Changaneen
Rubber Man
- Aug 31, 2010
- 7,078
- 4,388
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Port Adelaide Magpies
- Banned
- #76
This.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Tippett's Gone - READ RULES BEFORE POSTING
- Thread starter doodle48
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Just in - Kurt Tippett's house in Adelaide has caught on fire and no emergency services are attending to the call.
Taylor Walker, with singed mullet, was seen leaving the scene. Authorities have said he is refusing to answer questions on the matter
You can't throw this out there without elaboration.
Leadership not inclusive enough?
Leadership too straight and robotic/process driven?
I don't want VB as our Captain next year, but I wouldn't have thought there was anything divisive about our leadership group...
Was never worth the cash being thrown around.. Beats up the undersized and worse defenders/teams.. Main issue he covered was structural, output not much different to a Kosi type..
In the minor round Tippett kicked 25 goals from 11 games against non-finalist teams and 9 goals in 7 games against finalists.. 3 of those 9 goals were on Schoenmakers, same guy he beat up in the Prelim.. That leaves 6 goals from 6 games against the other finalists..
- Banned
- #81
we could giles a KPD and outside midf and fit them all within Tippets salary.
A forward line of Walker/Jenkins/Giles resting/Johnston seems much better in terms of spreading the load.
Tippet leaving could be a blessing...
If it was up to me and tippet asked more than 500k a yr i would of told him to find a new club.
Seriously cant believe the club offered him 800k, isnt that more than Franklin is earning
A forward line of Walker/Jenkins/Giles resting/Johnston seems much better in terms of spreading the load.
Tippet leaving could be a blessing...
If it was up to me and tippet asked more than 500k a yr i would of told him to find a new club.
Seriously cant believe the club offered him 800k, isnt that more than Franklin is earning
I'm really not sure what to make about the whole Tippett saga, other than to say that he has shafted Adelaide and handled it very poorly.
He's been very well treated at Adelaide. He's always been paid far above his worth, and his health and welfare has been put ahead of team this year when he had his bout of concussions.
He came as a basketballer wanting to play footy. and the club has given him the opportunity and assistance to achieve that goal.
He's been offered a contract by the club far in excess of his real worth IMO, and he's treated that and the club with disdain.
He has pretended for weeks to be deliberating his future, while deliberately dropping a re-assuring comment here and there to keep the anxiety of supporters and pressure by the club at bay.
Whether AFGM is right or not about the contract signed with the Gold Coast last year, he's right about one thing - he never intended to be with us next year.
He's done a Cunston on us.
What we don't know yet is what he intends to do in the future.
Is he genuinely home-sick and going home to Qld to either Gold Coast or Brisbane?
Is he going to be a football prostitute and hawk his services around to the highest user pays?
He will get his wish, by deserting the AFL club that has nurtured him as well as deserting his teammates that have supported him, and play wherever he wants to next year for a big fat pay packet.
I can only hope that there is a some shred of decency left in him to ensure that he at least goes to a club that won't completely screw the Crows and that we will get more than a half eaten pasty for his loss.
i don't have a particularly high opinion of Tippett at the moment. It's probably only a question of how low it can get.
He's been very well treated at Adelaide. He's always been paid far above his worth, and his health and welfare has been put ahead of team this year when he had his bout of concussions.
He came as a basketballer wanting to play footy. and the club has given him the opportunity and assistance to achieve that goal.
He's been offered a contract by the club far in excess of his real worth IMO, and he's treated that and the club with disdain.
He has pretended for weeks to be deliberating his future, while deliberately dropping a re-assuring comment here and there to keep the anxiety of supporters and pressure by the club at bay.
Whether AFGM is right or not about the contract signed with the Gold Coast last year, he's right about one thing - he never intended to be with us next year.
He's done a Cunston on us.
What we don't know yet is what he intends to do in the future.
Is he genuinely home-sick and going home to Qld to either Gold Coast or Brisbane?
Is he going to be a football prostitute and hawk his services around to the highest user pays?
He will get his wish, by deserting the AFL club that has nurtured him as well as deserting his teammates that have supported him, and play wherever he wants to next year for a big fat pay packet.
I can only hope that there is a some shred of decency left in him to ensure that he at least goes to a club that won't completely screw the Crows and that we will get more than a half eaten pasty for his loss.
i don't have a particularly high opinion of Tippett at the moment. It's probably only a question of how low it can get.
SilverCrow
Rookie
- Apr 24, 2009
- 46
- 24
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Thank you for your service to the club Kurt.
I have mixed feelings on this one and I am glad this charade has finally come to an end. At the moment I am prepared to give him the benefit of the doubt that this was a hard decision.
If he leave to go HOME, I will be fine with the decision as he has given 100+ games of valuable service to the AFC. I would be staggered if he ends up anywhere else considering the year the Crows have had and the perception we will improve even further next year. Where he ends up will pretty much determine if it really was the go home factor or if it was only ever about the money.
I just hope he does the right thing by the AFC like they have done for him during his time at the club but considering how he has handled this whole affair, I won’t be holding out much hope.
I have mixed feelings on this one and I am glad this charade has finally come to an end. At the moment I am prepared to give him the benefit of the doubt that this was a hard decision.
If he leave to go HOME, I will be fine with the decision as he has given 100+ games of valuable service to the AFC. I would be staggered if he ends up anywhere else considering the year the Crows have had and the perception we will improve even further next year. Where he ends up will pretty much determine if it really was the go home factor or if it was only ever about the money.
