I am 30k short of Shaw > Birchall so need to make a downgrade unfortunately, the same would apply to Martin as I only have 10k in the bank. Newman can be done but he doesn't provide the strength of Birchall or Martin..........
Round 18 trades
- Thread starter huggy_b
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Banned
- #52
If that was my team with 3 trades, I'd sit tight for now. Its a very strong 22. Only trade I would be making is Shaw>Suckling...but you don't even need to do that right now with Heppell averaging 90+ the last 3 weeks.
NRoo should be good for a 95+ average for the remaining 7 rounds. Too good for F8 IMHO. Watch him pump out 120+ this week.
Puopolo -> Talia
Adcock -> Suckling
leaves me with 4 trades and 51k
team complete
argh, forget about Suckling
should i pay the big bucks for Broughton or just stick with Adcock ???
kaiserchief13
Hall of Famer
- Jul 12, 2011
- 35,510
- 26,353
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Eagles, Lakers, Bayern, Trojans
Should I upgrade Iles or Isaac Smith? I want to keep Smith but I think he might get dropped where as Iles will be solid bench cover the rest of the season. What are your thoughts?
kick it to hodge
Team Captain
- Mar 30, 2010
- 325
- 170
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Can bring any forward in this week.
Can't decide between Sylvia (cheap, easy run home during finals), Goodes or ROK (both still have a bye).
I already have most of the other premium forward options.
Can't decide between Sylvia (cheap, easy run home during finals), Goodes or ROK (both still have a bye).
I already have most of the other premium forward options.
Stick with Adcock. Not worth a double trade to get Broughton.
With Suckling out I am now considering trading Montags in so I can swing Goddard back to cover. Would make Duffield my 8th back.
Or do I cover this week with one of ISmith or ZSmith?
And if I were to trade do I trade ISmith and save some cash or Mzungu and use most of my bank?
5 trades, 110k
- Aug 22, 2009
- 24,506
- 28,840
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Too risky to bring Callinan in this week anyway?
The Spornstar
Premiership Player
Hi guys
would love some advice. This is my team right now (5 trades, 286k)
Gibbs, Deledio, Goddard, Enright, Heppell, Broughton, Stanley (Otten, Hibberd, Howard)
Boyd, Swan, Pendles, Mitchell, Ablett, Thompson (Prestia, Bewick, Jacobs)
Cox, Lobbe (Keefe, Tippett)
Goodes, Cloke, Buddy, Sylvia, Petrie, Riewoldt, I Smith (Mzungu, Lynch, C Richardson)
Really not sure where to go from here. I would like to keep a few trades for finals (Gibbs and Heppell due to their byes, will need upgrading). Should I be trading anytime soon though, or just sit tight?
Smith has either peaked in price or might dip a bit and go up again (has a high BE this week). Mzungu can wait a week or so with his low BE, but I was thinking I should trade one of these guys in the next few weeks and keep the other. I am thinking of eventually bringing in Fyfe, or maybe ROK or Pav. Down back, not so sure but I feel I should upgrade one of them.
I don't have any more tough league games until week 1 of the finals.
Any thoughts on a good strategy?
would love some advice. This is my team right now (5 trades, 286k)
Gibbs, Deledio, Goddard, Enright, Heppell, Broughton, Stanley (Otten, Hibberd, Howard)
Boyd, Swan, Pendles, Mitchell, Ablett, Thompson (Prestia, Bewick, Jacobs)
Cox, Lobbe (Keefe, Tippett)
Goodes, Cloke, Buddy, Sylvia, Petrie, Riewoldt, I Smith (Mzungu, Lynch, C Richardson)
Really not sure where to go from here. I would like to keep a few trades for finals (Gibbs and Heppell due to their byes, will need upgrading). Should I be trading anytime soon though, or just sit tight?
Smith has either peaked in price or might dip a bit and go up again (has a high BE this week). Mzungu can wait a week or so with his low BE, but I was thinking I should trade one of these guys in the next few weeks and keep the other. I am thinking of eventually bringing in Fyfe, or maybe ROK or Pav. Down back, not so sure but I feel I should upgrade one of them.
I don't have any more tough league games until week 1 of the finals.
Any thoughts on a good strategy?
