So who comes in for Hall?

[Swanstar]

As it's looking like Hall is gonna be out of the side much longer than first thought we will need to find a semi permanent replacement - candicates

1) Nick Davis

2) Heath Grundy

3) Brennan - just see what the kid got

No doubt Buchanon will give way for Goodes this week so that's a obvious inclusion.

 

[Sanecow]

Goodes I reckon.

 

[RUNVS]

As it's looking like Hall is gonna be out of the side much longer than first thought who will replace him? - candicates

1) Nick Davis

2) Heath Grundy

3) Brennan - just see what the kid got

No doubt Buchanon will give way for Goodes this week so that's a obvious inclusion.

I'd like to see Brennan given a go in the forward line. He has a good set of hands on him and if he can kick reasonably accurately he could get a couple of goals a game.

 

[grimlock]

1) Injured
2) Yes
3) Not a kid, don't think his future is as a forward.

 

[RUNVS]

3) Not a kid, don't think his future is as a forward.

Id give him a go as even though its only the ACTAFL 9 goals is still very impressive. Also if it doesnt work Roos can just push him futher back and he can play as a loose defender.

 

[EatBig Australia]

I'd like to see Brennan given a go in the forward line. He has a good set of hands on him and if he can kick reasonably accurately he could get a couple of goals a game.

Did he play 2's on the w/e?

 

[kira]

we lack depth to replace anyone...

how about schmitt, he's a decent player

ps. is grundy and brennen really any good? i live in melbourne so i can't see any reserve players, but what i've seen of those two at senior level is disappointing

 

[cefalu_instinct]

Veszpremi

 

[RUNVS]

Veszpremi

He isnt fit enough to play at the AFL level yet. If he was fitter he would already be in the team as he sounds like a gun.

 

[smasher]

The forward line functioned well when BBB was out last time.We had high scores for a start.I'd revert back to then!

 

[legend166]

What's wrong with Davis?

 

[TheMase]

What's wrong with Davis?

Needs a heart transplant.

 

[bedford]

Needs a heart transplant.

Turn it up i couuldn't give a stuff,didn't stop him in the last 1/4 against Geelong in 05

 

[No1SwansFan]

Did he play 2's on the w/e?

Yep sure did. A couple of really good spoils but really I wasnt watching most of the game. He is being groomed as a defender though sohighly doubt he will be bought in to fill a gap in the forward line.
When Hallwas out our forward line (after a rough start) coped. We didnt rush in Grundy or Brennan or any other body like that. Do we reallyneed to bring in either of the above. As has been mentioned else where Spida really could do with a few ressies games to get back into it again then we could bring in Currie he is looking awesome but otherwise I would imagine it would be a straight swap Goodes for Hall. There maybe an opportunity for Barlow to come in too. But he would have to step it up after last season I thought he would be a certain starter this year but he is strugling to be part of the team.

I really want to see Schmidty playing though. I really love watching him play.

 

[bradmanstandguy]

The forward line functioned well when BBB was out last time.We had high scores for a start.I'd revert back to then!

Agreed Smasher. Goodes back in,and revert to line up when Baz was out.
Although i think that now could be the time for Davis to make a decision on
his future and stand tall,if Roosey puts him in the team! Davis on one wing,and
Mickey on the other,with O`keefe and Playfair in centre, could work?

 

[TheMase]

Turn it up i couuldn't give a stuff,didn't stop him in the last 1/4 against Geelong in 05

Mate. I hate to be the one to break this to you. But its 2008.

 

[bedford]

Mate. I hate to be the one to break this to you. But its 2008.

Yes it is,but his heart is no different in size to then,maybe his guts is

 

[TheMase]

Yes it is,but his heart is no different in size to then,maybe his guts is

I give up. I hereby declare I will no longer respond directly to anything by bedford. It is a complete waste of my time.

 

[bedford]

I give up. I hereby declare I will no longer respond directly to anything by bedford. It is a complete waste of my time.

What was wrong with that,have a bit of fun

 

[TheMase]

What was wrong with that,have a bit of fun

Because a good portion of the time, you talk completely nonsense. Sometimes it appears you have not even read what the person put in their post.

 

[SOPH_CROSS]

idd love Schmit Grundy or Matty O

 

[ssfc0203]

idd love Schmit Grundy or Matty O

Yeah, I'm on the Matty O for Debut bandwagon too.

 

[bedford]

Because a good portion of the time, you talk completely nonsense. Sometimes it appears you have not even read what the person put in their post.

Fair enough,but you were the one that said heart transplant,if i said that about McHack what would you say.
I do read the posts and i don't post nonsense,i just cracked the shits with the anti Goodes posts from so called supporters.

 

[MoonSwans]

either a straight swap for Goodesy or bring in Davis.

 

[bedford]

either a straight swap for Goodesy or bring in Davis.

Davo hasn't played the last 2 so i doubt if he will come in