at D6 and Tippa at F6 with Adams and Petracca moving to the bench. Could trade Kerridge instead but that would mean I'd still have Brown and Menadue in my team, which is a bit yuk.

My other thought regarding Wingard is that I think I could happily give my last fwd spot to Montagna, Merrett, or Martin ahead of him. Whereas in the backs, there's possibly only Simpson or Bartel I'd want for the last spot there, and I prefer Howe to Williams (Williams would be a luxury upgrade to one of those two).

Mids will have to wait until cows moo a little more.

 

[clogwearer]

hmmm, i'm looking at a donut if Goldy misses (Goldy/Gawn/Currie)

perhaps Currie -> Tippett is worthwhile because i've got West fwd

Same predicament. I'm waiting to see before I move on rucks though, I think Goldstein will play. If he doesn't, Tippett isn't a terrible idea if you can swing it. I don't think I can.

 

[go you pups]

I'm in the unusual - for me - position of having a team I'm not unhappy with at this stage. Already gone MacPherson > Mathieson. Doesn't make a lot of money but Mathieson is playing, so that's something.

I don't really have much in the way of mid options at the moment. Cows still mooing and no dpp so that was a bit short sighted, although it can potentially be fixed a bit later.

Looking at Brown out as my other trade this week. Could go Wingard and pocket a little cash, but I'm not sold on him yet. My other thought was Howe in the backline, moving Tippa forward. That would leave Williams at D6 and Tippa at F6 with Adams and Petracca moving to the bench. Could trade Kerridge instead but that would mean I'd still have Brown and Menadue in my team, which is a bit yuk.

My other thought regarding Wingard is that I think I could happily give my last fwd spot to Montagna, Merrett, or Martin ahead of him. Whereas in the backs, there's possibly only Simpson or Bartel I'd want for the last spot there, and I prefer Howe to Williams (Williams would be a luxury upgrade to one of those two).

Mids will have to wait until cows moo a little more.

View attachment 252547

Your team value is massive, there shouldn't be too many problems completing your team through the byes as your backs and forwards are making a bit

If you want Bartel I'd jump on him now though, even if it blows your budget

 

[clogwearer]

Your team value is massive, there shouldn't be too many problems completing your team through the byes as your backs and forwards are making a bit

If you want Bartel I'd jump on him now though, even if it blows your budget

I could get Bartel for Tippa - move Adams forward and keep Brown on my def bench for now. That's something to think about. Could get Bartel or Simpson for Kerridge too, but that would mean playing one of Brown and Petracca on field and I'm not so keen on that idea.

Edit: Shit, I didn't realise my team was looking so healthy value-wise. I'm so used to everyone else having better.

 

[go you pups]

I could get Bartel for Tippa - move Adams forward and keep Brown on my def bench for now. That's something to think about. Could get Bartel or Simpson for Kerridge too, but that would mean playing one of Brown and Petracca on field and I'm not so keen on that idea.

Bit unlucky you can't do the move for Brown, looks like you miss out by $400

I'd hold Tippa though until he maxes out, Adams might make cash now with our backline looking better with returning players from injury helping that could potentially boost his scores

 

[clogwearer]

Bit unlucky you can't do the move for Brown, looks like you miss out by $400

I'd hold Tippa though until he maxes out, Adams might make cash now with our backline looking better with returning players from injury helping that could potentially boost his scores

Spot on, $400 short. I like Tippa and Adams for fwd/def bench cover at the moment, and had been thinking to keep both til the end. If I grab Howe this week it means I can release one of them to a rookie later for their cash and get Bartel/Simpson through the byes - probably Simpson after rd 13. There's 3 trades down, leaving 11 trades to move on 3 spots - 2 fwd and 1 mid (Kerridge/Petracca/Smith or equivalents). It's dicey, because I probably need an upgrade on Libba at some stage, and injuries are a constant cloud.

Gee, Tippa to Bartel is tempting though. Good for my byes.

 

[go you pups]

Spot on, $400 short. I like Tippa and Adams for fwd/def bench cover at the moment, and had been thinking to keep both til the end. If I grab Howe this week it means I can release one of them to a rookie later for their cash and get Bartel/Simpson through the byes - probably Simpson after rd 13. There's 3 trades down, leaving 11 trades to move on 3 spots - 2 fwd and 1 mid (Kerridge/Petracca/Smith or equivalents). It's dicey, because I probably need an upgrade on Libba at some stage, and injuries are a constant cloud.

Gee, Tippa to Bartel is tempting though. Good for my byes.

I'm looking at moving on Smith very quickly due to the nature of his role (think Callum Mills at half back), he's a poor score away from little to no generation etc, bit annoyed he's not DPP as he's definitely a half back flanker.


Tippa and Adams would be good F7/D7 types as they can swing back and forth when required giving you flexibility, but if you did that then I'd be upgrading all of Kerridge, Wells and Petracca in due course and keeping Libba as your M9 as your D7/F7 are covered by Adams and Tippa.

 

[clogwearer]

Went back and looked at your team, and I think I like what you've done here. I get that it's tempting to hold Kerridge but your bench cash generation looks so much better if you move him on instead of Smith or Davis, and Petracca ought to be able to hold down that F6 spot while you need him to. I absolutely think holding Wells is the right move, and I'd love to have Steven if I could find a way to get him. I think you've managed both in a manner that's healthy for your team.

On paper your team looks great. Your rucks are hurting you though. No way to have known Jacobs and Martin would be so far down on expectations. If you can find a way to move on Martin soonish without compromising your trades too much I'd keep that in mind. Tippett/Lycett aren't the worst options in the world at this point.

View attachment 252114

 

[clogwearer]

I'm looking at moving on Smith very quickly due to the nature of his role (think Callum Mills at half back), he's a poor score away from little to no generation etc, bit annoyed he's not DPP as he's definitely a half back flanker.

Tippa and Adams would be good F7/D7 types as they can swing back and forth when required giving you flexibility, but if you did that then I'd be upgrading all of Kerridge, Wells and Petracca in due course and keeping Libba as your M9 as your D7/F7 are covered by Adams and Tippa.

One of Kerridge/Wells definitely on the block soonish, with a view to the other getting upgraded down the track. Smith can go as soon as he looks like becoming a liability, as long as Hopper holds his spot. I don't trust Keays or Mathieson on field. As good as DBJ has been I think he's a downgrade option, possibly for Collins next week. He'll be too much cash tied up at D8 in the long run.