Tippett's Gone - READ RULES BEFORE POSTING

[Johnny Rutten]

Really hope it's 11 and 22 we could realistically end up with Kennedy/Mayes then as well

Doubt Mayes would drop to 11, but never know.

 

[amer]

If the proposed trade that SEN is reporting goes through then there will be a lot of people on this board eating their words. It would be the best possible outcome given the situation.

It really would be, and I will be the first to apologise.

 

[King Elvis]

This whole Parker/Carlton thing is purely rumour at this stage. I wouldn't be doing the Gangnam just yet.

Did lulz

 

[Cap]

If the proposed trade that SEN is reporting goes through then there will be a lot of people on this board eating their words. It would be the best possible outcome given the situation.

what is the SEN proposed trade?

 

[cmndstab]

It's more that you're underrating McKernan and underestimating the importance of a strong, consistent structure in terms of spine.

Should I assume that you don't see a role for Jenkins in our future?

 

[hey shorty]

Doubt Mayes would drop to 11, but never know.

Wont get past Port IMO. More likely to end up with Menzel which wouldnt be so bad.

 

[Heafy83]

This whole Parker/Carlton thing is purely rumour at this stage. I wouldn't be doing the Gangnam just yet.

Thanks now I have the bloody song stuck in my head again.

 

[rodkimble]

Really hope it's 11 and 22 we could realistically end up with Kennedy/Mayes then as well

We would surely have to go for stringer and Jaksch with those picks

 

[Crow-eater]

The Swans presser may not even involve the trade. It could be Jude Bolton's retirement?

 

[amer]

Should I assume that you don't see a role for Jenkins in our future?

I'm saying I don't see Jenkins as a natural footballer because he is not. He hasn't had the time in the game. If you think he's just going to slot in and effectively blanket the CHF/FF issue you're completely kidding yourself.

We'd effectively be Walker and nothing else next season, and an injury away from structural disaster, total inability to kick a score. We MUST keep McKernan, and he WILL surpass your expectations quite comfortably. Somewhat miffed that so many can't see the ability in him.

 

[Crow-eater]

what is the SEN proposed trade?

Carlton get Parker
Sydney get Tippett
Adelaide get 11 and 22

 

[DieHardCrow]

Wont get past Port IMO. More likely to end up with Menzel which wouldnt be so bad.

Id think menZel with his knees. Might slide down a bit think its Kennedy at 11 Menzel at 19 in an ideal world

 

[Heafy83]

what is the SEN proposed trade?

Adelaide: 11 & 22
Carlton: Parker & White
Sydney: Tippett

That's the essential gist of it.

 

[Johnny Rutten]

Wont get past Port IMO. More likely to end up with Menzel which wouldnt be so bad.

Of the SA kids, Menzel, Kennedy and Colquhoun could all be a chance if we had 11 & 23.

 

[Heafy83]

Id think menZel with his knees. Might slide down a bit think its Kennedy at 11 Menzel at 19 in an ideal world

I don't think thats going to be as much as a problem now he got the tick from that world renown surgeon

 

[Danoz]

Ontrade 23 to Cats for GHS?

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

Id think menZel with his knees. Might slide down a bit think its Kennedy at 11 Menzel at 19 in an ideal world

Unless Grundy slides to 11

 

[matty p]

Of the SA kids, Menzel, Kennedy and Colquhoun could all be a chance if we had 11 & 23.

Wouldn't we just love to get all three of them with 11, 19 and 23. Would be a dream outcome.

 

[Johnny Rutten]

Adelaide: 11 & 22
Carlton: Parker & White
Sydney: Tippett

That's the essential gist of it.

If we all pray hard enough, it may happen??

 

[DieHardCrow]

No

Unless Grundy slides to 11

No chance in hell Grundy gets through to 11 as much as I'd like to dream

 

[Ticktak]

If we get rid of McKernan it will come back to bite us!

 

[Stiffy_18]

I hope Smack isn't involved, but I like the sound of the rest of it. Would certainly leave some very red faces in here if this eventuates.

Its is still not a "fair" deal but certainly better than the pick 23 and White.

11 and 23 is probably towards the bottom of what we should be accepting.

 

[Johnny Rutten]

Its is still not a "fair" deal but certainly better than the pick 23 and White.

11 and 23 is probably towards the bottom of what we should be accepting.

It's a bit like thinking you were going to date the ugliest sister (23/White), ended up with the ok-looking sister (11/23), but missed out on the hot sister (11/Rohan). Jesus, I sound like I'm 12.

 

[Mego Red]

11 and 23 is about right.

For an out of contract player with other issues, it's pretty fair.

 

[hellboy1975]

Why would Carlton swap 11 for Parker?