Sorry but Cooney is better than Deledio, Tambling, Murphy and Gibbs put together ...

[Bulldog Joe]

Cooney is certainly justifying his No 1 draft position from his year.
The players that should be compared are Deledio, Griffen, Tambling and Lewis who are midfielders from the same draft.
Tambling is certainly trailing the others at this stage.

 

[Ant_]

I would prefer Cooney than all 4 of those guys.

Am I alone on this?

Cooney is such a gun...

It's amazing what his first ever full preseason without OP can do.

 

[Nikita Blue]

A fantastic player but lets not forget it wasn’t that long ago that there were threads on BF saying Cooney was a hack.

 

[Bigeasy]

tambling is ____ing useless
who the ____ was the clown who decided he was better than buddy!

We ARE talking about a club that in their wisdon have used high draft picks to select players of the calibre of Richard Lounder, Anthony Banik and Adam Fiora so it is not as if it is unexpected?

 

[Zachy45]

Hes one of the top 3 midfielders in the game right now.
Can do anything, kick goals, get the ball, run with it. hard at it.
Ild take him in an instant.

Merge all 4 of those players and you have an quick outside seagull whos built like a stick, scared of a contest and cant kick the ball.

Seagulls are quick, outside, there legs are like sticks, they like a contest over a chip and no the can't kick a ball. your point?

 

[Les Norton]

I would prefer Cooney than all 4 of those guys.

Am I alone on this?

Cooney is such a gun...

You're not alone. Cooney is a star. He was playing senior footy before being drafted at a high level.
He's improving each year. He's a "Charlie" type player

 

[Rex07]

how can you say cooney is better than gibbs??? Gibbsy was a number 1 draft pick

 

[Les Norton]

how can you say cooney is better than gibbs??? Gibbsy was a number 1 draft pick

Nice try....Pay that

 

[Nikita Blue]

how can you say cooney is better than gibbs??? Gibbsy was a number 1 draft pick

Why do we expect young kids to walk right in to sides and be champions - give him time. As said before it wasn't that long ago that people here were rubbishing Cooney.

 

[Zachy45]

You're not alone. Cooney is a star. He was playing senior footy before being drafted at a high level.
He's improving each year. He's a "Charlie" type player

wow you're kidding right? AND he's improving... it's not like he's in his 5th year of AFL football.

Gibbs wouldn't of been playing senior football at a high level before he was drafted would he?

 

[Bigeasy]

Richo, Riewoldt, and Fevola spring to mind as better contested marks.

Back on topic, Cooney is a gun, but take into consideration that he only really became elite this year. Deledio, Tambling, Murphy and Gibbs might just do the same, and make this thread look very stupid.

What about the best of the lot, one Jonathon Brown?

 

[Doza]

You mean Cooney who is in his Fifth year of football and finally showing how good he can be? Yes I agree he is playing fantastic footy, great player. Can't wait until Murphy and Gibbs reach their fifth year of footy.

 

[Rex07]

You mean Cooney who is in his Fifth year of football and finally showing how good he can be? Yes I agree he is playing fantastic footy, great player. Can't wait until Murphy and Gibbs reach their fifth year of footy.

exactly but sad thing for cheaton is Gibbsy will be back home

 

[telsor]

Cooney is certainly justifying his No 1 draft position from his year.
The players that should be compared are Deledio, Griffen, Tambling and Lewis who are midfielders from the same draft.
Tambling is certainly trailing the others at this stage.

Cooney was a year before the other players mentioned.

 

[sunnyTEE]

How funny are all the Carlton supporters in here with penis envy.

Tuck your strings in ladies.

 

[kirbatron]

He's not tripping over his own feet anymore

They have Kreuzer for that now

 

[Zachy45]

How funny are all the Carlton supporters in here with penis envy.

Tuck your strings in ladies.

first of all we have penis envy and then we are ladies?

make your mind up champion

 

[H2F]

Who cares if Cooney is a year older. He struggled with injuries like Hodge did, but you always knew these two were miles ahead of recent no 1 picks.

 

[sunnyTEE]

first of all we have penis envy and then we are ladies?

make your mind up champion

Penis envy in Freudian psychoanalysis refers to the theorized reaction of a girl during her psychosexual development to the realisation that she does not have a penis.

Mind is made up.

Cooney > Carlton

 

[Rex07]

Well I think Gibbs is better and im not a cheaton supporter

 

[Mofra]

Well I think Gibbs is better and im not a cheaton supporter

Supporters generally rate their own players higher - including those soon to join their chosen club

 

[Rex07]

Supporters generally rate their own players higher - including those soon to join their chosen club

exactly. maybe we might even get cooney too

 

[29 4 Brownlow]

Cooney is certainly justifying his No 1 draft position from his year.
The players that should be compared are Deledio, Griffen, Tambling and Lewis who are midfielders from the same draft.
Tambling is certainly trailing the others at this stage.

Cooney absolutley kicks deledio's anus. Maybe if Deledio was more concerned about playing footy, than his f*@#ken hair, he might be better than cooney

 

[themuddy#3]

We ARE talking about a club that in their wisdon have used high draft picks to select players of the calibre of Richard Lounder, Anthony Banik and Adam Fiora so it is not as if it is unexpected?

true, what were they thinking? high draft pick indigenous dont have a great record do they? i mean, wells is a dud, tambling is a dud, dont get me started on raph clarke, x clarke, ashley sampi( i guess you can say that he did alright).they are all top ten picks, of course there is a bloke called buddy who completely rapes my theory, but still.........

 

[Zachy45]

Penis envy in Freudian psychoanalysis refers to the theorized reaction of a girl during her psychosexual development to the realisation that she does not have a penis.

Mind is made up.

Cooney > Carlton

Your copy and paste skills are good champion. You probably should have given credit to Wikipedia though.