The OFFICIAL Brownlow Is A Farce thread.

[Groggyk]

Chris Judd.

Brownlow medallist 2010.

WTF?

 

[theboxmike]

Swan Fail

 

[bleeding red and white]

Proof that the Brownlow medal has lost all credibility.

Absolute Joke!

Judd has had a very average year. I could name at least 10 players who've had better seasons.

It's a NOTHING medal now. Swan is very very stiff!

 

[glenn_ox]

 

[Quivorir]

To me it proves that stats mean shit, its your impact on the game. Suck it up girls.

 

[The Octopus]

Re: Proof that the Brownlow medal has lost all credibility.

Absolute Joke!

Judd has had a very average year. I could name at least 10 players who've had better seasons.

It's a NOTHING medal now. Swan is very very stiff!

He is the leagues best inside mid.

 

[SodaPop]

Re: Proof that the Brownlow medal has lost all credibility.

Gazza should've gone back to back if the AFL had've cited Judd with that elbow!

 

[omit]

To me it proves that stats mean shit, its your impact on the game. Suck it up girls.

umpires clearly don't care about hitting a target

 

[raskolnikov]

It was worth it to see the look on Eddie's face.

Now for the Saints to complete the double whammy on Saturday.

 

[King Elvis]

What a ****ing joke.

 

[Quivorir]

umpires clearly don't care about hitting a target

Once again, its your impact on the game, Judd can tear a game open where as im sure Swan can not.

 

[Gift]

When in doubt give the 3 to Chris Judd

 

[strategy]

Deepest sympathy to Swan , Ablett, Boyd, Hayes , Pendles etc , Judd didnt play as good as you

Swan , Ablett , Boyd , Hayes , Pendles and others should feel very angry and robbed of a medal they deserved .
Judd was not as good as you all year .
Good luck for the future

 

[Adrian Shelton]

Only just got home, how many did Cuz get?

 

[Japes]

It was worth it to see the look on Eddie's face.

Indeed. Priceless.

And Judd is a champion of the highest order. Congratulations to him.

 

[im_a_lazy_sod]

Re: Proof that the Brownlow medal has lost all credibility.

I'd rather Judd get it than someone who delibaretly gave someone brain damage

 

[eddiesmith]

To me it proves that stats mean shit, its your impact on the game. Suck it up girls.

If that was true then Swan should have been a lock for 3 votes v Port where he absolutely smashed them especially in the 2nd qtr and single handedly won Collingwood the game

But its obviously nothing to do with impact, how much impact does a player have when his side gets smashed by 50+ points?

 

[gbatman]

won it easily, no one would win a brownlow if all accidental head hits were counted.

 

[pumpter]

Couldn't help thinking about Chris Grant, who missed the Brownlow for accidental contact with Nick Hollands head, while Judd wins after elbowing Pavlich.

 

[TARANTULA]

Total disgrace. Ablett should be celebrating back to back Brownlow's right now

 

[Team Mo']

Re: Proof that the Brownlow medal has lost all credibility.

Judd has had a very average year. I could name at least 10 players who've had better seasons.

Please! Take your BigFooty glasses off and recognise that Judd is a superstar.

Almost carried Carlton to a semi final. Did you watch the Elmination final? That game doesn't count but Juddy was doing that in his first 5 weeks back. You would have to be the most biased and ingorant person to even think that Judd had a "very average" year. The best year in the AFL? Maybe not but really the Brownlow isn't this award.

 

[wce4premiership]

Once again, its your impact on the game, Judd can tear a game open where as im sure Swan can not.

Judd isn't in the top 10 players this year. It's a joke of a result.

 

[pickman]

 

[vanders]

Re: Proof that the Brownlow medal has lost all credibility.

+1. Massive joke.

 

[cats150]

He forgot to thank the umpires