-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Round 11 Trades
- Thread starter Beau_Waters for PM
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Jan 30, 2007
- 5,181
- 3,284
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Is Cotchin a suitable replacement for Palmer as the 6th mid??
I was going to simpley do:
OPTION 1.
H. Taylor ---> Armfield, then Boak --> Corey.
But that leaves me with no future scope to upgrade Rioli in my fwd line. So now I'm thinking I might do:
OPTON 2
Palmer ---> Cotchin, then Rioli --> Riewoldt, then I will prob still have enough for Boak --> Corey next week, or someone around $400K at least.
So, OPTION 1 - Corey, Palmer, Rioli Vs OPTION 2 - $400Kmid, Cotchin, Riewoldt
... bear in mind option 1 is risky, as Armfield isn't guaranteed to play every game.
I was going to simpley do:
OPTION 1.
H. Taylor ---> Armfield, then Boak --> Corey.
But that leaves me with no future scope to upgrade Rioli in my fwd line. So now I'm thinking I might do:
OPTON 2
Palmer ---> Cotchin, then Rioli --> Riewoldt, then I will prob still have enough for Boak --> Corey next week, or someone around $400K at least.
So, OPTION 1 - Corey, Palmer, Rioli Vs OPTION 2 - $400Kmid, Cotchin, Riewoldt
... bear in mind option 1 is risky, as Armfield isn't guaranteed to play every game.
Not as a long term proposition, but if it's only one week before he demoted down to an EMERG I think it's a sound option.
Blue_Skies_Ahead
Senior List
Ibbotson out
Bartel in
Bartel in
snowstorm_ac
Debutant
just traded out gamble for valenti
who do you bring in for hawkins ?
franklin or didak ?
they're the two i've narrowed it down too but no idea who to choose:
i'm scared of missing out on the buddy train n copping a big score from him in the eliminator / finals. didak also plays sydney in rd 21 ...
thoughts ?
who do you bring in for hawkins ?
franklin or didak ?
they're the two i've narrowed it down too but no idea who to choose:
i'm scared of missing out on the buddy train n copping a big score from him in the eliminator / finals. didak also plays sydney in rd 21 ...
thoughts ?
I would take Didak, Althought Hawthorn are playing Essendon this week...
- Jan 30, 2007
- 5,181
- 3,284
- AFL Club
- Geelong
As my last midfield upgrade, should I get rid of Palmer or Boak, for Corey? Boak hasn't been scoring as consistently well, though Palmer may get tired as the year goes on...
DiscoBiscuits
Rookie
Traded Tippett for Johnson and Johnston for Goodwin.
Leaving me with:
Palmer to 82K
Ibbo to McPhee maybe?
Rioli to Chappy/Richo
McLean to Corey/Bartel
Leaving me with:
Palmer to 82K
Ibbo to McPhee maybe?
Rioli to Chappy/Richo
McLean to Corey/Bartel
snowstorm_ac
Debutant
swansational05
Senior List
Got 245k in the bank!
Options
1. Houlihan for Chris Newman
2. Glass for Nathen Brock with 80K cash left
Options
1. Houlihan for Chris Newman
2. Glass for Nathen Brock with 80K cash left
foley4brownlow
Team Captain
option 1 trade palmer to cotchin(who would start for probably 3 weeks) and then nathan thomson to giansiracusa
option 2 trade wellingham to armfield and then thompson to matty stokes
so its either a starting combination of palmer and stokes or either cotchin or wellingham and giansaricusa.
which would you rather. cheers
option 2 trade wellingham to armfield and then thompson to matty stokes
so its either a starting combination of palmer and stokes or either cotchin or wellingham and giansaricusa.
which would you rather. cheers
snowstorm_ac
Debutant
option 1 trade palmer to cotchin(who would start for probably 3 weeks) and then nathan thomson to giansiracusa
option 2 trade wellingham to armfield and then thompson to matty stokes
so its either a starting combination of palmer and stokes or either cotchin or wellingham and giansaricusa.
which would you rather. cheers
why would you trade wellingham now ?? a lot of money to be made by keeping him in your team.
option 1 if anything
foley4brownlow
Team Captain
ok then thanks for your input mate
snowstorm_ac
Debutant
ok then thanks for your input mate
also, giansiracusa > stokes and cotchin > armfield.
defs option 1
no worries!
swansational05
Senior List
Bank: $245000
Trades: 6
Im not sure if i should use all my 6 trades this season or keep some.
