The 2013 'Which Player Should I Start On The Field?' Thread (TWPSISOTFT)

[kierez4ever]

I just read though that Hannebery got 120 on the dogs last year! With Boyd out again, I'm not sure whether that means Hannebery will get more opportunities to get stuck in and rackup disposals, or whether Titchell will go huge with half the paddock to run around in since the ball is basically gonna camp in the Dogs back half..

Hmm good point, however I think he will attract the lower tag which he didn't have last year. But then again he could go big but people like ROK/Mitchell/jack steal points from him

 

[kierez4ever]

Jack Grimes (vs GWS) high average recently against them, but pkayed a tagging role last week and Melb board seem to think this will continue

Vs

Stokes (vsNMFC) notoriously hard team to score against and Stokes in bad form

Hard hard pick but I say GWS mainly because they need to win and probably won't tag.but really hope stokes does well

 

[kierez4ever]

Hartlett, Hanley, H. Shaw or Ellis?

Bench Ellis then HH then shaw

 

[Fitzey]

Which two should I start? B.Wilson, Terlich Staker

 

[kierez4ever]

Which two should I start? B.Wilson, Terlich Staker

Bench staker, he has a role that doesn't get a lot of points

 

[Bobby P]

Titchell or Thompson(adelaide)?!

 

[kierez4ever]

Titchell or Thompson(adelaide)?!

Thompson -not In great form

 

[amazingjoshy]

Am i crazy for considering starting Buddy over Riewoldt?

Coming off best game of the season, great record against the Tiges, Roo coming off an injury and a fairly average record against the Lions...

Why does it feel wrong though?

 

[LanLion]

Am i crazy for considering starting Buddy over Riewoldt?

Coming off best game of the season, great record against the Tiges, Roo coming off an injury and a fairly average record against the Lions...

Why does it feel wrong though?

Buddy has a decent record against the Tigers doesn't he? And his tail's up after last week.
I'd be very hesitant to start Riewoldt with floating bone in his foot... He'll probably start well, but I'd be worried he aggravates his injury during the game and gets subbed, or at the very least spends less time on ground.

 

[SloppyJoe]

Riewoldt or Kennedy?

 

[kierez4ever]

Riewoldt or Kennedy?

Riewoldt, gotta trust what he's done so far this year

 

[Willo #6]

Marc Murphy vs Titchell?

Normally I would go Titch no question based on recent form but Murphy's past against Freo is tempting. 117, 105, 113, 92, 130 in his last five against them.

 

[Anzac16]

Redden or Titch

and

Who to bench out of my forward line premiums this week - N.Riewoldt, Bartel, Lewis, SJ, Rockliff, Cloke, JJK.

 

[Mateyman]

Mitchell or JPK?
And should I put Buddy on over any of NRoo, JJK, Rockliffe, Stokes, Bartel, Johnson?

 

[CaptScott]

For the umpteenth time this season

Cotchin (showing some form) v Titch (against WB)

Can't wait to upgrade Cotchin > Beams next week!

 

[kierez4ever]

Marc Murphy vs Titchell?

Normally I would go Titch no question based on recent form but Murphy's past against Freo is tempting. 117, 105, 113, 92, 130 in his last five against them.

Titch, murphy hasnt really been the same since the injury (+ doesnt get many marks/tackles)

Redden or Titch

and

Who to bench out of my forward line premiums this week - N.Riewoldt, Bartel, Lewis, SJ, Rockliff, Cloke, JJK.

Titch

i would bench Lewis even though Nroo is under an 'injury cloud'-gotta back him in after his great year. however if you arent feeling risky/it might be a close game this week then bench him

 

[Butler]

For the umpteenth time this season

Cotchin (showing some form) v Titch (against WB)

Can't wait to upgrade Cotchin > Beams next week!

Interesting that you want to upgrade Cotchin, who was massive towards the end of last season and is coming off scores of 100, 118, 144 and 91 over T.Mitchell who is a rookie that is seeing very little midfield time and is coming off scores of 104, 113, 74 and 112.

 

[RBW_007]

Start Priddis or Titchell?

 

[TheJoker56]

Cloke or Buddy?

 

[kierez4ever]

Start Priddis or Titchell?

Priddis, Mitchell has been playing a lot up forward

 

[kierez4ever]

Cloke or Buddy?

Definitely cloke!

 

[LanLion]

Am seriously considering starting Clisby instead of Gibbs.
Anyone else in this position?
My DEF trade this week was Grimes > Enright.

Gibbs vs. Bulldogs, you'd think he'd rack it up, but my guess is he becomes a KPD on Dalhaus....
Clisby vs. Suns- Clisby been taking the kick-ins instead of Terlich, basically has been doing what Terlich did earlier this year. Suns will never lockdown on him.
Grimes vs Suns- anybody think he'll actually get something decent?

 

[kierez4ever]

Am seriously considering starting Clisby instead of Gibbs.
Anyone else in this position?
My DEF trade this week was Grimes > Enright.

Gibbs vs. Bulldogs, you'd think he'd rack it up, but my guess is he becomes a KPD on Dalhaus....
Clisby vs. Suns- Clisby been taking the kick-ins instead of Terlich, basically has been doing what Terlich did earlier this year. Suns will never lockdown on him.
Grimes vs Suns- anybody think he'll actually get something decent?

Gibbs has had a good history against the doggies so i would still play him and grimes would still be tagging so i wouldnt imagine a massive change

 

[kierez4ever]

Who to bench:
HH, Hanley, Hibbs or Hibberd?
and
Stokes, JJK or Lachie Hansen?
and
Kieren Jack or Trent Cotchin

Cheers in advance

 

[Willo #6]

Macaffer V Staker V Grundy V Rowe