News the double deal?

What would you prefer?

  • Kelly, minus our first round pick and second round pick

    Votes: 42 35.0%
  • Martin, but we keep our first round pick and second round pick

    Votes: 62 51.7%
  • Neither, spend money on our own list

    Votes: 16 13.3%

  • Total voters
    120

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
I dont want t feel ripped off when Kelly comes here and get 71% TOG and doesnt hit the 30 possession mark once lol

Our mids have a low TOG because they can't run all day like Kelly. If we get Kelly we're getting a known quantity. Picks are still an unknown. Also, I don't expect us to have pick 3. Probably more 6-9 range
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Lose Goldy, lose pick 3 and then lose pick 12.

That is a **** ****, not a trade.
Pick 3 should borderline get it done.
Kelly for pick 3 only?.. hahaha pull the other one.

Treloar nominated Collingwood and it cost them 2 x first rounders and a late pick

ADAM Treloar is finally a Magpie after Collingwood and Greater Western Sydney concluded their protracted trade negotiations for the young star on Wednesday afternoon. As expected, Collingwood gave up its first-round picks this year (No.7 overall) and next year's first pick for Treloar, while it also gave No.65 to the Giants. In addition to Treloar, the Giants also passed their second-round draft pick this year (No.28 overall) back to the Pies

Get Kelly with pick 3 and give me the Tatts lotto numbers while you're there lads..
 
As expected, Collingwood gave up its first-round picks this year (No.7 overall) and next year's first pick for Treloar, while it also gave No.65 to the Giants. In addition to Treloar, the Giants also passed their second-round draft pick this year (No.28 overall) back to the Pies


Pretty much what has been commonly stated elsewhere. 1st round picks from 2017 & 2018 with a 2nd round pick coming back to North.

Not nearly as extravagant as what you devised. If it's pick 1-3 (2017), then they will probably end up with 19-21 (2017) as well, and that will be it!

You claimed 3, 12 & the loss of Goldy, which is an absurd trade.
 
Our mids have a low TOG because they can't run all day like Kelly. If we get Kelly we're getting a known quantity. Picks are still an unknown. Also, I don't expect us to have pick 3. Probably more 6-9 range
Your talking North here unlike some clubs Scum kilda , Red and Blue draft cheats and Scumwood and dark blue and white CFC draft cheats our club we will never lay down and will fight tough and nails to not finish in the bottom 3 we have pride I think if we finish anywhere between 9 and 13 on the ladder mind you if we want get an early pick it maybe in our best interest to look at a Goldstein to try and trade him to Brisbane since the lions will finish last to get pick one and use our 1st in 2019 to GWS to get kelly then with the Suns maybe throw up a Swallow maybe a Wright, Gibson Daw, Atley to get and early pick as there need experience players
 
Your talking North here unlike some clubs Scum kilda , Red and Blue draft cheats and Scumwood and dark blue and white CFC draft cheats our club we will never lay down and will fight tough and nails to not finish in the bottom 3 we have pride I think if we finish anywhere between 9 and 13 on the ladder mind you if we want get an early pick it maybe in our best interest to look at a Goldstein to try and trade him to Brisbane since the lions will finish last to get pick one and use our 1st in 2019 to GWS to get kelly then with the Suns maybe throw up a Swallow maybe a Wright, Gibson Daw, Atley to get and early pick as there need experience players


Say what?
 
Pretty much what has been commonly stated elsewhere. 1st round picks from 2017 & 2018 with a 2nd round pick coming back to North.

Not nearly as extravagant as what you devised. If it's pick 1-3 (2017), then they will probably end up with 19-21 (2017) as well, and that will be it!

You claimed 3, 12 & the loss of Goldy, which is an absurd trade.
I thought it was Goldy to get pick 12 (from Saints?) that goes to GWS? In short, Goldy is the currency to get pick 12.

Or, put another way, our first 2017 pick + Goldy for Kelly. In short, Goldy over next year's first round pick.
 
Your talking North here unlike some clubs Scum kilda , Red and Blue draft cheats and Scumwood and dark blue and white CFC draft cheats our club we will never lay down and will fight tough and nails to not finish in the bottom 3 we have pride I think if we finish anywhere between 9 and 13 on the ladder mind you if we want get an early pick it maybe in our best interest to look at a Goldstein to try and trade him to Brisbane since the lions will finish last to get pick one and use our 1st in 2019 to GWS to get kelly then with the Suns maybe throw up a Swallow maybe a Wright, Gibson Daw, Atley to get and early pick as there need experience players

If Joyce got pick 1 for Goldy I will chisel the marble statue myself.
 
Pretty much what has been commonly stated elsewhere. 1st round picks from 2017 & 2018 with a 2nd round pick coming back to North.

Not nearly as extravagant as what you devised. If it's pick 1-3 (2017), then they will probably end up with 19-21 (2017) as well, and that will be it!

You claimed 3, 12 & the loss of Goldy, which is an absurd trade.
So we agree it's going to cost us two first rounders for one of the best midfielders in the world right?..

Ok, so if we finish bottom 4 this year - that's one first rounder GWS will jump at, where are you getting you're second from Tef?
 
Kelly for pick 3 only?.. hahaha pull the other one.