But i need help with my team, any suggestions for trades will be much
appreciated.
Thanks
Trades: 6
Im not sure if i should use all my 6 trades this season or keep some.
But i need help with my team, any suggestions for trades will be much
appreciated.
Thanks
hey everyone, i need some help
im trading out nathan thompson which will give me $524,100 to spend.
so i cna pretty much buy anyone.
i wont get didak coz i dont think he will keep it up, was thinking either richo, buddy or steve johnson. im leaning towards stevie j, coz hes a lot cheaper and i think he will pick up, even though theres the chance he can play dud games, and also next week that will let me upgrade palmer to bartel or swan, and upgrade a defender.
lol what u guys think? ta
im trading out nathan thompson which will give me $524,100 to spend.
so i cna pretty much buy anyone.
i wont get didak coz i dont think he will keep it up, was thinking either richo, buddy or steve johnson. im leaning towards stevie j, coz hes a lot cheaper and i think he will pick up, even though theres the chance he can play dud games, and also next week that will let me upgrade palmer to bartel or swan, and upgrade a defender.
lol what u guys think? ta
just did symes to mcphee
ran out of patience
should have done the trade last week and upgraded thompson to brown
idiot!!!
oh well i was preserving trades
will still be one short in my forward line thanks to gamble, thompson and burton
ran out of patience
should have done the trade last week and upgraded thompson to brown
idiot!!!
oh well i was preserving trades
will still be one short in my forward line thanks to gamble, thompson and burton
quick an last question before i go to work
would anyone make ne trades on my side this week, i have ideas in mind jus wondering what ppl would do
0
THANKS
daniel
just quietly - that is sh1t hot
i'd get rid of fev soon though (volt) and upgrade to chad (gram)in a week or so
i'd also get cox at any price (kozzi)
hey mate, maybe trade kennelly for sam fisher. try to get an adelaide player in ur side, and maybe upgrade kelly
hey everyone, i need some help
im trading out nathan thompson which will give me $524,100 to spend.
so i cna pretty much buy anyone.
i wont get didak coz i dont think he will keep it up, was thinking either richo, buddy or steve johnson. im leaning towards stevie j, coz hes a lot cheaper and i think he will pick up, even though theres the chance he can play dud games, and also next week that will let me upgrade palmer to bartel or swan, and upgrade a defender.
lol what u guys think? ta
hey everyone, i need some help
im trading out nathan thompson which will give me $524,100 to spend.
so i cna pretty much buy anyone.
i wont get didak coz i dont think he will keep it up, was thinking either richo, buddy or steve johnson. im leaning towards stevie j, coz hes a lot cheaper and i think he will pick up, even though theres the chance he can play dud games, and also next week that will let me upgrade palmer to bartel or swan, and upgrade a defender.
lol what u guys think? ta
- Sep 26, 2004
- 47,847
- 64,826
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #374
Your thoughts about Didak are very interesting, and on the contrary, I think he can definitely keep a very good average for the season. I am far more confident in Didak than I would be in Richo.
If you are steadfast about not getting Didak, then Stevie J is the way to go IMO. As I said, I don't think Richo will be able to keep it up. Buddy is also very inconsistent. and whilst can thrill you with massive scores, is very prone to putting in a few stinkers.
SJ has well and truly bottomed out and we played him into some great form last week. Should consistently get 80+ whilst also pulling in some huge scores. As you said, he saves you a bit of cash too.
Similar threads