I just hope he does the right thing by the AFC like they have done for him during his time at the club but considering how he has handled this whole affair, I won’t be holding out much hope.
I rate Jenkins, and I wouldn't be chasing a player to replace Kurt; Jenkins or SMcK are both capable of doing the job.
But I don't think either of them are as good as Kurt was.
He's a monster physically, great endurance and agility - and an elite contested mark.
Our game plan is built around having those talls options to kick long and forward to.
We'll be weakened by this, but I think between those two, we can minimise the hurt.
- Jun 10, 2009
- 29,795
- 44,888
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Panthers, GWV Rebels Beaufort Crows
If he goes anywhere but Qld I will have lost all respect for him, this would signify all the talk of him wanting to go home for lifestyle and family reasons was a total load of bullshit and he's nothing but a money hungry Knut!!
As for preferring Sydney or Melbourne over Adelaide is just bullshit, fair enough the Qld climate is great but once you get out of the major cities the population is full of rednecks.
If he ends up at the Pies I can see Sando and Buckley's close friendship coming under strain for sure, Jett Buckley may need to find another godfather!!
As for preferring Sydney or Melbourne over Adelaide is just bullshit, fair enough the Qld climate is great but once you get out of the major cities the population is full of rednecks.
If he ends up at the Pies I can see Sando and Buckley's close friendship coming under strain for sure, Jett Buckley may need to find another godfather!!
And that reason is?
Don't think I have posted regarding Tippett's future throughout the 250 or so pages of that thread, but will say now that I to agree with Faith's comment here.
I am also with those who are keen to see how Jenkins steps up with his various abilities.
We do need a standby number one ruck in case Jacobs goes down, but we do not need to waste big draft picks on such a contingency.
Big Mac (Smack's) time to really impress is here.
We need to make the most of whatever compensation we get. Best player avaiable IMO. We can build that elite team.
Because Sando is that unprofessional...
Good. Personally glad to see the back of the selfish twat.
Now the AFC must take control and send him where we get the best return. There is plenty of interest, so getting adequate compo shouldn't be an issue, provided Tippet isnt just out to screw us. If he says Collingwood and they offer nothing, we say GC, Brisbane or GWS via the PSD. We cant allow this spoilt brat to tell us what is going to happen.
Now the AFC must take control and send him where we get the best return. There is plenty of interest, so getting adequate compo shouldn't be an issue, provided Tippet isnt just out to screw us. If he says Collingwood and they offer nothing, we say GC, Brisbane or GWS via the PSD. We cant allow this spoilt brat to tell us what is going to happen.
We've got SMcK and Jenkins; both are a better option than Lynch.
I'm convinced Johnson has what it takes to be the other key forward with Walker. Both beautiful kicks as well.
Of course, that will change the structure as Johnson and Walker would be stay at home forwards so Jenkins/McKernan would need to play the 2nd Ruck and other roles pinch hitting forward or back.
Hopefully trade with Gold Coast for their top pick and we land Toumpas.
Of course, that will change the structure as Johnson and Walker would be stay at home forwards so Jenkins/McKernan would need to play the 2nd Ruck and other roles pinch hitting forward or back.
Hopefully trade with Gold Coast for their top pick and we land Toumpas.
Wouldn't say that bit is completely accurate, Buddy has kicked quite a few clutch ones (remember back to 2008 final against them
), it's just the easy ones he somehow shanks. I think Smack/Johnston/Jenkins can cover for Kurt but I'd still like us to get a ruck/forward to increase competition for that role. Pre-season will be a big one with a starting 18 spot there for the taking. Lets see who really wants it.
- Banned
- #93
At 5.48 am tommorrow.
Life goes on....
I promise you the Adelaide Oval won't look like that tomorrow!
Iva Bigun
Brownlow Medallist
Force us how exactly?
M
Agree that JJ is viable but not so sure about Smack????? Will also take 2-3 years for both of them to get to their prime/peak.
Also, if we got Lynch for 2 years (he is nearly 30) he would be a ready made replacement immediately while the two other options got some more experience.
33 goals this year for Weagles and he would be a big strong marking option to complement Tex. Would not cost much to get him on a short term contract IMO.
Worth a crack at him.
Agree that JJ is viable but not so sure about Smack????? Will also take 2-3 years for both of them to get to their prime/peak.
Also, if we got Lynch for 2 years (he is nearly 30) he would be a ready made replacement immediately while the two other options got some more experience.
33 goals this year for Weagles and he would be a big strong marking option to complement Tex. Would not cost much to get him on a short term contract IMO.
Worth a crack at him.
Sydney 900k to 1m what a joke.
But sounds his most likely destination according to SEN.
Has been for two months.
But sounds his most likely destination according to SEN.
Has been for two months.
A bidding war. At this stage Tippett hasn't named a preferred destination. Carlton, Collingwood, Sydney, Brisbane and Gold Coast have all shown interest in getting Tippett. With no desired destination other than not being in Adelaide, he should be happy to land at any of the listed clubs as all have offered him a fair bit of money. Therefore, he will hopefully land at the club that offers us the best deal.
No thanks.
jenny61_99
Premium Platinum
Something we learned about losing kpp before, bock left - Davis rose to the fore, Davis left, talia blossomed and won the rising star award. Gunston left, stiffy moved forward, wright stood up, porps got better as the year went on. There will be a tomorrow, and there will be a replacement for Tippett. We need players that want to play for us. The "buy-in" mantra from sydney should be the one we adopt and demand of all of our players now.
- Status
Similar threads
- Poll
