The next Melbourne stadium

[Johnny Bananas]

Fair point on electrifying the longer lines, especially the Sydney and Adelaide links that would require co-operation with other states.
Although, would they need to be electrified the whole way? It still would allow for the build over the station, without the fumes, if they ran on electricity only within Melbourne and diesel outside city area.

That's a good point, but it'd require an entirely new fleet. I did a little reading and found NSW are replacing their entire regional fleet with bi-mode multiple units that can do exactly what you describe. In Victoria however, the issue is that VLocity trains only run on diesel, and they're still being manufactured. Given they have a planned usage of 35 years, it seems like the plan is to keep using pure diesel trains until at least 2060. Perhaps a future government could embark on a project to renovate the existing fleet to become bi-mode multiple units, but I'm not sure if that's even technically feasible.

 

[JohnZ]

If the AFL sold Marvel and used the money to develop Gosch's Paddock, this is what could be done:

1. Based on Marvel Stadium's Footprint


2. Based on Kardinia Park's Footprint


So the space is there (just). The stadium could be used as Melbourne's training ground. Keep the MCC and AFL happy by including a member's reserve (either separate or combined).

The stadium at docklands is a roadblock to development of the waterfront. Open it up. You could keep the oval as parkland, or build a park over the railway lines between Bourke and La Trobe.

 

[Saucy]

If the AFL sold Marvel and used the money to develop Gosch's Paddock, this is what could be done:

1. Based on Marvel Stadium's Footprint
View attachment 2107567

2. Based on Kardinia Park's Footprint
View attachment 2107568

So the space is there (just). The stadium could be used as Melbourne's training ground. Keep the MCC and AFL happy by including a member's reserve (either separate or combined).

The stadium at docklands is a roadblock to development of the waterfront. Open it up. You could keep the oval as parkland, or build a park over the railway lines between Bourke and La Trobe.

No way they get rid of that parkland. It's a cool concept. Just won't happen.

The perfect spot was where Eddie proposed a few years ago. Knocking down John Cain Arena.

 

[The Quite Man]

If the AFL sold Marvel and used the money to develop Gosch's Paddock, this is what could be done:

1. Based on Marvel Stadium's Footprint
View attachment 2107567

2. Based on Kardinia Park's Footprint
View attachment 2107568

So the space is there (just). The stadium could be used as Melbourne's training ground. Keep the MCC and AFL happy by including a member's reserve (either separate or combined).

The stadium at docklands is a roadblock to development of the waterfront. Open it up. You could keep the oval as parkland, or build a park over the railway lines between Bourke and La Trobe.

I think the best place for another stadium would be between North Melbourne station & Footscray Rd

start with a 30,000 with with a corporate stand in about a 25% of the ground & single level for the rest of the ground

With planning to increase capacity when Marvels is at the end of its life

Google Maps

Find local businesses, view maps and get driving directions in Google Maps.

www.google.com

 

[JohnZ]

I think the best place for another stadium would be between North Melbourne station & Footscray Rd

start with a 30,000 with with a corporate stand in about a 25% of the ground & single level for the rest of the ground

With planning to increase capacity when Marvels is at the end of its life

Google Maps

Find local businesses, view maps and get driving directions in Google Maps.

www.google.com

Yes, E-Gate would be another good spot for a stadium, but I prefer the Gosch's Paddock location purely because it would centralise all sporting events into the one precinct.

There's also too much complaning about going from Richmond to Spencer St for a game of footy. Imagine if they had to go one stop further to North Melbourne....

 

[HBFlanker]

Matter of time before Collingwood and Richmond move out of their current training bases.

No room to grow and will be left behind the other clubs when it comes to expanding their footprints as a training base.

That will then open up possibilities for either of those venues to be transformed into a 30k seat stadium.

Both in great locations for this to occur.

 

[Rickee]

No way they get rid of that parkland. It's a cool concept. Just won't happen.

The perfect spot was where Eddie proposed a few years ago. Knocking down John Cain Arena.

That's all well and good, but John Cain Arena has tenant clubs that won't exactly be thrilled about being made homeless.

Where do we put the replacement 10,500+ seat indoor sports stadium for the basketball, netball, concerts and Australian Open?

 

[Saucy]

That's all well and good, but John Cain Arena has tenant clubs that won't exactly be thrilled about being made homeless.

Where do we put the replacement 10,500+ seat indoor sports stadium for the basketball, netball, concerts and Australian Open?

Couldn't you do all of those things at RL arena & MC Arena??

I have never understood the point of having the three.

 

[Rickee]

Couldn't you do all of those things at RL arena & MC Arena??

I have never understood the point of having the three.

They all have different capacities: Rod Laver is 15,000, MC is 7.5k and John Cain is 10,500. They are all used during the Australian Open, which is primarily why they were built.

Given the amount of events that are held in Melbourne, three multi purpose indoor venues of various capacities is a real necessity, losing the largest one would mean we probably miss out on concerts, tours and other events that bring in a lot of money.

 

[Saucy]

They all have different capacities: Rod Laver is 15,000, MC is 7.5k and John Cain is 10,500. They are all used during the Australian Open, which is primarily why they were built.

Given the amount of events that are held in Melbourne, three multi purpose indoor venues of various capacities is a real necessity, losing the largest one would mean we probably miss out on concerts, tours and other events that bring in a lot of money.

Is Marvel a multi purpose indoor venue??

Genuine question.

 

[RWB_Threads]

While the MCC argument and proximity to Olympic Park makes sense if it's going to be used for things other than Footy but if the AFL own and operate, let's be real that the main two clubs who would use the smaller stadium will be North and the Bulldogs. Having to get across town for our two H&A games at the G a year is a pain. If the purpose of the stadium is to be a smaller option to Marvel, then it has to be to the west/north-west of the CBD.

I don't think a 3rd stadium stacks up and the redevelopment option is probably the more feasible option.