Trades Round 7 Trades

[Neale4brownlow]

Just wondering where everyone else is sitting at in terms of cash generation? After some preliminary trades I'm at 15.27m plus 244k spare. I'm hoping I'm at least par and can make a late season push to get into the top 10k at least. Sitting at 20k now.

Pretty similar story for me!

Almost identical! $15.50M with 34k spare. Ranked 17k at the moment.

If you haven't got Neale then I think that's probably about par or slightly above average.

With Neale probably ~ $15.7M is Par. But that'll drop off as soon as Neale returns to being mortal.

 

[staffa002]

Double downgrade for me

Starch - Simpson
Taylor - Rankine

Leaves 392k to get rid of some duds next week

Think Rankine will only score around 45-55 so will be on the pine

How did u do starchevich to simpson if u dont mind me asking.

 

[jimmydoves]

Just wondering where everyone else is sitting at in terms of cash generation? After some preliminary trades I'm at 15.27m plus 244k spare. I'm hoping I'm at least par and can make a late season push to get into the top 10k at least. Sitting at 20k now.

I'm sitting at about 15.8k value on field with 34k in the bank and I'm ranked at 325. I'm probably a little over par for those around my rank, think anything above 15.5k you are still in a good position for now.

 

[darooda]

Praying that with all of these injuries some rookie options present themselves this week.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[darooda]

Surely young will be a few weeks. Never a good sign if they are seeing a specialist. Freo also don’t have a good track record managing injuries.






On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[RowellAnderson12]

not sure if echo but Tom morris is reporting that GWS may drop Coniglio for taranto.....

 

[VSTone]

not sure if echo but Tom morris is reporting that GWS may drop Coniglio for taranto.....

surely Ward / others get the chop before Cogs.... sounds like a load of shite to me!

Taranto back is huge for them.

 

[Neale4brownlow]

not sure if echo but Tom morris is reporting that GWS may drop Coniglio for taranto.....

Drop their captain?

Thats a stretch.

But if it were true, you've got to love modern football... play one of your best midfielder out of position up forward every 2nd game, throw heaps of guys at random through the midfield rotation... then act bemused when you're not getting much out of your star midfielder.

Derp de derp.

Far to reactionary looking at stats to axe players. Meters gained yada yada. All of that looks better when you're winning anyway.

 

[Chris99]

Is Mitch Hibberd an option? Seems very solid, but no one seems to be getting him. I might be missing something.

I brought him in last week and straight onto field. No stringer who was taking up majority CBAs. Tackled more last week which was nice. Still only 1 CBA so hopefully he sees an uptick in that department

 

[RowellAnderson12]

The Giants are ‘miles off’ their best. Now they’re considering making a bold selection statement

The Giants are ‘miles off’. Now they could drop their skipper

www.foxsports.com.au

 

[Cotchy9]

Hibberd v Simpson?

 

[Neale4brownlow]

Hibberd, simpson, rankine, butler, McPherson, Stephen.

So many good options. So little trades to get them. So many other leaks to plug at the same time.

Hibberd will probably be a better pick than simpson and yet I simply cannot skip simpson after that 102.

A double down is probably needed next week at the latest to keep the rookies ticking over.

 

[StickyMick]

The Giants are ‘miles off’ their best. Now they’re considering making a bold selection statement

The Giants are ‘miles off’. Now they could drop their skipper

www.foxsports.com.au

Surely a stitch-up. Mind games from the Giants' selectors to get the team fired up. Also, the source...

 

[Flying_as_One1991]

What to do. Shall I get a playing rookie off my field but keep non playing rookies on the bench

or

use two trades to covert non playing rookies to playing rookies for bench coverage

 

[samFFC]

Im left with a choice of Battle, Duggan or Lukosius!!! HELP!! which one

Best midpriced defender preferably under 600K??

Interesting thoughts
Aish? Doedee?

How did u do starchevich to simpson if u dont mind me asking.

DPP probably!!

Surely young will be a few weeks. Never a good sign if they are seeing a specialist. Freo also don’t have a good track record managing injuries.






On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Footy players would always see a specialist but agree he looks out for a while sadly as a freo fan !

Hibberd v Simpson?

Simpson

 

[mezaire]

Just wondering where everyone else is sitting at in terms of cash generation? After some preliminary trades I'm at 15.27m plus 244k spare. I'm hoping I'm at least par and can make a late season push to get into the top 10k at least. Sitting at 20k now.

$15.84m for me with $84k in the bank.
Ranked about 3000th so pretty happy with my foundation

 

[mezaire]

Hibberd, simpson, rankine, butler, McPherson, Stephen.

So many good options. So little trades to get them. So many other leaks to plug at the same time.

Hibberd will probably be a better pick than simpson and yet I simply cannot skip simpson after that 102.

A double down is probably needed next week at the latest to keep the rookies ticking over.

I think people are over rating Simpson and under rating Stephens because of a one score.

Stephens will have longer JS and I honestly think better scoring potential in the long term.

Once Duncan is back Simpson will either get pushed fwd or out, whereas Stephens now really has no one competing for his role.

My prediction ios Simpson will get 1-2 more weeks but Stephens will get most of the season

 

[staffa002]

Do we dare get Brodie Smith again? Englsih never again cause sooo many better rucks but could smith be top6 material.

 

[staffa002]

I think people are over rating Simpson and under rating Stephens because of a one score.

Stephens will have longer JS and I honestly think better scoring potential in the long term.

Once Duncan is back Simpson will either get pushed fwd or out, whereas Stephens now really has no one competing for his role.

My prediction ios Simpson will get 1-2 more weeks but Stephens will get most of the season

Problem is stephens is still 50k more expensive than simpson. If Simpson gets 2 more weeks i can see a 100k rise easily where as with stephens even though he has no competition u r talking about longmire. He will do the opposite of whatever everyones is thinking

 

[staffa002]

Sorry for the tripple post but why is everyone saying simpson will be gone when Duncan came back. Didnt they both start the game together?

 

[kuhni]

Do we dare get Brodie Smith again? Englsih never again cause sooo many better rucks but could smith be top6 material.

I like Brodie, only 2 scores below 70. One an injury one where they got absolutely flogged by Port Adelaide. Just can't decide between him and short, I think B. Smith because you can keep him to the end while Houli will be back in 3 weeks or so impacting short's scores.

 

[JADED]

I like Brodie, only 2 scores below 70. One an injury one where they got absolutely flogged by Port Adelaide. Just can't decide between him and short, I think B. Smith because you can keep him to the end while Houli will be back in 3 weeks or so impacting short's scores.

I doubt Houli will be back in 3.
Newborn child to help with, + mother with Covid 19 in ICU. Richmond would likely have to hub elsewhere next (W.A or S.A for a few) and he didn't want to join the hub.

 

[samFFC]

Just wondering where everyone else is sitting at in terms of cash generation? After some preliminary trades I'm at 15.27m plus 244k spare. I'm hoping I'm at least par and can make a late season push to get into the top 10k at least. Sitting at 20k now.

That’s quite decent taking a look around leagues!

 

[VSTone]

Sorry for the tripple post but why is everyone saying simpson will be gone when Duncan came back. Didnt they both start the game together?

good point... Simpson came in for Jack Steven.

 

[samFFC]

Sorry for the tripple post but why is everyone saying simpson will be gone when Duncan came back. Didnt they both start the game together?

Moreso role and CBA I think