Doss
Ass
- Aug 1, 2011
- 75,222
- 112,368
- AFL Club
- Essendon
We absolutely underperformed in 2018. The year in isolation was a failure. Once you go 2-6 as we did, it takes a minor miracle to get to finals and, with the logjam of teams around the 11-13 win mark, it was probably always going to be a step too far.
In the end BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!! is the one that really nailed it I believe; it was a failure but, hopefully, not a waste in the longer term. There were things that went wrong undoubtedly, and they need to be addressed. For whatever reason, our game plan seems to work far less effectively at the MCG this year compared to last, and that needs addressing for obvious reasons. We still need more class through the midfield, although I'd argue overall the midfield has improved significantly compared to 2017. I have some concerns around what will happen in the backline in a few years with Hooker and Hurley getting no younger.
Obviously, the mismanagement of Daniher was a genuine catastrophe, and we've had a pretty bad run with other injuries once you consider Fantasia, McKernan, Gleeson, Ambrose, Begley and Zaharakis too. Contrast that with the good run we had in 2017.
I get the pessimism people feel; hell, despite what some think, I'd think I'm hardly a blind optimist either. In the end we've all lived the last 15 years as supporters, what with the shitness and the false dawns. In the end, I believe I have seen signs that the group is playing a more sustainable type of football now than in the past; it still needs work, but I believe (hope) that it's closer to what is required now than it was 12 months ago.
But I also think it's hardly ridiculous to feel that there were some genuine positives to come out of the year either, and thinking that is hardly worthy of derision. If we'd had the same injury run in 2018 as 2017, with the same easier draw, but still had the same positional weaknesses as we did in 2017, then I'd be more inclined to have sympathy for those who don't see any positives to come out of the year.
That's not been the case though.
In the end BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!! is the one that really nailed it I believe; it was a failure but, hopefully, not a waste in the longer term. There were things that went wrong undoubtedly, and they need to be addressed. For whatever reason, our game plan seems to work far less effectively at the MCG this year compared to last, and that needs addressing for obvious reasons. We still need more class through the midfield, although I'd argue overall the midfield has improved significantly compared to 2017. I have some concerns around what will happen in the backline in a few years with Hooker and Hurley getting no younger.
Obviously, the mismanagement of Daniher was a genuine catastrophe, and we've had a pretty bad run with other injuries once you consider Fantasia, McKernan, Gleeson, Ambrose, Begley and Zaharakis too. Contrast that with the good run we had in 2017.
I get the pessimism people feel; hell, despite what some think, I'd think I'm hardly a blind optimist either. In the end we've all lived the last 15 years as supporters, what with the shitness and the false dawns. In the end, I believe I have seen signs that the group is playing a more sustainable type of football now than in the past; it still needs work, but I believe (hope) that it's closer to what is required now than it was 12 months ago.
But I also think it's hardly ridiculous to feel that there were some genuine positives to come out of the year either, and thinking that is hardly worthy of derision. If we'd had the same injury run in 2018 as 2017, with the same easier draw, but still had the same positional weaknesses as we did in 2017, then I'd be more inclined to have sympathy for those who don't see any positives to come out of the year.
That's not been the case though.