Treloar nominated Collingwood and it cost them 2 x first rounders and a late pick

ADAM Treloar is finally a Magpie after Collingwood and Greater Western Sydney concluded their protracted trade negotiations for the young star on Wednesday afternoon. As expected, Collingwood gave up its first-round picks this year (No.7 overall) and next year's first pick for Treloar, while it also gave No.65 to the Giants. In addition to Treloar, the Giants also passed their second-round draft pick this year (No.28 overall) back to the Pies

Get Kelly with pick 3 and give me the Tatts lotto numbers while you're there lads..

If we have pick 2/3, wouldnt we just threaten the PSD to lower the cost?

If a mid is worth a pick in the top 3 + the following years 1st round pick, then what is a Cameron/Kennedy type worth? 3 x 1sts? lol

Danger was had for a song compared to these proposed trades...
 
If we have pick 2/3, wouldnt we just threaten the PSD to lower the cost?

If a mid is worth a pick in the top 3 + the following years 1st round pick, then what is a Cameron/Kennedy type worth? 3 x 1sts? lol

Danger was had for a song compared to these proposed trades...
Yes and yes.

But what if the Aints are still balls deep come trade time?

Everyone is floating 2 x first rounders for Kelly which I agree with but they want to get a potential Brownlow winner this year for what?... two late first rounders???

Lets get out of the fantasy footy world and get real. This bloke is a GUN. GUN. GUN. We will have to spend and what might seem like a pineapple at the time could very well set up a dynasty.

God forbid if he wins the Chas and a Premiership at 22 yrs old start looking for 3 x firsts..
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

So we agree it's going to cost us two first rounders for one of the best midfielders in the world right?..

We agree if North finish with pick 6-10 this year.

Ok, so if we finish bottom 4 this year - that's one first rounder GWS will jump at, where are you getting you're second from Tef?

Pick 1-3 plus pick 19-21 of the 2017 draft. I Posted this above.
 
Yes and yes.

But what if the Aints are still balls deep come trade time?

Everyone is floating 2 x first rounders for Kelly which I agree with but they want to get a potential Brownlow winner this year for what?... two late first rounders???

Lets get out of the fantasy footy world and get real. This bloke is a GUN. GUN. GUN. We will have to spend and what might seem like a pineapple at the time could very well set up a dynasty.

God forbid if he wins the Chas and a Premiership at 22 yrs old start looking for 3 x firsts..

Kelly will decide where he goes, not GWS. Your points are based on the premise of an auction. There will be no auction. You don't seem to be understanding this fact according to your reasoning. Consider this and readjust accordingly.
 
Kelly will decide where he goes, not GWS. Your points are based on the premise of an auction. There will be no auction. You don't seem to be understanding this fact according to your reasoning. Consider this and readjust accordingly.
Pick 1-3 plus pick 19-21 of the 2017 draft. I Posted this above.
I originally said picks 3 and 12.... so you're only 7 measly picks away from agreeing with me.. nice work.
 
Your talking North here unlike some clubs Scum kilda , Red and Blue draft cheats and Scumwood and dark blue and white CFC draft cheats our club we will never lay down and will fight tough and nails to not finish in the bottom 3 we have pride I think if we finish anywhere between 9 and 13 on the ladder mind you if we want get an early pick it maybe in our best interest to look at a Goldstein to try and trade him to Brisbane since the lions will finish last to get pick one and use our 1st in 2019 to GWS to get kelly then with the Suns maybe throw up a Swallow maybe a Wright, Gibson Daw, Atley to get and early pick as there need experience players

iu


Full stops mutha ****er!

Do you use them!
 
Yes and yes.

But what if the Aints are still balls deep come trade time? Wont matter if JK nominates us, StKilda havnt got a hope in hell of getting him in the PSD, so what can they do? Ask JK to go there and he says no. Conversation over.

Everyone is floating 2 x first rounders for Kelly which I agree with but they want to get a potential Brownlow winner this year for what?... two late first rounders??? Potential Chas winner doesnt mean jack shit. 100 mids in the competition could win the Brownlow. JK could do his knee next week, then what do we give up?

Lets get out of the fantasy footy world and get real. This bloke is a GUN. GUN. GUN. We will have to spend and what might seem like a pineapple at the time could very well set up a dynasty. I would of thought 1M a season is spending, but dropping pick 3 and a future 1st is getting on the piss and making it rain.

God forbid if he wins the Chas and a Premiership at 22 yrs old start looking for 3 x firsts.. No player will ever be traded for 3 x 1sts imho

If NM get nominated, id rather us play hardball right up until the bell rings...

GWS got overs for Treloar imho. Buckley needed to win now and they obviously thought they were closer than they obviously are.

What deal did Treloar get btw? 5 x 800k

Geelong got Danger for sfa, Carlton got Docherty for pick 33 lol, Toast got Yeo for pick 28 etc etc

Id give up 2 x 1sts in a heartbeat for Tom Lynch though... KPP>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Mids
 
Unfortunately North doesn't qualify, having bought two premierships in the 90s. Sure, we paid peanuts, but we still bought Carey and Longmire.
But didn't we give up the Krakoeur brothers to get them? That's what the Fault Line told me anyway.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top