Willsy82
Debutant
Wouldnt mind another persons opinion...
4 trades with 60K in the bank
Defence - Gibbs, Lids, Goddard, Suckling, Fisher, Adcock, Stanley (Poo, Ottens, Howard)
Thinking of upgrading either poo or ottens to Gram, then switching Gram onto the field for Adcock.
Any thoughts if this is a decent move or a waste of a trade?
4 trades with 60K in the bank
Defence - Gibbs, Lids, Goddard, Suckling, Fisher, Adcock, Stanley (Poo, Ottens, Howard)
Thinking of upgrading either poo or ottens to Gram, then switching Gram onto the field for Adcock.
Any thoughts if this is a decent move or a waste of a trade?
Unrivaled Mach
Cancelled
I would save your trades unless you're upgrading one of Puopolo or Ottens to a real premium defender than you can count on every week. Don't think you'll gain much from the trade IMO and the backline looks pretty good atm.
5 trades, 9.3k
B: gibbs, deledio, goddard, enright, broughton, lower, puopolo (shaw, hibberd, toy)
M: boyd, pendlebury, swan, mitchell, rockliff, bartel (iles, prestia, i.smith)
R: cox, petrie (hale, keeffe)
F: o'keefe, goodes, pavlich, sylvia, franklin, riewoldt, rioli (mzungu, lobbe, callinan)
I was one trade off completion before shaw. Now I am two
I'm thinking of going i.smith and shaw for gram and one of birchall or s.fisher.
I am crazy for even considering Gram, even at a super discount? Gram for I.Smith would open up my back/mid link, give me a choice between him or lower for D7 and would provide good backup in the midfield. Even if he averages only 75 from here on I think I would be very handy for these reasons. Thoughts?
B: gibbs, deledio, goddard, enright, broughton, lower, puopolo (shaw, hibberd, toy)
M: boyd, pendlebury, swan, mitchell, rockliff, bartel (iles, prestia, i.smith)
R: cox, petrie (hale, keeffe)
F: o'keefe, goodes, pavlich, sylvia, franklin, riewoldt, rioli (mzungu, lobbe, callinan)
I was one trade off completion before shaw. Now I am two
I'm thinking of going i.smith and shaw for gram and one of birchall or s.fisher.
I am crazy for even considering Gram, even at a super discount? Gram for I.Smith would open up my back/mid link, give me a choice between him or lower for D7 and would provide good backup in the midfield. Even if he averages only 75 from here on I think I would be very handy for these reasons. Thoughts?
Is anybody concerned about bringing in Fisher with Gwilt now out for the year?
Seems like Gwilt has been taking the opposition's second tall fwd (Dawson takes the 1st), but with him out, will Fisher have to play a more accountable role at CHB and therefore score less?
Seems like Gwilt has been taking the opposition's second tall fwd (Dawson takes the 1st), but with him out, will Fisher have to play a more accountable role at CHB and therefore score less?
^ I am a fan of Mitchell.
1......Heath Shaw to Stefan Martin. Team complete no money and 4 trades left.
2.......Heath Shaw to Talia. Keeping the money and Needing an upgrade later from Hibberd to either Broughton or Suckling.
3.....Sit for 2 weeks and Hope I can afford Shaw to Suckling after Suckling plays a couple more games.
1......Heath Shaw to Stefan Martin. Team complete no money and 4 trades left.
2.......Heath Shaw to Talia. Keeping the money and Needing an upgrade later from Hibberd to either Broughton or Suckling.
3.....Sit for 2 weeks and Hope I can afford Shaw to Suckling after Suckling plays a couple more games.
To above: I think they will score very similar for the remainder of the year, but Sylvia is obviously value so I'd go him.
With Suckling out I am now considering trading Montags in so I can swing Goddard back to cover. Or is Fyfe a better option for the extra 40k? Would make Duffield my 8th back.
Or do I cover this week with one of ISmith or ZSmith?
And if I were to trade do I trade ISmith and save some cash or Mzungu and use most of my bank?
5 trades, 110k
With Suckling out I am now considering trading Montags in so I can swing Goddard back to cover. Or is Fyfe a better option for the extra 40k? Would make Duffield my 8th back.
