Mercurial89
Brownlow Medallist
He was an average VFL coach, who oddly also helped out in the midfield. He went to our forward line and had one good year, but then moved to midfield where we've been as inconsistent as ever, he just seems to hang around and we continue to produce the same results.
We've been mediocre for how long and we've had these assistant coaches for how long? Something's gotta give.
You still haven't provided a metric of what you are basing your average comments on.
He was moved into the forward line and got results he was moved away from that line and it regressed and the line he moved into has been improvement this year in defensive running, clearances and contested ball.
I'm not talking about the team being inconsistent look at what he is directly in control of. Each time he has been involved with a section of the ground he has had a positive impact. Probably as he has gotten better as a coach as I agree when he first started I feel he may not have been getting the best results.
I'd have no problem keeping him on in development or as a forward coach. I don't however agree with fans who seem to default throw his name up based purely how long he has been at the club.