The 2013 'Which Player Should I Start On The Field?' Thread (TWPSISOTFT)

[toptigers]

K.Jack or K.Cornes?

 

[kierez4ever]

K.Jack or K.Cornes?

Jack normally gets tagged and Kornes is the tagger. Geelong have no great regular tagger and kornes will go to fyfe or mundy so pick kieren jack

 

[glasto2010]

Need to play three out of the following: James Kelly, Brock McLean, Rory Sloane (vs Melb), Shaun Grigg (vs GWS)

Thinking Sloane may get tagged like last week and score poorly. Fyfe was tagged by melb last week and scored low also. McLean in hot form, Grigg to potentially rack up numbers vs gws and Kelly for consistency. Thoughts?

 

[kierez4ever]

Need to play three out of the following: James Kelly, Brock McLean, Rory Sloane (vs Melb), Shaun Grigg (vs GWS)

Thinking Sloane may get tagged like last week and score poorly. Fyfe was tagged by melb last week and scored low also. McLean in hot form, Grigg to potentially rack up numbers vs gws and Kelly for consistency. Thoughts?

i would bench kelly the rest are in fine form. mckenzie will go to danger or douglas imo

 

[Pinochio]

A few for UF guys

Backs: Guerra v Joel Corey v Suban
and
Forwards: Motlop v Dahlhaus v Zorko v WhiteX
and
Mids: Hannerbery v Gibson v WhiteX


Need 1 from each group.

Cheers fellas, much appreciated

 

[kierez4ever]

A few for UF guys

Backs: Guerra v Joel Corey v Suban
and
Forwards: Motlop v Dahlhaus v Zorko v WhiteX
and
Mids: Hannerbery v Gibson v WhiteX


Need 1 from each group.

Cheers fellas, much appreciated

Suban (good form)
Moltop (or Dahlhaus)
Hannerbery in a big game

 

[Pinochio]

Suban (good form)
Moltop (or Dahlhaus)
Hannerbery in a big game

cheers for the response!

suban wasnt great last week while guerra has been good last 3 weeks before his late out last week.

also worried about motlop with injury last week and with him being named last on i/c....sub alert???

 

[kierez4ever]

cheers for the response!

suban wasnt great last week while guerra has been good last 3 weeks before his late out last week.

also worried about motlop with injury last week and with him being named last on i/c....sub alert???

10% chance he's been in very good form. Suban has been a revelation since half way through the year.

 

[Clint Beastwood]

hey mate, im thinking about doing JJK-> Wellingham. Just curious why has we been scoring well as for late compared to pre-injury. Has it been a role change and do you think it's sustainable for the last 2 matches?

I think it's sustainable. Missing a few quality mids recently meant Wellers got a good run in the middle and he's been impressive so no reason for him to move. He'll be in there supporting the younger guys I reckon. I think JJK will bounce back this week though (hopefully anyway, my backline's too screwed to change anything!) Sorry about the late reply!

 

[kierez4ever]

I think it's sustainable. Missing a few quality mids recently meant Wellers got a good run in the middle and he's been impressive so no reason for him to move. He'll be in there supporting the younger guys I reckon. I think JJK will bounce back this week though (hopefully anyway, my backline's too screwed to change anything!) Sorry about the late reply!

nah all good cheers for that. I reckon JJK is unlikely to ton it up and Wellingham is more of a safe pick

 

[SureBuddy]

Who to bench this week out of Malceski and Gibbs?

 

[Shaxx Attaxx]

I still have slight hope that Gibbs has potential to score big. Not so much Malceski. Might be bias but it seems people score well in DT when they play us

 

[Rise_up_Stiffy]

ablett vs deledio

 

[kierez4ever]

ablett vs deledio

gotta stick with GAJ no matter what imo

Who to bench this week out of Malceski and Gibbs?

im expecting malceski to get tagged by whitecross (?) so i would say bench him

 

[SureBuddy]

gotta stick with GAJ no matter what imo
im expecting malceski to get tagged by whitecross (?) so i would say bench him

Yea I tend to agree mate. Will be doing that.

 

[SloppyJoe]

I need to bench one out of each of the following:

DEF: Gibbs, Heater or Duffield

FWD: Bartel, Cloke or JJK

Halp!

 

[kierez4ever]

I need to bench one out of each of the following:

DEF: Gibbs, Heater or Duffield

FWD: Bartel, Cloke or JJK

Halp!

bench Duffield and JJK

 

[kierez4ever]

for my draft league:
puopolo or gunston?
neale or wingard?

 

[Crawb]

Grimes or Birchall? Leaning towards Grimes.

Also for potential trading purposes I'm keen to hear who you'd rather start, Cox or Minson? Seems West Coast are content to finish 13th for the easier draw next year plus the decent draft pick. Adelaide have a semi-realistic finals chance, so they'll be pushing for a big margin. Minson however plays Melbourne, and the Dogs will want to make-up for what happened in the year!

 

[kierez4ever]

Grimes or Birchall? Leaning towards Grimes.

Also for potential trading purposes I'm keen to hear who you'd rather start, Cox or Minson? Seems West Coast are content to finish 13th for the easier draw next year plus the decent draft pick. Adelaide have a semi-realistic finals chance, so they'll be pushing for a big margin. Minson however plays Melbourne, and the Dogs will want to make-up for what happened in the year!

yep grimes primarily because of opposition
and yeh minson

 

[Rise_up_Stiffy]

Which MID would you guys bench?

I am completely lost lol. Benching Ablett seems so strange, but I'm pretty confident in all of the others!

 

[SureBuddy]

Which MID would you guys bench?

I am completely lost lol. Benching Ablett seems so strange, but I'm pretty confident in all of the others!

I would bench Lids and not Ablett. He will have a big game for sure. If he wants any chance of winning the brownlow he needs a 3 Voter.

 

[kierez4ever]

Which MID would you guys bench?

I am completely lost lol. Benching Ablett seems so strange, but I'm pretty confident in all of the others!

Have you made your trades this week? I would bench lids instead for ablett fwiw

 

[pauldrc]

Hmmm.....

Who do I start?

WTF??????

 

[Crawb]

Hmmm.....

Who do I start?

WTF??????

Why are you allowed 198 players on the field!