Or do I cover this week with one of ISmith or ZSmith?
And if I were to trade do I trade ISmith and save some cash or Mzungu and use most of my bank?
5 trades, 110k
Fyfe has a horrid run home. Although he's clearly an elite player, in just his second year, it's something to be mindful of. I'm thinking of gambling on Travis Cloke (Didak upgrade). He's been ripping it up this year, and Collingwood have a far easier run home, except maybe Geelong in Round 24 (which they should still win).
Need some help please! Will be throwing Petrie into the rucks, then:
Knights > Fyfe or ROK
Hibberd > Fisher or Birchall
Any thoughts? Can get any combination of the four, who do you think is best? leaning towards Fyfe and Fisher
Current backs: gibbs, deledio, goddard, broughton, heppell, adcock, stanley (lower, hibberd, golby)
current fwds: pav, goodes, chappy, petrie, buddy, sylvia, Nroo (knights, howe, richardson and lobbe on ruck bench)
Knights > Fyfe or ROK
Hibberd > Fisher or Birchall
Any thoughts? Can get any combination of the four, who do you think is best? leaning towards Fyfe and Fisher
Current backs: gibbs, deledio, goddard, broughton, heppell, adcock, stanley (lower, hibberd, golby)
current fwds: pav, goodes, chappy, petrie, buddy, sylvia, Nroo (knights, howe, richardson and lobbe on ruck bench)
I have 5 trades left and thinking of trading out Hibberd to Talia and then bringing in Clome for Didak leaving me with 3 trades for the last 6 rounds. Am I crazy? Somebody please talk me out of this.
Childish Gambino
Premiership Player
- Apr 26, 2006
- 3,401
- 941
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Newcastle United - OKC
All depends on the rest of your team. If you've got a team full of premiums and Didak is your last upgrade then I say go for it.
- Sep 22, 2008
- 698
- 244
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Knicks, Arsenal, A.C Milan
Okay
I just traded howe for talia in the forwards to free up cash for any last minute trades
6 trades left
thinking of going harris to either goodes or fyfe in order to open up 3 dp links with mids and forwards
This way should never get a doghnut in either
So my question is who do you think is better Goodes and 29000 or fyfe?
Goodes historically finishes very strongly but this year fyfe has been more consistent
I just traded howe for talia in the forwards to free up cash for any last minute trades
6 trades left
thinking of going harris to either goodes or fyfe in order to open up 3 dp links with mids and forwards
This way should never get a doghnut in either
So my question is who do you think is better Goodes and 29000 or fyfe?
Goodes historically finishes very strongly but this year fyfe has been more consistent
Gibbs, Scotland, Deledio, Goddard, Enright, Rawlings, Stanley .... Suckling, Puopolo, Golby
Boyd, Pendlebury, Swan, Priddis, Ablett, Montanga .... Bartel, Prestia, Callinan
Cox, Griffin .... Lobbe, McCauley
O'Keefe, Johnson, Goodes, Pavlich, Franklin, N.Riewoldt, Lecras .... Smith, Mzungu, Howe
Seeking some advice for my team, 4 trades left,1k in the bank. I kind of want to bench Lecras and have him as back up. Could get Fyfe/Sylvia.
Should I keep Griffin ? 155 two weeks ago says yes, but who knows what will happen when 211 is back.
Or should I hold tight?
Boyd, Pendlebury, Swan, Priddis, Ablett, Montanga .... Bartel, Prestia, Callinan
Cox, Griffin .... Lobbe, McCauley
O'Keefe, Johnson, Goodes, Pavlich, Franklin, N.Riewoldt, Lecras .... Smith, Mzungu, Howe
Seeking some advice for my team, 4 trades left,1k in the bank. I kind of want to bench Lecras and have him as back up. Could get Fyfe/Sylvia.
Should I keep Griffin ? 155 two weeks ago says yes, but who knows what will happen when 211 is back.
Or should I hold tight?
Who would everyone keep out of I. Smith or Mzungu?
My last downgrade and not sure who to get rid of. I think Mzungu has better JS but I think Smith will outscore him if he plays for the rest of the season.
My last downgrade and not sure who to get rid of. I think Mzungu has better JS but I think Smith will outscore him if he plays for the rest of the season.
