Round 4 Trades (with POLL)

[fantasyunit]

Next week trades will likely be Atkins/Gibbons>Stack and English>Mumford.

Trying to decide whether Atkins/Gibbons>Wagner/Lockhart is worth it this week. I'm guessing neither of those Melbourne fellas has a whole lot of JS?

Could also consider Hore>Markov/Lockhart, but I think I'd rather use just the one trade this week.

 

[Max the great]

Saints should try and turn Longer into a KP defender.

Yer nah they shouldn't

 

[shibby]

Tempted to go Beams -> Libba to top up the bank, but I'm shit scared he's going to turn it back to 2012 and go berserk after I dump him.

Without that late goal last week Beams would not have cracked 80. Against the Tigers he had 36 touches for only 104.
Projected to Average 100 for the rest of the year which seems about right, after 3 weeks....

Will leave me with $230k to perform some roughies such as Balta->Marshall, or $400k mid def -> Lloyd

 

[Max the great]

I ended up doing:

Steele > Libba
Darling > Boak

Gains me $120k also.

Shocking trades

 

[Lindsay_Gilbee]

Do I trade Selwood? He’s clearly not playing a sc friendly role.

 

[AssassinAndy]

What is the fascination with Rohan Marshall?

Dunno. It's a garbage pick. Kent's just wanna trade I guess.

 

[Glorin]

Darling was definitely gone on Sunday but as the week has moved on I am having 3nd thoughts.
Is it worth keeping him with his run of matches in Perth?

 

[keithrichards]

Brodie Smith to Rozee too sideways?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Brodie Smith to Rozee too sideways?

Absolutely too sideways .....Rozee will likely average less that Smith will .....so it's a cash grab decision, so I wouldn't consider that trade

Sometimes you can't get them all

 

[keithrichards]

Absolutely too sideways .....Rozee will likely average less that Smith will .....so it's a cash grab decision, so I wouldn't consider that trade

Sometimes you can't get them all

Deep down I know.

Given Smith is the biggest issue I have, I really should just hold

 

[Ingall]

Sometimes you can't get them all

True, they're not Pokemon. Think I'm gonna have to let people like Lockhart & Rozee sail on by....

 

[SC fish]

True, they're not Pokemon. Think I'm gonna have to let people like Lockhart & Rozee sail on by....

Same

 

[Wellsy35]

Do I trade Selwood? He’s clearly not playing a sc friendly role.

Only if you can afford a good alternative, as he’s already dropped $40k. Either that, or you wait several weeks until he tons again and gets his price back up.

 

[Glorin]

Potential to end up in top 10 on their lines:
Worpol
Dalhaus
Lambert
J Martin
Z Jones
Rich
Stewart

 

[leng jai]

Still too early to tank overall so this round is the perfect chance to trade the sickest SC player to the most shameful one:

Fyfebot -> Big Stack

Keira to FWD

Faulta -> Gull

Fixes my structure so I have to play one less forward gimp and gives me some scintillating DPP action I'll never use. The last 2 times I went early on a rookie it was Ridley and big Isaac Cumming. Some faults never learn.

Feast your eyes on these endless faultbots Kentlemen:

 

[Andrew Birch]

Next week trades will likely be Atkins/Gibbons>Stack and English>Mumford.

Trying to decide whether Atkins/Gibbons>Wagner/Lockhart is worth it this week. I'm guessing neither of those Melbourne fellas has a whole lot of JS?

Could also consider Hore>Markov/Lockhart, but I think I'd rather use just the one trade this week.

Very little JS mate. Wasted trades

 

[Suma Magic]

Darling was definitely gone on Sunday but as the week has moved on I am having 3nd thoughts.
Is it worth keeping him with his run of matches in Perth?

He might go big this week. Maybe worth keeping him. Depends who you trade him for I suppose.

 

[Moustachio]

Potential to end up in top 10 on their lines:
Worpol
Dalhaus
Lambert
J Martin
Z Jones
Rich
Stewart

No
Yes
No
No
No
No
Maybe

 

[enobrien]

Shocking trades

Sorry mate but where’s the use in this post? At least give a reason to why they are

 

[Keg on legs]

Interested in you splendid kents thoughts. I'm inclined to hold.

Ranked 3.4k
28 trades
22k



Options are:

1) smiff to rozee and junkley to boak / heeney via a roughie maneuver

2) bailey snott to stack and junkley as per above (thinking this might be me next week if junkley stays garbage)

3) hold

4) junkley to dollhouse


As i say, inclined to hold but interested to see what y'all would do.

 

[Keg on legs]

It’s a ******* mess, rookies need fixing, Fyfe, Dusty & Tobias well..

View attachment 651987View attachment 651989View attachment 651988

My initial thoughts are move dusty and punchy.

You cant do those 2 to brouch / sheed and dollhouse can you?

If not-

Dusty to dollhouse (swing him fwd later on)

Punchy to worpel

Or -

Dusty to sheed / brouch

Punchy to worpel

 

[jdwood]

Kind of hoping one of Scott or Atkins is dropped, in which case I may use my first trades on Scott/Atkins and Fyfe to Neale and Stack.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Interested in you splendid kents thoughts. I'm inclined to hold.

Ranked 3.4k
28 trades
22k

View attachment 652137View attachment 652138

Options are:

1) smiff to rozee and junkley to boak / heeney via a roughie maneuver

2) bailey snott to stack and junkley as per above (thinking this might be me next week if junkley stays garbage)

3) hold

4) junkley to dollhouse


As i say, inclined to hold but interested to see what y'all would do.

Dunkley > Marshall
Goldy > Grundy

 

[Knighta21]

My motto this year is to say **** it.
Fyfe > neale
Dunkly > Marshall

 

[ROOINYOU]

Is it worth trading dunkley to darcy moore? With libba and wallis back dunkley is now spending 43% in the midfield, which will obviously limit his scoring. I can see moore going up to around 400k and dunkley possibly dropping to 450k. Is it worth it??

make the trade I say.
...but may be better grabbing Marshall.
heap of cash to be made there, if that's what your looking for.