-
LIVE: Geelong v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Cats at 54% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
top 10 from the APS this year?
- Thread starter A_Kerr
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- May 22, 2007
- 125
- 2
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Barcelona, Melbourne Storm
- Banned
- #2
Based on performance, not reputation:
1. Sanfillipo - Classy middfielder who stands out in the Xavs midfield
2. Sargent - Averaging over 30 possessions im guessing and incredibly hard at it
3. Sundberg - Quite classy and gets alot of the football consistently, quite selfish though...
4. Sandilands - Very versatile and so important to CGS, great player...
5. Yamen - Has kicked huge bag of goals over the season, very selfish though...
6. Noonan - has beaten probly all of his opponents, great CHB (probably APS best back atm)
7. Shaw - Is MGS's best player by a long way, probably the only one doing anything...
8. Lloyd - Has killed it week in week out, no defensive running and kicks alot of goals as midfielder
9. Vickery - I know he is injured, but he has dominated the ruck and wins alot of the ball around the ground, great hands
10. Tom Lynch - Versatile, had big jobs and won most, when pushes forward plays really well too...
1. Sanfillipo - Classy middfielder who stands out in the Xavs midfield
2. Sargent - Averaging over 30 possessions im guessing and incredibly hard at it
3. Sundberg - Quite classy and gets alot of the football consistently, quite selfish though...
4. Sandilands - Very versatile and so important to CGS, great player...
5. Yamen - Has kicked huge bag of goals over the season, very selfish though...
6. Noonan - has beaten probly all of his opponents, great CHB (probably APS best back atm)
7. Shaw - Is MGS's best player by a long way, probably the only one doing anything...
8. Lloyd - Has killed it week in week out, no defensive running and kicks alot of goals as midfielder
9. Vickery - I know he is injured, but he has dominated the ruck and wins alot of the ball around the ground, great hands
10. Tom Lynch - Versatile, had big jobs and won most, when pushes forward plays really well too...
i think your being very harsh on sundberg. how is he selfish. and when cgs played against xavier sundberg absolutely killed sanfillipo, and i mean abo****ely destroyed him. in my opinon id say Sargent is the best player so far with him seeming like hes dominated all games. he looked like an extremely good leader on the field as wel. what about o'keefe? hows he been going in APS? but besides those questions i think thats a very good attempt at a top ten.
- May 22, 2007
- 125
- 2
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Barcelona, Melbourne Storm
- Banned
- #4
Sanfillipo was tagged by A.Jackson in the CGS vs Xav game and also Sundberg i have seen him play a few games he often tries to take on players when he could easily handball to someone in a better position, great payer though...O'Keefe has been playing well but got beaten on the weekend which made me just leave him out, decent player though
cgssinger90
Draftee
- Mar 15, 2006
- 17
- 0
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Manchester United
1. Junior Rioli
2.Lachie Henderson
3.Hugh Sandilands
4. Sanfillipo
5. Lynch
6. Sundberg
7.Curnow
8. Martin
9. McCarthy
10. Vickery
Sargent? you have got to be joking
2.Lachie Henderson
3.Hugh Sandilands
4. Sanfillipo
5. Lynch
6. Sundberg
7.Curnow
8. Martin
9. McCarthy
10. Vickery
Sargent? you have got to be joking
highflyer123
Debutant
- Apr 2, 2007
- 80
- 0
- AFL Club
- Essendon
If you read the thread title, its the top 10 from the APS this year, seeing as though Henderson and McCarthy have been injured this year, how could they be in the top 10? Sargent probably would be in the top 10 based on form this year.. Not such a supid comment
sundberg also was tagged that game in the xavier game! and this top 10 is based on reputatoin not performance...
- May 22, 2007
- 125
- 2
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Barcelona, Melbourne Storm
- Banned
- #9
Singer you have no idea, you just put players in by reputation..
If so would be
Henderson
Vickery
A.Smith
Top 3 as they are All-Aus
If so would be
Henderson
Vickery
A.Smith
Top 3 as they are All-Aus
This rubbish you cant name top 10 without seeing all teams often
I wouldnt rate sanfillipo in my top twenty in the 2 games i have seen him play . hardly a no 1 player. but xavs in thier bubble what else .
No mention of
watts best player in all games except the last ,capt of wesley is a great player .
spot on about sunberg and yamen is worse might kick goals but the points they kick should have been goals had they passed it off . thats why caulfield will lose to hailebury and maybe stkevins have plenty of talent no team work.
peter19
Rookie
i think 'i love my left foot' did it very well sargent deserves to be second.
but what staggers me is that he wasnt listed in the TAC side for sandringham and he is NO. 2 in the APS just shows how TAC is a joke
but what staggers me is that he wasnt listed in the TAC side for sandringham and he is NO. 2 in the APS just shows how TAC is a joke
- Oct 17, 2006
- 1,142
- 1
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Banned
- #14
Wesley have a few who could push such as Croft and Causer
You can't say that Ash Smtih is better than Junior Rioli. He is looking like a top 20 pick in this years draft. Was stiff to miss all-aus last year at the 18s carnival when he was bottom aged. Far better than Smith who will go nowhere near top 20 in next years draft.
- May 22, 2007
- 125
- 2
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Barcelona, Melbourne Storm
- Banned
- #17
Yeah im just saying by reputation in general you would say that because he is AIS...
cement mixer
Rookie
sam lees should at least be considered, he is (besides sanfillipo) the most legitimate chance of a xavier draft pick in the next two years, EMPHASISED by his b.o.g performance against Skevs
hmmm.... just a tad bias towards sundberg there pal. Sanfilipo got nearly 30 touches against CGS. Sam Lees would have to go very close
- Mar 29, 2005
- 8,407
- 944
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Bushrangers, Liverpool, Celtics
And Sundberg got 42 pos and 2 goals... keep dreaming Sanfillipo lovers.... Sundberg = Judd the 2nd
I never said sundberg didntplay well. my point is that u cant say sanfilipo got destroyed when he got that many touches. as much of an impact that sundberg had some of his influence was counteracted by sanfilipo because he didnt man up
jimbojones90
Rookie
can i have an updated current aps top 10 please
1. Sanfillipo
2. Sundberg
3. Sandilands
4. Shaw
5. Yaman
6. O'keefe
7. Lloyd
8. Sargent
9. Ziebel
10. Riloi
obviously very caulfield orientated casue i have watched them the most but as people have been saying on this forum, cualfield are a team of champions, not a champion team
2. Sundberg
3. Sandilands
4. Shaw
5. Yaman
6. O'keefe
7. Lloyd
8. Sargent
9. Ziebel
10. Riloi
obviously very caulfield orientated casue i have watched them the most but as people have been saying on this forum, cualfield are a team of champions, not a champion team
This is done by consistant performance, not reputation
1. Sunberg
2. Sanfillipo
3. Sargent
4. Sandilands
5. O'Keefe
6. Croft
7. Yamen
8. Smith
9. Lloyd
10. Martin
Obviosuly Rioli, Henderson, Lynch and VIckery would be in there but Riolo and Henderson have played mimimal games and Lynch/Vickery out for the year
1. Sunberg
2. Sanfillipo
3. Sargent
4. Sandilands
5. O'Keefe
6. Croft
7. Yamen
8. Smith
9. Lloyd
10. Martin
Obviosuly Rioli, Henderson, Lynch and VIckery would be in there but Riolo and Henderson have played mimimal games and Lynch/Vickery out for the year
