Team vs Geelong

Remove this Banner Ad

hotpie

Brownlow Medallist
10k Posts
May 1, 2002
16,707
29
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Collingwood
Minimal changes again

In C Cloke
Out Fanning

Woey Lokan Davies H Shaw amongst the best for Willy, we are building some depth.
 
hotpie said:
Minimal changes again

In C Cloke
Out Fanning

Woey Lokan Davies H Shaw amongst the best for Willy, we are building some depth.


Ideal....

Tho I would like to see Iacobucci get another go but probably the only candidate to be dropped on form would maybe be Tarks? I'm not sure. Its tough to change a winning side.

Ironically, Burns and Licca only had 7 and 10 possessions respectively. Very minimal impact today.
 
In: C.Cloke
Out: D.Fanning

B: J.Clement, S.Prestigiacomo, D.Swan
HB: B.Johnson, S.Wakelin, N.Maxwell
C: J.Rowe, S.O'Bree, A.Didak
HF: C.Egan, T.Cloke, C.Tarrant
F: B.Caracella, S.Rusling, B.Holland
Fo: J.Fraser, P.Licuria, R.Shaw
Int: T.Lockyer, C.Cloke, S.Burns, C.Morrison
Emg: H.Shaw, D.Fanning, S.Woewodin
 

Log in to remove this ad.

lockyer wont be dropped

leave fanning in i reckon, give cam some more time down at Willy

davies looked good yesterday, but no use playing him or yakka and give them only 20-30 minutes worth of game time when they could play full games at Willy

no change for mine
 
sp-mac said:
Any word on Richards?
Yeh would be great to get him back. Better than ******** Cloke
 
shuveradda_41 said:
Eveeryone always seems to forget about Richards..


He's got to get 100% fit and play consistently well in the seconds before he gets anywhere close to consideration
 
Unless you drop Lockyer Rowe or Rusling there's no room for Woey this week
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Let's just hope we never see Lokan in the black and white again.

Haven't seen a replay of the match against the Hawks yet, just highlights.

I see Rusling only had a couple of touches. What's the verdict on his debut?
 
jabso said:
The verdict on Rusling:
Needs more time not many players make stunning debuts.
2 or 3 more games in the side will do him good.

That's a fair point, hard to star if you're on the pine.

So Rusling only saw about a quarter of game time or thereabouts?
 
flagpie said:
That's a fair point, hard to star if you're on the pine.

So Rusling only saw about a quarter of game time or thereabouts?

He played 75 mins out of 121. I would like to see him play for the next 2 games.

Guy Richards is 2 weeks away. MM said so last night on Fox.

We should just rotate all the young guys through. Play them 2 or 3 games in a row and then send them back to Willi.
 
shuveradda_41 said:
Eveeryone always seems to forget about Richards..
yeh everyone saying they want to bring in Yakka and no mention about Richards who is by far our best ruck and a crucial player as he helps fraser have a rest and makes our forward line even better.Leon Davis and Woewodin should come in. Pick anyone I dont really care
 
i bagged mick at the start of the season becuase the guy was gettin very poor efforts from the guys but with regards to his player management he is SPOT on!

t cloke is not playing games as a stand and deliver fwd but able to run up and crumb or present - brilliant he has 10 yrs to be killed in contests at chf

rusling, davies, yakka, and rowe from last yr - all rotated after 2-4 games and exposed, dropped to regain fitness and form

well done mm and balmey

slowly does it unless you have a chriss judd or ball.... but they arent an every year prospect
 
i think we shouldnt make any changes unless theres injuries, fanning that was his best game he looked alot better then he did ages ago. We have won the last 2 games no need to change it just yet let the young guys go.
 
In: Woewodin
Out: Rusling

Fanning gives a contest, give him a go. Cloke seems to do very little when on the ground, same with Tex, both just get in the way. They need plenty of time down at Willy to try and work out what a ruckman/ key position player is meant to do.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Team vs Geelong

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top