Trades Round 17 Trades

[FlowersByIrene]

If a 170k mid debuts this week I can get Cripps. Otherwise it's Hunter.

 

[Thetrader15]

Would love some opinions on what to do
Have $254k in the bank
BSmith, Sheed and all rookies on the chopping block

View attachment 705626

That's an easy one - Smith to Whitfield. Done

 

[Thetrader15]

De Boer out effect:
Good for Cogs - More mid time
Bad for Taranto - More defensive role

Kelly out effect:
Bad for Cogs - Becomes #1 tag target
Good for Taranto - More attacking role

Both MDB and Kelly out effect:
?

 

[stevebbb]

That's an easy one - Smith to Whitfield. Done

$9k off, so need to do Bewley to Dunkley (or other) to do that

 

[Thetrader15]

How good would it be to have money or rookies who are actually decent. Terrible, terrible trades this week but i need to do something. Looking like Lahcie Hunter could be coming in for me. Getting Clarke off field and trading in Osckar Baker. Logue survives one more week. No idea how to get whitfield next week though.

This is hopefully where my 'go for $' approach start to pay off (pardon the pun). Chol last week while taking a 0 from Gawn. 2 more weeks and he becomes a premo

 

[kozi]

Both MDB and Kelly out effect:
?

Probably just the 2nd one. Don’t think they can afford Taranto playing a defensive role with Kelly out.

 

[_Cayz_]

De Boer out effect:
Good for Cogs - More mid time
Bad for Taranto - More defensive role

Kelly out effect:
Bad for Cogs - Becomes #1 tag target
Good for Taranto - More attacking role

Whitfield is #1 tag target now IMO.

 

[kozi]

Whitfield is #1 tag target now IMO.

Could go either way depending on opposition coach. Horse the great will tag both in round 20 can’t wait.

 

[nob2210]

Is there anyone else here who hasn’t had Whitfield at all this year??

Not planning to trade him in now with the high b/e, even though he could easily hit it. Maybe next week if I have to keep Witho for one more...

 

[Lyyynnnchy]

Is there anyone else here who hasn’t had Whitfield at all this year??

Not planning to trade him in now with the high b/e, even though he could easily hit it. Maybe next week if I have to keep Witho for one more...

Have had him twice

 

[kraka]

Would love some opinions on what to do
Have $254k in the bank
BSmith, Sheed and all rookies on the chopping block

View attachment 705626

A). pray cripps is back this week
b). piss heeny off. flick danger to FWD and bring in a mid premo

 

[Ah12]

De Boer out effect:
Good for Cogs - More mid time
Bad for Taranto - More defensive role

Kelly out effect:
Bad for Cogs - Becomes #1 tag target
Good for Taranto - More attacking role

Cogs has always been the number 1 tag target. Havent seen a team put time into j kelly

 

[kozi]

Cogs has always been the number 1 tag target. Havent seen a team put time into j kelly

Must not have been watching last few weeks. Clarke tagged him v Essendon and Lions gave him some attention yesterday.. he’s just that good it doesn’t effect his scoring much.

Cogs disposal has been average lately which has been a blessing. Nobody has been near him last 3 weeks, hope that continues in Kelly’s absence.

 

[SM]

Might go Logue > Quaynor
Baker > Heeney

 

[PAFC27]

Seriously, what is with AFL.com.au reporting more will be known tomorrow re injuries...only to provide a blanket statement 24 hours later like "Giants will be sweating on..." Or "Blank facing an uphill battle"

I knew that during the game FFS.

 

[PAFC27]

Is there anyone else here who hasn’t had Whitfield at all this year??

Not planning to trade him in now with the high b/e, even though he could easily hit it. Maybe next week if I have to keep Witho for one more...

I owned him for 1 week - the same week he got injured lol

 

[PAFC27]

Parker > Hanrahan and Logue > Milera

If Jelly is out...Jelly > MCrouch/Heeney and, Logue > Milera

Basically, piss off Griffen.

 

[PAFC27]

Boak is fine

 

[PAFC27]

Anybody down on a completed side thread? And can keep updating weekly

 

[DynamiteDons]

Seriously, what is with AFL.com.au reporting more will be known tomorrow re injuries...only to provide a blanket statement 24 hours later like "Giants will be sweating on..." Or "Blank facing an uphill battle"

I knew that during the game FFS.

Wayne Campbell said today on SEN, that Kelly likely done calf, but wasnt sure and was waiting on scans and said more information in 24 hours. But i dont think it looks positive for Kelly. He said Cogs should be fine, was okay after the game and reiterated that Whitfield should be available for selection this week.

 

[PAFC27]

Wayne Campbell said today on SEN, that Kelly likely done calf, but wasnt sure and was waiting on scans and said more information in 24 hours. But i dont think it looks positive for Kelly. He said Cogs should be fine, was okay after the game and reiterated that Whitfield should be available for selection this week.

Give me Wayne Campbell's job surely. I could've said as much

Bloke who finishes game injured, should play.
Bloke who doesn't finish game injured, in doubt.

 

[Sixpence]

Brayshaw -> 170k FWD/DEF (Lipinksi -> MID)
Baker -> Whitfield (Answerth -> MID)

No rooks on field!!!

 

[4tune8]

Geez, it'd be handy if Cripps, Boak and Hanners are named this week.....trades at mo are Daniel > Whitfield and Parker > Hanrahan

243k ITB but for some reason I still have Brayshaw and need to upgrade Hanners.

I thought I had a 'complete' team last week but ended up fielding 4 rookies, **** knows what's gonna happen this week

 

[Ah12]

Must not have been watching last few weeks. Clarke tagged him v Essendon and Lions gave him some attention yesterday.. he’s just that good it doesn’t effect his scoring much.

Cogs disposal has been average lately which has been a blessing. Nobody has been near him last 3 weeks, hope that continues in Kelly’s absence.

Clarke rotated between both cogs and kelly and i didnt see anyone go to him against lions. I did see them riding cogs at most stoppages after his big start.

 

[kozi]

Clarke rotated between both cogs and kelly and i didnt see anyone go to him against lions. I did see them riding cogs at most stoppages after his big start.

Ok we must be watching different games then because Cogs has been running free last 2 weeks while Kelly definitely copped some attention.