Prediction Round 12, 2024: Changes vs St Kilda

[Miguel Sanchez]

They’ve just slotted Trew’s name where Kelly’s was.

Don’t think that precludes him being the sub.

 

[KBLT]

He's not the sub, he's starting in the 23.
Sub comes from the 5 on the bench.

Not necessarily, Geelong in particular often make someone named on the field the sub.

 

[flyinghi64]

Sub should have already been chosen you would think
Zane will come in as a Trew replacement for Kelly.

 

[UseR2006]

Also for those worried about production between Kelly and Trew.

Trew 2024 averages:
Disposals - 26
Tackles - 5
Goals - 0.6
Marks - 4

Kelly 2024 averages:
Disposals - 23.3
Tackles - 5.1
Goals - 0.2
Marks - 2.9

Obviously one is at AFL and the other WAFL.
But if Trew can step it up he'll be ok.

 

[Rowan18]

He's not the sub, he's starting in the 23.
Sub comes from the 5 on the bench.

Doesn't have to. We've taken it from the field in the past.

 

[Get_The_Gaff]

Saints dropping collard for a game in his home state not even in the emergencies?

Don't want him to experience optus stadium or get a free trip home to see his family

 

[EagleMan87]

Saints dropping collard for a game in his home state not even in the emergencies?

Don't want him to experience optus stadium or get a free trip home to see his family

Afraid he won't board the return flight?

 

[JackOutback]

It's an opportunity for Trew.
It's not a massive out at our stage of where we are at.

It's a winnable game for a developing squad... of course it's a big out.

 

[TY24]

Can’t wait for us to win tomorrow and for all of you plastic fans to crawl back into your holes for another week

 

[TY24]

He's not the sub, he's starting in the 23.
Sub comes from the 5 on the bench

 

[Smeg Head]

Can’t wait for us to win tomorrow and for all of you plastic fans to crawl back into your holes for another week

But its cosy down in the hole.

 

[Get_The_Gaff]

Can’t wait for us to win tomorrow and for all of you plastic fans to crawl back into your holes for another week

Lol anyone who posts on big footy is not a plastic fan .

Not obsessed just a fan

 

[JackOutback]

But its cosy down in the hole.

 

[UseR2006]

View attachment 2006353

He is in the 23, the 23 includes the 5 on the bench.
He is named on the ground, not on the bench so the odds of him being the sub are pretty low to nil.
When was the last time we picked a sub from the players on the ground?

 

[TY24]

He is in the 23, the 23 includes the 5 on the bench.
He is named on the ground, not on the bench so the odds of him being the sub are pretty low to nil.
When was the last time we picked a sub from the players on the ground?

Players being named somewhere doesn’t mean much. Geelong regularly pick subs from ‘on the field’.

Granted, yes we normally pick ours from the bench.

 

[InTheWings]

AFL site with Trew in for Kelly. Not on the bench so should be a starter.

EDIT: Just saw this has been posted... oh well.

Unfortunate that it is replacing Kelly, but I am glad Trew is in.

 

[CursoryMercenary]

I have a feeling the saints might get over us tomorrow even before Kelly was out.

 

[UseR2006]

2024 Sub selections

Rd1: Chesser - named on the bench.
Rd2: Maric - named on the bench.
Rd3: Ledwards - named on the bench.
Rd4: Rawlinson - named on the bench.
Rd5: Maric - named on the bench.
Rd6: Sheed - named on the bench.
Rd7: Sheed - named on the bench.
Rd8: Johnston - named on the bench.
Rd9: Johnston - named on the bench.
Rd10: Dewar - named on the bench.
Rd11: Dewar - named on the bench.

With Gaff, Sheed, Petch, Witherden and Maric named on the bench, Guess where the Sub is likely to come from?

 

[JackOutback]

2024 Sub selections

Rd1: Chesser - named on the bench.
Rd2: Maric - named on the bench.
Rd3: Ledwards - named on the bench.
Rd4: Rawlinson - named on the bench.
Rd5: Maric - named on the bench.
Rd6: Sheed - named on the bench.
Rd7: Sheed - named on the bench.
Rd8: Johnston - named on the bench.
Rd9: Johnston - named on the bench.
Rd10: Dewar - named on the bench.
Rd11: Dewar - named on the bench.

With Gaff, Sheed, Petch, Witherden and Maric named on the bench, Guess where the Sub is likely to come from?

Trew?

 

[JackOutback]

Following the recent pattern, whoever is named on the bench should be there again next week.

 

[JoshWoodenSpoon]

Flynn's selection video. Spotted Kieren Jack there. A nice surprise that he moved over, I just assumed he'd stay based in Sydney and do what needed to be done over there.

I'd like to see the Pyke-apologists defend that desktop icon management.
This once proud club...

 

[cottoneyeYeo]

what makes someone a plastic fan, genuinely curious

 

[frenchconnection]

Can’t wait for us to win tomorrow and for all of you plastic fans to crawl back into your holes for another week

A win or loss is not the big issue as we aren’t going anywhere this year but the young guns do need to get experience by playing at AFL level. Simmo just loves his old boys lol.

 

[DanWCE]

Yes Trewyyy. Give us more of that infamous one quarter pre-season Derby performance, but hopefully for a full game.

 

[Cuzz09]

Out: Kelly (not handballing to Harley)



On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app