The Carlton list. Who would you take?

[Cursed Cat]

No really, your list sucks balls. Tanking culture has r*ped the club and a mediocre pea heart culture has spread through the place like a cancer. No amount of Micky malthouse will cure it.

Personally I reckon Carlton has a very strong list talent-wise; their inability to live up to their collective potential reminds me a bit of Geelong circa 2006.
It's no doubt been a frustrating period for Carlton fans, perhaps given them a bit of time to reflect upon their clubs past off-field indiscretions.

Anyway, I still rate Kruezer highly, an exceptional talent who has suffered through injury and hasn't been able to get any continuity into his game throughout his career.

 

[Terror Time]

Is Betts on 650k?

 

[Upgrayedd]

Murphy, Tuhoy, Walker, Menzel, Judd, Jamison

lets be serious here, Carltons issue is not talented individuals The list is good if you evaluate them talent-wise, Judd/Murphy/Walker are elite players, It's just that they realllly fall down around the top 10-22 players. They are flying when Murphy/Judd/Walker are all off the chain and Henderson/Waite are providing a target.

They carry some unbelievably soft passengers however. Mitch Robinson is inconsistant as anything, Brock Mclean battles, Gibbs/Kurezer are what i would consider are at crossroads where they were absolute talent but have never pulled in at least half a season of consistant footy. Which Sums up carlton in the past few years. If malthouse could not bring them to play consistant footy he;'s going to take an axe to the list and put them back another few years, Which honestly they need

 

[BC9_]

I don't even know.

 

[Philpie]

would not touch any of their pea hearted players , but would just love some of their crafty and witty pre season slogans , you know the ones , like , smell the stench that we're cooking , they always seem to be on the money with their meaning!

 

[Ancient Tiger]

Is Betts on 650k?

No. Rumored to be asking for it!

 

[Falchoon]

giveus their 2 big blokes down back and even we have a better list.

 

[gardiner stand]

no problem, lucas is all yours

Pick 97 and he's all yours

 

[Bardo State]

Of players they'd consider expendable? I dunno. Maybe Bell on the cheap? Doubt they would get rid of Gibbs or Henderson

 

[gardiner stand]

Of players they'd consider expendable? I dunno. Maybe Bell on the cheap? Doubt they would get rid of Gibbs or Henderson

Bell no probs 3rd or 4th rounder
Henderson no chance

 

[gardiner stand]

Of players they'd consider expendable? I dunno. Maybe Bell on the cheap? Doubt they would get rid of Gibbs or Henderson

Gibbs all yours 3rd or 4th rounder or straight swap for a çouple of used sherrins

 

[JuddsABlue]

Thought Henderson would be getting more love

This is a typical reaction thread. Make this same thread after a good win and the amount of players people want would double at least

Murphy would increase the stocks and depth of every midfield in the comp so the idea that someone wouldn't want him is ridiculous. If it comes down to what you're willing to trade, then we can have this same argument about any team

 

[mike91]

300

Good call, as long as you don't offer him 600K. No way is he worth that much.

 

[Ron The Bear]

Thought Henderson would be getting more love

Most of us have stuck to players who we think Carlton might view as expendable.

 

[ApplecrossWC]

I'd take Dennis Armfield. I really rate him even if others don't. Would love to have him at North.

 

[Runk]

i will give any club our no.1 pick to take hampson & lucas

LOL, it's good to see i'm not the only one who thinks that any team with those two in it are not going to win a GF. Absolute spuds.

 

[Sub_Zero]

would take Murphy, Yarran, Menzel, Henderson

 

[chunkylover53]

The best way to get a Carlton player cheap:

- Put forward cheap contract
- Make up for lack of money by ensuring free haircuts at any given time from the one and only Ciccone Hair Studios!

 

[chunkylover53]

Honest supporters know the truth and you are spot on, our captain is a chicken heart! He's a scared player,went into the heat of the kitchen twice in the past two seasons and got sorted both times by real leaders with heart and balls Dangerfield and Hodge

FWIW you can't knock a bloke for putting his body on the line and coming off second best. I'd like to see you go head-to-head for a ground ball agains those blokes.

But yes he is playing like a frustrated pea heart.

 

[doodles98]

Hampson or Warnock and Yarran would be the best of the likely trades but you won't get much for them tbh.

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Can't think of anyone to be honest... Marc Murphy could slot straight into our midfield I guess for the right price

Edit.. Who does Megan Gale go out with again? I'd like to see her in a hawks jumper... So that guy..

 

[King Of The Hille]

How much would you pay for Betts?

$640 k per season

 

[beatlesmith]

Would take Henderson in a heartbeat but Carlton wouldn't let him go.
Kreuzer would also be nice but again it would be impossible, while the Lycett looks a goer and has very similar attributes.

Apart from them, Gibbs, Garlett and Yarran would be nice (in that order).
I can see the Eagles getting Yarran at the end of next year when his contract expires, and maybe also picking up Lucas if he gets delisted.

 

[Righteo]

Out of interest when did this thread go from picking Carlton's likely rejects at the end of this year to anyone on their list? Do mods think there's no real point in differentiating between them?

 

[1990crow]

Betts. And we won't have to give the Blues anything