El Kapitain
Senior List
Come on Spook this is certainly not the place for rational thought. We all want to hear sensationalist statements like the Weagles will demolish P.A today.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 7 - Pride Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Simon Black
- Thread starter Tenacious Kane
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Come on Spook this is certainly not the place for rational thought. We all want to hear sensationalist statements like the Weagles will demolish P.A today.
Black is the man under a pack of 3 opposition players dishing out pin-point handballs to passing team mates.
Black is the man getting peeled off the ground most of the game and that is the difference. He is fearless in his determination to get the ball and you never see him complain or pull faces at umpires, he just goes about his business.
Black works very hard, pulls the best tagger and takes the hard knocks this game dishes out and he is my pick for the Brownlow.
Black is the man getting peeled off the ground most of the game and that is the difference. He is fearless in his determination to get the ball and you never see him complain or pull faces at umpires, he just goes about his business.
Black works very hard, pulls the best tagger and takes the hard knocks this game dishes out and he is my pick for the Brownlow.
melbournemartin
Brownlow Medallist
The Fab 5 from brisbane would all be up in contention for "best midfielder" spot
along with haselby, judd, riccuito
btw im basing this on this years form
along with haselby, judd, riccuito
btw im basing this on this years form
BulldogMike
Norm Smith Medallist
Black is an absolute champion.
- Jan 13, 2001
- 15,903
- 6,945
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- Man City
If Judd can sustain his current form for another couple of seasons then fair assumption, but not quite yet in the same boat.
- Oct 17, 2003
- 10,792
- 4
- Other Teams
- Banned
- #34
neither Judd nor Black have been tried outside a star midfield group and at the moment i can't see either of them leaving thier clubs, or either of their clubs midfields needing them to carry it buckley style in time soon.
It's a split decision.
It's a split decision.
melbournemartin
Brownlow Medallist
i could see Judd possibly returning to victoria like stevens
probably to collingwood even though i hate to say it
as for black he will be next BFC captain and retire there
probably to collingwood even though i hate to say it
as for black he will be next BFC captain and retire there
is he?
maybe maybe not. How do you measure it?
he's already in their class
i wish every1'd stop giving browny a hard time about this, the ball was there, he got 4 weeks cos he'd been suspended in the GF and for "striking" Hulme (which was an unlucky decision). Sure he deserved to get suspended but he knows he let the team down and is more disappointed than any supporter could be. Although i agree Simon is in contention with Brown, Brown's age and leadership qualities would put him in front of Black at this stage (black for vc prob).
Black: Brownlow, Norm smith, 3 Premierships, 2 B+F, runner up B+F
Judd: Runner-up B+F x1, 3rd B+F x1
Simon Black has the advantage of playing in a brilliant side therefore being able to play in the 3 Premierships.. Not taking away his personal efforts in winning the Norm Smith though.. When Black won the brownlow he had an awesome year and won the B+F Award that year aswell..
Chris Judd was 3rd in the club B+F in his first year in the AFL, and runner up last year behind Ben Cousins, who was runner-up in the Brownlow..
If you want to compare the two players, you're going to have to compare them when judd has played the same anount of seasons that black has..
In all honesty, i think Judd may win 1, if not more brownlow medals, but wont win 3 premierships..
